A Site for Photographers by Photographers

Critique Photos in the Photo.net forums

Category: Only show images where anonymous critique is allowed

About This Forum 

Submit photos for other photo.net members to critique and/or rate. Photos must be submitted to this forum in order to be eligible for the Top Rated Photos pages. For more information on rating photos, please look at the Ratings Tutorial.

After submitting, your image will be placed into the rotation. 100 random images from the past 24 hours are presented at any given time. These 100 images are re-chosen every minute. This is to give every image an equal chance to be seen and commented on.

The moderators of this forum are Bob Atkins Cara St.Hilaire &Glenn Palm.

Older Critique Requests (by category)

Water on water by Petar Boskovski | 2015-03-06
Cars and Vehicles

Thanks for viewing
>> Contribute a critique

12 apostles by Sherwin Tan | 2015-03-05
Landscape

thanks
>> Contribute a critique

Brighton Beach by Tina Karina | 2015-03-05
Events

Thank you for your comments and critique
>> Contribute a critique

Bangkok by John Nell | 2015-03-06
Portraits

Critique please
>> Contribute a critique

Fury of God by Yan Zhang | 2015-03-05
Landscape

This is the color version of my previous post, I think this version is much stronger than the B/W one.

It was the morning of 18 January 2014. The sky was unusual, two cyclone-like clouds - one black and one white, were so low and almost touched the ground, while the black one was right above this famous church (Church of the Good Shepherd). In fact, this was my first time to see this type of sky during all of my New Zealand trips over these years.

This image was a panorama consisting of 6 successive shot stitching together.

Thanks for viewing this image.
>> Contribute a critique

Toward the sky by Theodor Dinulescu | 2015-03-05
Landscape

Your feedback is kindly appreciated ! Many thanks,

Theodor D.
>> Contribute a critique

. by Michail Lipakis | 2015-03-05
Documentary

.
>> Contribute a critique

CA32 (1) by Antony Long | 2015-03-06
Abstract

Tony
>> Contribute a critique

dancer by Wayne Sadler | 2015-03-06
Portraits

Nosu - Comments and critique appreciated.
>> Contribute a critique

gatherings by Ioannis Lukas | 2015-03-06
Abstract

Best view larger. Thanks.
>> Contribute a critique

PATAGONIA by JOSE BRENER | 2015-03-05
Landscape

AGRADEZCO SUS COMENTARIOS,SALUDOS DE MÉXICO
>> Contribute a critique

Deep Forest by Matthew Brennan | 2015-03-06
Landscape

Otways Forest is looking lush after a (rare) wet summer
>> Contribute a critique

street folk by stephanie c | 2015-03-05
Street

........
>> Contribute a critique

The Carousel by Massimiliano Uccelletti | 2015-03-05
Portraits

thx
>> Contribute a critique

Winter Red Berries by Sarah Perry | 2015-03-05
Nature

Amateur here. Any feedback/critiques appreciated. Thanks!
>> Contribute a critique

first crocus by Gregory and Verena Sava | 2015-03-06
Flowers

thanks- vie large please -- today they're under 10 " of snow...
>> Contribute a critique

Hard times by Svetlana Korolyova | 2015-03-06
Portraits

Color film, double exposure. Your opinions and comments are important to me.
>> Contribute a critique

Langer´s tree, York by Lars Karlsson | 2015-03-06
Landscape

Thank you!
>> Contribute a critique

Female Portrait by sydney ricks | 2015-03-05
Portraits

This was my first time shooting with my Nikon d7100 and 50mm 1.8. I'm open to any critique as I am beginning to pursue an education and career in photography. I love portrait photography and want to develop a unique, but appealing style.
>> Contribute a critique

