A Site for Photographers by Photographers

Featured Equipment Deals

The September Monthly Project Read More

The September Monthly Project

For September's monthly project, Tom Persinger is joining us again to examine the intriguing ways reflections can be photographed to add interesting additional layers to our images. Please add your...

Latest Equipment Articles

The Week in Photography News Read More

The Week in Photography News

November 15-21, 2014: Hear the latest goings-on in the photography world, from product releases to event and campaign announcements and more.

Latest Learning Articles

Introduction to Creating an Album in Lightroom - Part I (Video Tutorial) Read More

Introduction to Creating an Album in Lightroom - Part I (Video Tutorial)

Learn to create an album in the Book Tab of Lightroom that you can publish and present to clients.


ND vs Polarizer

Frederico L , Jan 18, 2013; 04:58 p.m.

I am looking to get a 2 stop ND filter so I can shoot wide open outdoor in bright sunlight. I wonder if I can use a polarizer (that I already have) instead to achieve the same/similar result. Is there output difference in image quality, assuming both filters are quality made?. Any comments?

Responses

Howard M , Jan 18, 2013; 07:10 p.m.

depending on the lens's max aperture, you'll probably find that 2 stop ND is no where near enough to be 'wide open' in 'bright sunlight'.

if you follow sunny16, you're only down to F/8 w/ a 2stop ND. Work the numbers and see what you need, probably more like 4 stop

Howard M , Jan 18, 2013; 07:16 p.m.

depending on the lens's max aperture, you'll probably find that 2 stop ND is no where near enough to be 'wide open' in 'bright sunlight'.

if you follow sunny16, you're only down to F/8 w/ a 2stop ND. Work the numbers and see what you need, probably more like 4 stop

David Henderson , Jan 18, 2013; 09:20 p.m.

I imagine that Frederico might be thinking of changing shutter speeds as well.

Otherwise, just remember that a polariser does some things that a neutral density filter doesn't do in addition to holding back light by maybe 1.5-2 stops depending on the polariser; such as darkening blue skies at certain angle with the sun, and reducing most types of reflections.

Mendel Leisk , Jan 18, 2013; 10:13 p.m.

A Polarizer's only going to reduce light one stop at most.

I picked up a very heavy ND, good for around 6 stops or more. Have yet to really experiment with it, really should. You can take daytime time exposures, up to around 30 seconds, with all that entails. Things like motion blur (or complete disappearing) of pedestrians, daylight "streams" of traffic, glass-flat oceans, and so on.

Wouter Willemse , Jan 19, 2013; 10:33 a.m.

I've got a 6-stop ND with the idea of being able to shoot wide open (f/1.4 - f/2) in daylight. For where I am, 2 stops would not be enough (frequently ending up f/2.8, 1/8000th at lowest ISO). The downside, though, is that focussing with this filter on is undoable, so it does slow down and for me only works well with a tripod. In the end, I use the filter more for long exposures.
And the wide open shots... I either wait for sundown, and shoot them then, without filters, or I accept that I cannot make that particular photo.

Howard M , Jan 19, 2013; 11:40 a.m.

If you have extra $$, you can get a variable ND filter which should really cover you. I use the new Tiffen which has a large front element (for you wide-angle fans (yes, I know about the 'X'))

John SweetMk , Jan 19, 2013; 12:14 p.m.

Did nobody mention stacking 2 polarizing filters, then you have a variable ND filter?

Joe Willmore , Jan 21, 2013; 05:07 p.m.

First, I second the comments about a 2-stop NDF. In bright light that won't make much of a difference. You really should look at 6-stop. I think I've even screwed 2 NDFs on top of each other at times.
Second, I've heard of some shooters putting two polarizing filters on top of each other to get a NDF effect (make sure the degree of polarization is different with each filter so they block different light waves). I haven't tried it myself but 3 different shooters that I trust claim they've done this and had success with it.

Back to top

Notify me of Responses