Bob Atkins , May 11, 1999; 11:19 p.m.
Good - yes. Better - no. Just different. Sorry to state the obvious, but if you want a wamer tone, then a warming polarizer will help, if you don't, it won't.
Do you shoot with a warming filter most of the time? If not, would you want a warm tone on all your polarized shots?
You said it yourself, filters are a matter of taste, and nobody can tell you what your taste should be!