church by Nervi by Maria Bostenaru | 2015-03-06
Architecture

outside detail
>> Contribute a critique

Send to Guernica by Manuela Sousa | 2015-03-05
Landscape

Thnks for viewing.
>> Contribute a critique

LA VÍBORA by JOSE BRENER | 2015-03-05
Nature

AGRADEZCO SUS COMENTARIOS,SALUDOS DE MÉXICO
>> Contribute a critique

Mountain rhythms - larger view by Theodor Dinulescu | 2015-03-05
Landscape

Your feedback is kindly appreciated ! Many thanks,

Theodor D.
>> Contribute a critique

He stole my dinner by charlie dill | 2015-03-05
Birds

View Larger.
>> Contribute a critique

Val Veny by Sergio Gavardi | 2015-03-05
Landscape

Thanks for your comments and rate. Sergio
>> Contribute a critique

Perro de Presa Canario by Magnus Karlsson | 2015-03-06
Pets

Please view full size and leave constructive comments. Thanks for your time and efforts.

Sincerely Magnus
>> Contribute a critique

decay... by nebojsa tasic | 2015-03-05
Street

...comments and ratings appreciated...
>> Contribute a critique

Converging by Michael Linder | 2015-03-05
Street

Thanks for viewing. Comments welcome.
>> Contribute a critique

Cold winter morning by Noncho Iliev | 2015-03-05
Landscape

A cold landscape with birds and mist. Please view it larger.
>> Contribute a critique

un giro con noi?... by nebojsa tasic | 2015-03-05
Still Life/Studio

...from rimini SIGEP fair... comments appreciated...
>> Contribute a critique

Oregon's Coast by George Bruckner | 2015-03-05
Landscape

Thank you for your comments and your critiques. Take care
>> Contribute a critique

the dance by Wayne Sadler | 2015-03-06
Portraits

Some of the dancers at this Festival of Cultures in Nashville seemed to immerse themselves into the dance. Those dancers had a look of satisfaction, pleasure and detachment or abandonment all at the same time. This reminded me of a passage in one of Carlos Castaneda?s books. Don Juan, a sorcerer, was giving the author, Castaneda, advice on the art of ?seeing? or ?becoming a man of knowledge?. He gave as an example another sorcerer named Sacateca who uses dance as a means of helping him to ?see?. When Castaneda asked Don Juan how could dancing help Sacateca to ?see?, Don Juan replied, ?One can say that Sacateca dances with all he has.? Comments and critique appreciated.
>> Contribute a critique

Playfull Jess by T. Carlos | 2015-03-05
Nudes

The fun of art or just being playful....Comments appreciated...Thanks...Tom
>> Contribute a critique

looking up by Maria Bostenaru | 2015-03-06
Abstract

skyscraper in SF
>> Contribute a critique

Russian salad ingredients by Pierre Dumas | 2015-03-05
Abstract

Thank you for your attention, dear colleagues!

PDE
>> Contribute a critique

Fishy?? by Supriyo Bhattacharya | 2015-03-06
Nature

A bunch of colorful koi. However I feel black & white does more justice to this image. Your opinion may vary.
>> Contribute a critique

Untitled by Aleks Drof | 2015-03-05
Travel

Thanks for viewing.
>> Contribute a critique

circled by Olaf de Vries | 2015-03-05
Street

Inhaling France
>> Contribute a critique

Any comments welcome. Thanks for Looking. by Mário Azevedo | 2015-03-06
Street

--MAA
>> Contribute a critique

Michal by Jiri Subrt | 2015-03-05
Portraits

...
>> Contribute a critique

by Jim Phelps | 2015-03-05
Nudes

Critiques appreciated.
>> Contribute a critique

Playful Jess in Color by T. Carlos | 2015-03-06
Nudes

Playing in color......comments appreciated....Thanks....Tom
>> Contribute a critique

KISS TO CLOWN by Hannu Soini | 2015-03-05
Pets

" I have to Kiss this guy Clean:)"
>> Contribute a critique

Gravity by Chuck Turner | 2015-03-05
Portraits


>> Contribute a critique

Coming in for landing by charlie dill | 2015-03-05
Birds

Just thought some might enjoy.
>> Contribute a critique

Juxta posed by Jon Hyde | 2015-03-05
Fine Art

Sidi Bou Said, Tunisia. Nikon D300, Nikon 18-70 at 44mm, 1/400 sec at f6.3, ISO 200.

