A Site for Photographers by Photographers

Community > Forums > Canon EOS > 5d MKII & Canon 12-24mm Lens

5d MKII & Canon 12-24mm Lens

rachael o , Feb 19, 2010; 02:29 p.m.

So I finally got my 5D MKII and have discovered that I cannot use my Canon 12-24mm Lens with it...I have looked all around and I can't find a solution (converter of sorts?)...but thought I would ask the wise community before I sold it...is there something I am missing or is it absolutely incompatible?


    1   |   2     Next    Last

Chris Clarke , Feb 19, 2010; 02:46 p.m.

I didn't know Canon made such a focal length. I think you are talking about a Tokina or Sigma lens, both of which are made for a Canon EF-S mount.
The Canon EF-S 10-22 lens is obviously an EF-S lens and won't physically fit on a FF camera. Only EF mount lenses will fit the 5D2. I have the 16-35 II which is wider on a FF than a 12-24 is on a 1.6 crop.
There are plenty of options on FF for a new lens to fill the gap left by your 12-24.

Joseph Wisniewski , Feb 19, 2010; 02:53 p.m.

A 1.4x teleconverter is usually sufficient to get a lens like that running. I believe the Kenko PRO-300 1.4x will work. But seriously, the optical quality won't be that great, and if you sell the 12-24, combine that money with the money you'd have spent on a good 1.4x TC, you shoudl be able to get a decent FF wide.

Jon Ess , Feb 19, 2010; 03:18 p.m.

you must be referring to a tokina 12-24 f/4, which won't work on full frame cameras, or a sigma 12-24 f/4.5-5.6 which is a full frame lens.

Steven F , Feb 19, 2010; 03:39 p.m.

Rachael, we need to know if you have a Sigma or Tokina lens and what the problem is. Will it attach to the body, is the camera posting an error code, or if there is a problem with the image post an image. Otherwise we are just guessing.

Bob Atkins , Feb 19, 2010; 03:51 p.m.

The Sigma 12-24 should work fine and the Tokina 12-24 should mount and work OK but will severely vignette.

The Sigma 12-24 has full frame coverage. It's not a crop-sensor lens. I suppose there could be software incompatibility with the 5D MkII, since older Sigma lenses have had a long history of requiring rechipping when used on new EOS bodies.

The only superwide zoom you can't mount on a 5D is the Canon EF-S 10-22. Tokina, Tamron and Sigma crop sensor lenses will all mount fine. They'll just vignette badly.

Nathan Gardner , Feb 19, 2010; 05:53 p.m.

there is no Canon 12-24mm. I'd sell whatever lens it is and get the Canon 16-35mm or 17-40mm, both great lenses and the latter more affordable.

M. P. , Feb 19, 2010; 06:46 p.m.

12 * 1.6= 19.2 mm So yes What Nathan said is correct. If the 12-24 is designed whether EFS or not for a crop sensor camera it will still not be as wide as a 16-35 or 17-40 on a 5D Mark II. I personally use the Canon 17-40 F4L on my 5D2 and I really enjoy that lens. I am spoiled now since I have been shoot L-series lenses 85 1.2L, 17-40 F4L, 24-70 F2.8L. i would definetely recommend selling what ever lens that is and upgrading to the one of teh two L-serices lenses recommended above.

Nathan Gardner , Feb 19, 2010; 08:20 p.m.

I don't believe it will be a 19mm on the 5D MkII. 12mm is 12mm. You have to multiply by the crop factor when using a crop camera, but the 5D MkII is not a crop camera so there is no conversion needed, it will still look like a 12mm. However, the quality of this lens will not be up to par with the 16-35mm L and 17-40mm L.

Steve Porte , Feb 20, 2010; 01:14 a.m.

FWIW, I tried the Sigma 12-24 on a 1Ds3 body. It mounted and functioned normally. I didn't buy it, however, because the IQ was a bit weak, especially at the lower end. Didn't seem worth it just to go wider than my 17-40L, which produces great results and is price competitive with the Sigma.

    1   |   2     Next    Last

Back to top

Notify me of Responses