David Haas , Oct 02, 2010; 10:24 a.m.
Every "new" body i've gotten has had a few clicks (less than 200) on it.
In fact I just had a shutter replaced on a D300 - old shutter had 133,000+ on it. Came back - new shutter had 161 on it.
I use opanda to check - they're very good and accurate -
It could be that the body was out in the store for a day or so or that they (B and H) tested it before they shipped - added to what the manufacturer did.
Consider this before you ship it back - the body is rated to 150,000 - so you've still got over 149,500 left. Also - you have a full warranty to back you up on it - so if there are issues - you can get it fixed.