Thanks for passing by. Any comments warmly welcome.
>> Contribute a critique

In the church by Gianni Spini | 2015-03-05
Portraits

In church ..... beautiful as the sun.
>> Contribute a critique

by Michael Linder | 2015-03-05
Flowers

Thanks for viewing. Comments welcome.
>> Contribute a critique

Composition with iron by Marco Overdiep | 2015-03-05
Abstract

Thank you for your attention.
>> Contribute a critique

Tereza by Jiri Subrt | 2015-03-05
Portraits

...
>> Contribute a critique

grounds by John Nell | 2015-03-06
Travel

Critique please
>> Contribute a critique

Night Scene by vlad khodski | 2015-03-05
Fine Art

Your comments are warmly welcome
>> Contribute a critique

Memory of the walls by Michail Lipakis | 2015-03-05
Documentary

.
>> Contribute a critique

A wedding by Francesco Cifarelli | 2015-03-06
Wedding and Social

Thanx for your comments and critiques.
>> Contribute a critique

Searching and Gathering - Epcot - Florida by Tony Hadley | 2015-03-05
Nature

Thanks
>> Contribute a critique

by Michael Linder | 2015-03-05
Flowers

Thanks for viewing. Comments welcome.
>> Contribute a critique

Tank by Harry Joseph | 2015-03-05
Landscape

Tank...
>> Contribute a critique

. by Michail Lipakis | 2015-03-05
Documentary

.
>> Contribute a critique

... by Katarzyna Gritzmann | 2015-03-05
Architecture

all comments are welcome :)
>> Contribute a critique

Waterspace by Renar Atrays (renoa) | 2015-03-06
Landscape

The Bench...
>> Contribute a critique

EL PELICANO by JOSE BRENER | 2015-03-05
Birds

AGRADEZCO SUS COMENTARIOS,SALUDOS DE MEXICO
>> Contribute a critique

LA LEONA by JOSE BRENER | 2015-03-05
Nature

AGRADEZCO SUS COMENTARIOS,SALUDOS DE MÉXICO
>> Contribute a critique

High Key Nature by Craig Allen | 2015-03-06
Landscape

I love the fog for many reasons, one of which how it helps to isolate subjects and break them down to there basic form. While hiking in the abandoned town of Franklin, WA I looked up the hill and saw this large vine maple struggling to survive and ended up taking many shots until finally the fog started to lift and the "magic" was gone. This ended up being my favorite of the bunch. All I did for the edit was convert to B&W (Nik Silver Efex Pro 2), luminosity mask to darken the tree just a touch, and cropped to 4x5 for aesthetics. I would love to hear your thoughts on this shot as it is my first attempt at a high key. Thanks for viewing and commenting.
>> Contribute a critique

Hard times by Svetlana Korolyova | 2015-03-06
Portraits

Color film, double exposure. Your opinions and comments are important to me.
>> Contribute a critique

Boardwalk by Paul Goldsmith | 2015-03-06
Landscape

The road to nowhere? I hope not! Whilst driving around one of the many lakes in the Lake District, I stumbled upon this scene and thought it would make a great subject. A bit cliched I suppose but we all have our own take on these views. What's yours?
>> Contribute a critique

Sister by Wayne Sadler | 2015-03-06
Portraits

Shabnam Dancing. Comments and critique welcome.
>> Contribute a critique

at the beach by John Nell | 2015-03-06
Travel

Critique please
>> Contribute a critique

It Takes (a thief) by K. D. Warbis | 2015-03-05
Still Life/Studio

Thanks for looking and for any c/c you may have.
>> Contribute a critique

Rattlesnake Ridge by Craig Allen | 2015-03-05
Landscape

One of the cliff faces on the back side Rattlesnake Ridge. I wasn't happy with the color version so I decided to try B&W, please let me know what you think good or bad. Your valuable feedback helps me a lot. Thanks for viewing and commenting.
>> Contribute a critique

