What you want is a mini-DV camcorder. This is a near-broadcast-quality
format introduced by Sony in 1996. The blank tapes are tiny. The same machine and
tape can do
- digital audio (variety of formats, including 44 kHz, 16-bit CD-quality)
- still digital photos (720x480 pixels; about 700 fit on a tape)
- 60 minutes of video, stored digitally as 720x480 pixels, 30 frames/second,
compressed with MPEG
Why digital? Because you can copy without loss. Why do you want to copy your
home videos 50 times? Because they need editing. Editing implies copying. Also,
ultimately if you're producing for Internet distribution, all you really care
about is digital display. So you might as well keep the information in digital
form right from the start.
All you really need in a DV cam is a digital output. For reasons that escape
me, not all DV cams have digital outputs. This is variously referred to as a "DV
out", "Firewire", or "IEEE-1394". It is all the same standard and connector and
everything plugs together; only the names are different.
There are three kinds of mini-DV camcorders worth buying:
- palm-sized
- mid-priced 3-CCD
- semi-professional 3-CCD
[Note that not all "digital" camcorders are mini-DV. If you go to Best Buy or
a similar shop you'll encounter an inferior quality format known as "Digital8".
This was designed for compatibility with the old analog Hi8 camcorders. Avoid
this format.]
Palm-sized mini-DV camcorders
Palm-sized camcorders are good when making a video coincidental to other
activities. For example, you may be on a business trip and are carrying a
camcorder in case something interesting catches you eye. Given how time-consuming
it is to edit video (see below), this is not a very good way to achieve one's
artistic goals. Palm-sized recorders generally suffer from poor video quality due
to having only one charged coupled device (CCD) imaging sensor. That wouldn't be
a problem if you were taking black and white. But 1-CCD cameras try to capture
red, green, and blue for each pixel with their single CCD array. This is done by
laying a matrix of colored filters over the CCD pixels and then interpolating to
try to approximate the color and intensity for each pixel. Palm-sized camcorders
also suffer from poor audio quality when the built-in microphone is used. The
microphone itself is of acceptable quality but it is hard-mounted to a rigid
metal case that contains the motors and gears driving the tape.
A good example of the palmcorder breed is the Sony DCR-PC110
which does all the usual video jobs and also functions as a one-megapixel digital
still camera, storing digital photos onto a memory stick. The other unusual
feature of the DCR-PC110 is "NightShot". This is an infrared light underneath the
lens that enables videography in complete darkness. If you want a cheaper smaller
unit, look at the Sony
DCR-PC5.
The Canon camcorders are also worth looking at. Canon is the leader in image
stabilization, which is critically important for making handheld video. Canon
machines also tend to have good still picture capturing capability. If you're on
a budget, the Canon ZR20 is one of
the lowest-priced miniDV camcorders available ($600).
Expect to spend $500 to $1500 for a palm-sized mini-DV camcorder.
Mid-priced 3CCD camcorders
A 3-CCD camcorder splits the image optically and feeds color-filtered versions
of the same scene to three CCD sensors simultaneously. The tape thus records a
true red-green-blue (RGB) value for each pixel. All TV production is done with
3-CCD cameras and if you have the money and care about quality, you should do the
same.
The cheapest 3-CCD camcorders cost $2000-2500. Two examples are the Sony DCR-VX2000
and the Canon
GL-1. These don't fit as well into a professional production environment as
the semi-pro camcorders (below) but they offer just about everything that a
consumer would want, including reasonable capabilities for using external
microphones.
Semi-Professional 3-CCD camcorders
The semi-pro camcorders offer features such as interchangeable lenses and XLR
audio inputs. The video quality is similar to that of the mid-priced units.
Prices are $3000-4000.
As of August 2001, the only real options in semi-professional are the Sony VX2000 and
the Canon
XL-1. Both are excellent machines but an amateur might be happier with their
mid-priced cousins.
Accessories
Don't leave home without
a tripod and the
right microphone for the job. It will very seldom be the case that the
camcorder's built-in mic is the right tool. If you're doing a family history
video, pin a lavalier mic on your subject's shirt. If you're capturing sound as a
distance, get a boom mike.
