A Site for Photographers by Photographers

Home > Equipment > Canon > Canon 30D Review - Part II

Most Popular Lenses

Moms, Dads & Grads Gift Guide Read More

Moms, Dads & Grads Gift Guide

Happy Mother's Day! Happy Father's Day! Happy Graduation! Photo.net has great photography gift ideas for the Mom, Dad, or Grad in your life. Shop for camera bags, lenses, DSLRs, and more...

Latest Equipment Articles

Sony NEX-F3 Preview Read More

Sony NEX-F3 Preview

Bob Atkins previews Sony's newest NEX body the F3

Latest Learning Articles

Concert and Live Music Photography: Clubs, Bars, and Small Venues Read More

Concert and Live Music Photography: Clubs, Bars, and Small Venues

Clubs, bars, and small venues are the places where most concert and live music photographers get their start, the reason being that there are fewer restrictions since the performers are less likely to...


Canon 30D Review - Part II

by Bob Atkins, 2006


Startup Timing

Canon say that they have reduced the startup time from 0.2 seconds (on the Canon 20D) to 0.15 seconds on the EOS 30D. Both cameras are essentially "instant on" as far as a user is concerned. I couldn't tell the difference. The camera always has shutter release priority, so whatever mode you're in (menu, image review etc.), the camera switches to shooting mode and  is ready to shoot as soon as you depress the shutter release.

Buffer Size and Continuous Shooting Rate

The EOS 30D has two continuous shooting rates, 3 fps and 5fps (the EOS 20D only has 5fps) and a larger image buffer than the EOS 20D. The Canon specs say that the EOS 30D buffer will hold 11 RAW images or 30 full size, low compression, JPEGs. The equivalent specification for the EOS 20D buffer is 6 RAW or 23 JPEGs.

In testing the continuous shooting performance I shot identical scenes with identical settings using both the EOS 20D and EOS 30D using a Sandisk Ultra II 1GB CF card.  AF was set to one shot, ISO to 200 and shutter speed to 1/250s. The size of the RAW file was 6.75MB.

The EOS 30D at 5fps  shot 12 RAW frames before the buffer filled. The average spacing between frames of 0.208 seconds corresponding to just over 4.8 fps. At 3fps it took 14 frames to fill the buffer. The average frame spacing was 0.337 seconds, corresponding to a frame rate of 2.96 fps. At both 3 fps and 5 fps the frame rate eventually drops to an average of about 1 frame every 1.17 seconds if the shutter release is held down.

In comparison, the 20D shot 6 frames before filling the buffer. The average frame spacing was 0.209 seconds, corresponding to just over 4.8 fps. It then shot 3 frames with a spacing of 0.74 seconds before continuing on at an average frame spacing of around 1.25 seconds.

The audio tracings below show the relative timing of the three tests.  With the 30D there's a slight pause before the system settles down to 1.17 seconds between frame. At 5fps there was one frame about 0.85 seconds after the buffer filled, then a gap of 1.8 seconds, then an average of 1.17 seconds between frames. At 3fps there was a gap of about 1.8 seconds then an average of 1.17 seconds between frames. The 20D is slightly different, shooting 3 frames with a 0.74 second spacing after the buffer filled, then slowing down to an average of about 1 frame every 1.25 seconds.

EOS 30D frmae rate

Since JPEG files are smaller than RAW files, you can store more in the buffer. Canon specs state that the buffer should hold about 30 JPEGs. At 5fps I managed to take 38 large/fine JPEG frames before the buffer filled. The difference is probably due to the fact that the scene I used for testing under the conditions I used gave a 2.75MB file. This is probably slightly smaller then the average large/fine JPEG file size. JPEGs with more detail and shot at higher ISO ratings (more noise = more detail) tend to be larger because they do not compress so efficiently. At 3 fps I managed to get a remarkable 69 frames in the buffer, but again the file size was 2.75MB, so depending on your subject you may get more or less. For example with a 3.3MB file size the buffer stored 46 frames at 3 fps.

Note that RAW files are far less variable in size than JPEG files, due the the use of a lossless RAW compression scheme.

