A Site for Photographers by Photographers

Community > Forums > Nikon > Nikon Lenses and Optics > Difference between Nikkor D...

Featured Equipment Deals

Announcing the Winners of the Nadine OHara Best of 2013 Wedding Contest Read More

Announcing the Winners of the Nadine OHara Best of 2013 Wedding Contest

Congratulations to the winners of this special contest! Take a moment to see what the judges--William W and Kristen Booth--had to say about the winners and why they were chosen.

Latest Equipment Articles

Lensbaby Spark Review Read More

Lensbaby Spark Review

This inexpensive gadget does indeed spark your creativity. Read on to see how.

Latest Learning Articles

26 Creative Photos of Water Drops Read More

26 Creative Photos of Water Drops

These absolutely amazing macro photographs feature a tiny elemental thing that can hold a lot of mystery. Take a moment to enjoy these photographs of water drops.


Difference between Nikkor D type and G type lenses

UMIT ALPER TUMEN , Dec 16, 2004; 05:51 a.m.

Hi everybody , I ' am taking art photos since 1989. I want to know nikkor 28-100 mm G type lens and nikkor 28-105 mm D type lens differences. I mean if I take 2 same pictures with both lenses on the camera and % 100 same condition ( subject, light, composition, distance, at 28 mm or 70 mm ). What about these 2 pictures. Are they % 100 same ( resolution, contrast etc...)or not. Which lenses must I purchase. Please help me

Regards, Umit Alper Tumen Istanbul-Turkey

Responses

Leslie Cheung , Dec 16, 2004; 06:40 a.m.

I don't know about the two lenses in question but g type denotes no aperture ring on lens. That may or may not affect your shooting depending on your style and body.

Jim Gifford , Dec 16, 2004; 06:52 a.m.

They are not 100 percent the same. Neither lens is bad. Neither is perfect. The D-series 28-105 is among the better Nikkor zooms, and for the money it is an outstanding value.

The G-series lens is one in a series of very lightweight, very low cost lenses (I used to have the AF-D 28-80, one of its early predecessors in the bargain line, from about 10 years back).

The 28-105 AF-D is the one you want.

art kramer , Dec 16, 2004; 07:32 a.m.

Not sure what the "G" type lens does, i think its just cheaper. The "D" is for the flash so it can judge the distance from the camera to the subject. nice to have if your shooting a nikon strobe. the pics should look the same.

Shun Cheung , Dec 16, 2004; 08:02 a.m.

As people say, you get what you pay for. Generally speaking, cheap zooms tend to have problems at the two ends of their zoom range, wide open. For example, serious barrel distortion is typical on the wide end. If you take two images in the middle of the zoom range at f8 or so from the two zooms you mentioned, there may not necessarily be any obvious difference. Moreover, build quality can be an issue.

Which one to get depends on how much you want to spend. Again, usually you get what you pay for.

Jerry Litynski , Dec 16, 2004; 12:24 p.m.

The 'G' denotes a lack of f-stop ring on the lens.

The 'D' denotes the 'Distance' factor in the lens and flash settings used for exposure.

If you shoot with the sun behind you (holding) the camera, both lenses would likely record the same image on film. Close-up work may be a bit better with the AF 28-105mm Nikkor lens.

Shooting into the sun might also be a challenge for either zoom lens.

Michael R. Freeman , Dec 16, 2004; 03:42 p.m.

One is a "high end" consumer lens, with good build quality, very little distortion throughout the entire zoom range, and is widely recognized as an excellent optical value for the price.

The other is built AS CHEAPLY AS POSSIBLE to cover essentially the same zoom range.

As with most things, you usually get what you pay for.

Michael

Jon Luebke , Dec 17, 2004; 01:42 p.m.

As Gerald said, the "G" designation simply indicates that there is no mechanical f-stop ring, so they will not be fully functional with older Nikons such as the F4, N8008, FM series, etc. "D" lenses transmit distance information for use in the newer Nikons' 3D matrix metering and advanced flash algorithms. Also, all G lenses transmit distance information. For that purpose, you may consider all G lenses as being D lenses as well.

Regarding the particular lenses you mentioned, the Nikon Compendium rates the 28-100 lens as quite possibly the worst lens that Nikon has ever made. I have not used the 28-105, but I can confirm that the 28-100 is a wretched piece of crap, so I would avoid it at all costs.

Back to top

Notify me of Responses