Editing
The most important resource to budget for editing is time. Count on one hour
of post-production for every minute of final video. As your original data are
digital, the most sensible way to begin the editing process is by copying the
captured video to a computer's hard disk.
The digital video output of a camcorder is an IEEE-1394 "Firewire" connector.
You simply run a cable from this connector to your personal computer and plug it
into... oops. Unless you own a Macintosh you probably don't have an IEEE-1394
input. It is possible to add a Firewire input to an older PC. I tried this once
by purchasing a $500 "DPS Spark" card. I could never get it to work properly and
the manufacturer's support was terrible. Probably the easiest thing to do is to
purchase either a Macintosh or a machine that has been designed for video
editing. These need not cost a lot. Hewlett Packard, for example, has a Pavilion
7960 model for $1150 with a Firewire input and bundled video editing software.
Almost any Apple Macintosh system will function out of the box as a digital video
production tool. If you have the patience to learn and use the Avid Technology
digital editing system, IBM bundles some of its PCs with this software.
When you buy a machine that has bundled Firewire input and video editing
software you can be fairly sure that the machine has adequate input/output
bandwidth to copy incoming video data onto the hard disk. Data comes out of the
camcorder at 3.56 MB/second and there is no way for the computer to tell the
camcorder to "hold on for a minute." Your editing computer needs to have a
reasonably fast internal bus and fast hard disks.
Speaking of hard drives... in the bad old days, disks were supposed to pause
every now and then to do "thermal recalibration". So people bought
"AV-compatible" drives that promised not to stop and inspect their navels. With
the superfast disks that are standard nowadays, this is theoretically not a
problem. IBM, for example, says that all of their hard disks are AV-compatible.
Nor is it any longer necessary to purchase expensive SCSI hard drives. The
standard cheap IDE/ATA drives are fast enough.
Distributing your video to friends
If you want to distribute video to your friends and family, the best media are
probably VHS video tape or DVD. A computer sold for video editing will very
likely have an analog video output suitable for connection to a VHS video
recorder. Many of the newer Apple Macintoshes and some of the latest HP machines
can write DVDs. Each blank disk costs about $20.
Distributing video on the Internet
Even Web users with cable modems and DSL lines won't want to wait for a
DV-quality movie to download. At 3.56 MB/second, a 5-minute video will consume
roughly 1 GB of storage. At 1 Mbit/second, this will take roughly 3 hours to
download.
There are three ways to attack download time: downsizing, compression and
streaming. Downsizing in the video world implies reducing screen dimensions to
360x240 or 180x120 pixels (1/2 or 1/4 the full DV standard). Downsizing in the
audio world entails cutting down to mono from stereo and/or to 22 KHz sampling
from 44 KHz. Compression entails throwing away information that is redundant,
e.g., frames 2-30 in a one-second still where the content doesn't change from
frame to frame. Streaming involves distribution via a protocol whereby the user
can view content as it comes in.
As soon as you decide to go streaming, there is no download time for users.
There is only setup time. Your user's client has to make a connection to your
server. After that, it is a real-time show. The decision to stream means that the
user's Internet connection speed affects the quality of his experience. You have
to use downsizing and compression to fit your content into his or her available
bandwidth.
Note that you may not need any special software in order to serve streaming
video. If you want the user to be able to jump forward or back up, you'll need to
run a streaming media server of some sort. But most client software has the
capability to start playing video as it comes in. The user is limited to passive
from-the-start viewing until the entire video is stored on his or her local hard
disk. However, everyone benefits from the fact that the video can be served by
the same Web server program that is serving HTML pages and photographs.
Where to Buy
Video camcorders and editing equipment are available from retailers that pay
photo.net a referral fee for each purchase, which is the main source of financial
support for this site:
- Adorama
-
DealTime
-
PhotoAlley
Getting Fancy
If you're not satisfied with the software that came bundled with your
computer, look at Adobe Premiere and related products ( http://www.adobe.com/motion/main.html).
Getting Educated
Almost everyone has good equipment for making movies these days. But when was
the last time you saw a good home video? Video requires a lot of planning and
thought and, usually, carefully placed lights, microphones, and assistants. Here
are some book recommendations to get you started on the road to becoming an
auteur:
Next stop: UCLA Film School
More
Add a comment
Notify me of comments