Memory of the walls by Michail Lipakis | 2015-03-05
Documentary

.
>> Contribute a critique

Fuerteventura by Felix Capote | 2015-03-06
Landscape

Un saludo
>> Contribute a critique

Coloured iron 2 by Marco Overdiep | 2015-03-05
Abstract

Thank you for your attention.
>> Contribute a critique

by Michael Linder | 2015-03-05
Flowers

Thanks for viewing. Comments welcome.
>> Contribute a critique

Spring morning by Theodor Dinulescu | 2015-03-05
Landscape

Your feedback is kindly appreciated ! Many thanks,

Theodor D.
>> Contribute a critique

. by Hans-Peter van den Berg | 2015-03-05
Events

.
>> Contribute a critique

Meerkats by Michael Lewis | 2015-03-05
Nature

Any comments are welcome - thank you
>> Contribute a critique

Rigi morning by Bob McLean | 2015-03-05
Landscape

A morning scene from Rigi -Queen of the Mountains - accessed by the first cogwheel railway in Europe stands 1,798 m in the North-Eastern Swiss Alps. Regards. Bob
>> Contribute a critique

Carpathian peak by Theodor Dinulescu | 2015-03-05
Landscape

Your feedback is kindly appreciated ! Many thanks,

Theodor D.
>> Contribute a critique

town hall by Maria Bostenaru | 2015-03-06
Travel

close view
>> Contribute a critique

. by Hans-Peter van den Berg | 2015-03-05
Portraits

.
>> Contribute a critique

High Heels by Art Rivera | 2015-03-05
Nudes

Comments are welcome.
>> Contribute a critique

169 by Rudolf Kartelin | 2015-03-05
Nudes

Thanks
>> Contribute a critique

Mor by Harry Sang | 2015-03-06
Still Life/Studio

Please comment!
>> Contribute a critique

shadow dancing by Wayne Sadler | 2015-03-06
Portraits

comments and critique welcome.
>> Contribute a critique

Still life walking by Elena Spirito | 2015-03-05
Still Life/Studio

Thanks Elena
>> Contribute a critique

Tile by Marco Overdiep | 2015-03-05
Abstract

Thank you for your attention.
>> Contribute a critique

Kata by Jiri Subrt | 2015-03-05
Portraits

...
>> Contribute a critique

Gentle Touch by Jamie Kraft | 2015-03-06
Flowers

colour and shade
>> Contribute a critique

100th anniversary by Maria Bostenaru | 2015-03-06
Documentary

San Francisco scape
>> Contribute a critique

Lake District_75 by Raymond Borg | 2015-03-05
Nature

Any comments would be appreciated. Thanks.
>> Contribute a critique

*** by Jack P. K. | 2015-03-05
Architecture

Thanks for your comments, click to see larger version of the photo... :-)
>> Contribute a critique

My youngest daughter by Olaf de Vries | 2015-03-05
Street

Frustrating France
>> Contribute a critique

Dutch bikes... 143 by Ruud Albers | 2015-03-06
Street

Thanks for (larger) viewing...
>> Contribute a critique

New York, March 5th, 2015 by Tina Karina | 2015-03-05
Street

Thank you for your comments and critique
>> Contribute a critique

New member seeking critique by Doug Aday | 2015-03-05
Portraits

Tell me what you think. :)
>> Contribute a critique

Cold day, thinking of warmer days by Aileen Lannen Mozug | 2015-03-05
Flowers

All critiques and feedback are welcomed. thank you.
>> Contribute a critique

Monika by Jiri Subrt | 2015-03-05
Portraits

...
>> Contribute a critique

Morning dreams... by Krzysztof Browko | 2015-03-05
Landscape

Regards!
>> Contribute a critique

Hard times by Svetlana Korolyova | 2015-03-06
Portraits

Color film, double exposure. Your opinions and comments are important to me.
>> Contribute a critique

Interesting/strong or banal/boring? by Steve Coen | 2015-03-06
Nudes

Please let me know what you think, thanks in advance!
>> Contribute a critique