Ken Grimm , Jan 11, 2007; 06:08 p.m.
All:
I recently (nine months ago) got a Nikon D50 with both lenses (kit) and could not be more pleased,
mostly. I've managed to take about 20,000 pictures since then and am elated with what I've been able
to accomplish with this tool. The issue: About a month ago, the telephoto lens' auto focus just stopped
working for no apparent reason.
I have done everything I know to do: checked to make sure the lens was seated properly (the "click");
used every combination I could try to set the AF/M on the camera and lens; turning the camera on and
off; resetting the camera; taking the battery out for extended periods of time; and probably a few
things better not admitted to... :-)
What is really weird is the auto focus, again with no apparent reason, will just start working again! I did
find a thread using Google in which others had experienced similar behavior, but no help in a fix or
what to do, and for the life of me I can't find the thread once I get here by opening the site -- so I don't
know if it is ancient or what...
Any help or ideas? Upgrading is not an option, and I really don't want to... the camera meets my needs
perfectly, other than its non-auto focusing temper tantrums.
Thanks for listening,
Ken Grimm
325-374-4238
Michael Axel 
, Jan 11, 2007; 06:11 p.m.
Which lens is it happening with?
Ken Grimm , Jan 11, 2007; 06:15 p.m.
It is the AF-S NIKKOR 55-200mm 1:4-5.6G ED.
Michael R. Freeman 
, Jan 11, 2007; 07:03 p.m.
Try cleaning the CPU contacts on the lens (use a cotton swab moistened with alcohol). It's possible an offending contact is "dirty", which would prevent it from establishing good electrical continuity with the camera circuits responsible for activating the AF-S motor in the lens.
If that doesn't cure the problem, or it continues to act up, I would suggest you send the lens to Nikon for an inspection and or repair before your warranty expires.
P.S. - It's usually not a good idea to post your email address in a public forum.
Ken Grimm , Jan 11, 2007; 09:11 p.m.
Hi Michael,
Well, I just thought I had cleaned the contacts. I got some 91% alcohol and swabs and
started working on the contacts in the camera. To my surprise, there was some black gunk
that was coming off in a pretty large quantity. The contacts went from a dull bronze to a
bright copper color.
The black gunk was from a thin strip of what looked like some kind of foam close to the
contacts, apparently to keep foreign objects out. A small piece had come loose, just
enough to get its stick-um smeared all over the contacts when a lens was twisted on.
During the cleaning process, this piece off foam just fell off. I'm sure it was there for a
legitimate purpose, but it wound up hurting more than it helped, indeed doing the exact
opposite of what it was engineered to do.
I have the foam and if the camera gets dirtier without it than with it, I'll glue it back on. But
for now, both lenses have come back to life -- the response time on the focusing has
improved, so there was definitely some interference going on.
I appreciate the response. Most helpful. And thanks for the tip about posting safety.
Ken
Michael R. Freeman 
, Jan 11, 2007; 09:37 p.m.
"The black gunk was from a thin strip of what looked like some kind of foam close to the contacts ..."
If it is the foam indicated in the photo below, that is the mirror bumper foam. It cushions the reflex mirror when it comes up. It is very, very unusual for it to deteriorate so rapidly - usually that takes years unless it comes into contact with a solvent.
If that is indeed the case, then you should have this foam replaced as soon as possible. Glad to hear that you solved your autofocus issues.
... mystery foam?
Ken Grimm , Jan 12, 2007; 12:24 a.m.
That's it!
Apparently it is a problem, because I've now heard of several people with the same
problem. I hadn't used any solvent at all and this piece of foam had came loose enough to
just interfere with the lens when twisted on. The black glue that was holding it on had
smeared over the contacts enough over time and use to stop the auto focus from working.
The foam is very, very porous and lightweight. Whatever was used to stick it down
originally doesn't seem to be very good.
I'll get it replaced. I'm just glad to know what the root of the problem was.
Ken
Sanford Edelstein 
, Jan 12, 2007; 09:49 a.m.
I used a Nikon FM for years with the all the foam removed and saw with no harm to the camera, lenses, or photos.