ISO Settings

The ISO settings on the EOS 30D can be changed in 1/3 ev, 1/2 ev or 1 ev steps, just like the EOS 5D. A custom function can select an "H" (High ISO) setting, equivalent to ISO 3200, though intermediate ISO settings of 2000 and 2500 are not available. There is no "L" (Low) ISO setting , equivalent to ISO 50), as there is in the EOS 5D. The ISO is displayed in the viewfinder while it's being changed, so you can adjust ISO without taking your eye from the viewfinder. ISO isn't continuously displayed in the viewfinder since the characters used for ISO display are normally used to display shutter speed, however it can be checked at anytime by pressing the ISO change button on top of the camera.

Image Noise

The EOS 20D and EOS 30D have exactly the same APS-C sensor and Digic II digital image processing chip so you'd expect that they would both show very similar noise levels - and they do. Other than effects due to very slight differences in exposure and color balance, the noise levels appear virtually identical.

The images below are 100% samples from the EOS 30D and EOS 20D at ISO 3200, ISO 800 and ISO 100. I shot a variety of subjects under a variety of conditions and overall I really couldn't tell any difference. Sometimes one might look slightly noisier at ISO 3200, sometimes the other, but on average I'd say they were essentially the same, or at least similar enough for the difference to be insignificant.

EOS 30D noise

Note that the above images were shot of an EOS-3 brouchure. The EOS 30D does not have ECF (Eye Controlled Focus). In fact no DSLR has ECF.

Resolution

Since the EOS 30D and 20D share the identical 8.2 MP APS-C sensor and Digic II processing chip, you wouldn't expect to see any difference in resolution, and again, you'd be right. I couldn't see any difference in resolution even looking at 200% image crops.

White Balance

The EOS 30D has the usual EOS white balance modes. Values in parentheses (e.g. 5200K ) are the color temperatures (in Kelvins) corresponding to the preset white balance modes.

  • Auto (3000K - 7000K)
  • Daylight (5200K)
  • Shade (7000K)
  • Cloudy (6000K)
  • Tungsten (3200K)
  • Fluorescent (4000K)
  • Flash (6000K)
  • Color Temperature (2800K - 10000K)
  • Custom. (2000K - 10000K)

It shows the typical EOS DSLR white balance characteristics, pretty accurate in Auto mode under outdoor lighting, with flash and under fluorescent lighting, but in Auto White Balance mode it's quite noticeably warm under household tungsten lights, and even in Tungsten White Balance mode it's still a little warm. Canon say that their Tungsten setting corresponds to a color temperature of 3200K, which is a lot warmer than a typical household tungsten bulb (nearer to 2800K). 3200K corresponds more to the color temperature of special short lived Photoflood lamps and so might be appropriate for studio work using special photographic tungsten lighting.  If you want neutral white balance when shooting under tungsten lights, you either need to set the color temperature (usually to its minimum value of  2800K for household tungsten lighting) or better, take a reading from a white or gray card and use the custom white balance setting. The samples below are cropped from an image of a gray card shot under illumination by a 100W household tungsten light bulb.

EOS 30D wite balance

Note that as with the 20D, the 30D has a fairly extensive set of white balance correction options including white balance auto bracketing of +/- 3 levels and with 9 levels of blue/amber or magenta/green settings. This means that if you're shooting JPEGs and don't like the standard or custom settings, you can apply a significant degree of correction. Of course if you shoot in RAW rather than JPEG you can do extensive white balance and color correction during RAW conversion.

NEXT - PART III - Picture Styles, Metering, Histograms and Conclusions

Where To Buy

Featured Merchants
Product:
Canon EOS 30D 8.2 Megapixel Digital SLR Camera Body with Lens Kit - 0.71"-2.17"
VendorVendor RatingAvailabilityPrice
There are currently no sellers for this product.
Search for similar products on PriceGrabber
Results by PriceGrabber.com
Product:
Canon EOS 30D 8.2 Megapixel Digital SLR Camera Body Only
VendorVendor RatingAvailabilityPrice

See all-time ratings
yes$1299.99
Results by PriceGrabber.com
Product:
Canon EOS 20D 8.3 Megapixel Digital SLR Camera Body Only
VendorVendor RatingAvailabilityPrice
There are currently no sellers for this product.
Search for similar products on PriceGrabber
Results by PriceGrabber.com

All original text and images ©2006 Bob Atkins (www.bobatkins.com)