Wayne Cornell
, Mar 20, 2007; 05:25 p.m.
Anybody have any experience with the Nikkor 18-135mm lens? How does it compare
to the 18-70?
Peter Hamm 
, Mar 20, 2007; 05:31 p.m.
D.H. Geyer , Mar 20, 2007; 06:12 p.m.
I've had and informally tested the 18-70, the 18-200, and the 18-135. The 18-70 is the sharpest, and I've actually kept it. The other two I returned. The Sigma 18-50 seems to be a bit sharper than any of these three lenses as long as you don't shoot wide open at f2.8, particularly at 18mm focal length. The 18-135 was actually the worst lens I tested. The 18-70 is also set up pretty nicely, with its own focusing motor, the focus and zoom rings in good places, and a decent lens hood. The 18-200 was better than the 18-135 within the 18-135 range. Beyond that I found it getting a bit soft for my liking. The 55-200 is decent, even if the build quality and setup are not as nice. I have kept the 55-200. My strategy is that the 18-50, or the 18-70 will work most of the time, and they're both good lenses. The 55-200 will serve on those few occasions when I need that range of focal lengths. Hope all this rambling helps you!
Wayne Cornell
, Mar 20, 2007; 06:29 p.m.
Thanks. That's good info to know.
Nick White , Mar 20, 2007; 07:51 p.m.
I bought the D80 + 18-135 kit, this lens bears no comparison to the excellent 18-70. I sold the lens on within a week! Go for the 18-70 for sure.
Ronald Duren , Mar 20, 2007; 09:15 p.m.
This Lens came with my D80 it is very sharp, but prone to distortion, CAs and vignetting all off which can be controled by Capture NX and other software. It's a good value for the money.
18-135 street scene
Ronald Duren , Mar 20, 2007; 09:31 p.m.
While not as good as my 180mm 2.8, at the 135mm setting it handles shooting into sun much better than the 85mm 1.8.
18-135 into the sun
Rob Hardiman , Mar 25, 2007; 03:18 a.m.
I've found my 18-135 to be very sharp in good light. The better the light, the sharper the pics. It is actually sharper than my 70-300 VR lens. It does have other issues, but a lack sharpness is not one of them, with my lens, at least.