A Site for Photographers by Photographers

Critique Photos in the Photo.net forums

Category: Only show images where anonymous critique is allowed

About This Forum 

Submit photos for other photo.net members to critique and/or rate. Photos must be submitted to this forum in order to be eligible for the Top Rated Photos pages. For more information on rating photos, please look at the Ratings Tutorial.

After submitting, your image will be placed into the rotation. 100 random images from the past 24 hours are presented at any given time. These 100 images are re-chosen every minute. This is to give every image an equal chance to be seen and commented on.

The moderators of this forum are Bob Atkins Cara St.Hilaire &Glenn Palm.

Older Critique Requests (by category)

Three Chairs by Brian Clark | 2014-10-30
Travel

Comments welcome
>> Contribute a critique

'Bryce Canyon National Park II, USA' by John Crosley | 2014-10-31
Landscape

'Hoodoos', tall wind and water resistant spires tower at Bryce Canyon National Park, Utah. Your ratings, critiques and observations are invited and most welcome. If you rate harshly, very critically, or wish to make a remark, please submit a helpful and constructive comment; please share your photographic knowledge to help improve my photography. Thanks. Enjoy. john
>> Contribute a critique

. by martin h | 2014-10-31
Digital Alterations

.
>> Contribute a critique

no title by Siamak Jafari | 2014-10-31
Portraits

thanks in advance .
>> Contribute a critique

Waiting... by Michail Lipakis | 2014-10-31
Documentary

.
>> Contribute a critique

Be Good Tonight, I am watching you. by Owen O'Meara | 2014-10-31
Still Life/Studio

d810 with Nikkor prime.
>> Contribute a critique

GRIMES MILL: Fire Rages Under Blustery Skies, January 16, 2013 II by Landrum Kelly | 2014-10-30
Landscape

Comments welcome.

--Lannie
>> Contribute a critique

'Waiting While Tired' by John Crosley | 2014-10-31
Street

A lone, weary traveler outside a colored train station wall squats as is the custom in Eastern Europe, and shields and supports his head with his hands. Your ratings, critiques and observations are invited and most welcome. If you rate harshly, very critically, or wish to make an observation, please submit a helpful and constructive comment; please share your photographic knowledge to help improve my photography. Thanks! Enjoy! john
>> Contribute a critique

N-Y by Isi Haber | 2014-10-31
Travel

thank you for your comments
>> Contribute a critique

Damselfly...............22. by Amal Saha | 2014-10-31
Macro

Your comments please.
>> Contribute a critique

Untitled by John Peri | 2014-10-31
Nudes

..
>> Contribute a critique

Strokes of Nature by Rajkumar Krishna | 2014-10-31
Nature

C n C WC
>> Contribute a critique

berrys by tim hayes | 2014-10-31
Still Life/Studio

thanks
>> Contribute a critique

Mount Alpha - COMMENTS AND CRITICISM WELCOME! by Cory Sine | 2014-10-31
Landscape

This image was shot RAW using the HDR method with a Canon 60D and processed in Lightroom 3.6. Personally, I consider it one of my better mountain portraits and have a print of it in my portfolio. I'm considering it for significant enlargement into a canvas-print for future shows. Any criticism and feedback that might help me make it a better photo would be greatly appreciated.
>> Contribute a critique

Thanks for stopping by by Kersti Luik | 2014-10-31
Architecture

Thanks for ratings and critique!
>> Contribute a critique

wheat fields by B. Bernardo Grobman | 2014-10-31
Landscape

Hi, Your comments and critics are most welcomed, Bernardo
>> Contribute a critique

Young witch who hates sunlight by Pierre Dumas | 2014-10-30
Portraits

Thank you for your attention, dear colleagues!

PDE
>> Contribute a critique

Chief Buttress in Winter - COMMENTS WELCOME! by Cory Sine | 2014-10-31
Landscape

This was shot using the HDR method with a Canon 60D and processed inb Lightroom 3.6. I do like the image and it is part of my portfolio, but it is one of my least favorite shots in my portfolio and I would appreciate other photographers' opinions on whether or not this winter shot has merit or not.
>> Contribute a critique

THE COLOURS OF AUTUMN - PIAN DI GEMBRO - VALTELLINA - ITALY by MASSIMO ALBERTO BONELLI | 2014-10-31
Landscape

Thanks for your comments.
>> Contribute a critique

Rose by Steve J Murray | 2014-10-31
Flowers

Literally, the last rose of the season. We have now had frost. I had to take some photos of this one, and my wife remarked: "this last rose is the most beautiful."
>> Contribute a critique

Yellow T-Bird by Bill J Boyd | 2014-10-31
Cars and Vehicles

Found this car parked on a hillside in Austin. Thank you for comments.
>> Contribute a critique

7188 by Maurizio Guarino | 2014-10-31
Macro

Thanks for the comments!
>> Contribute a critique

Ancient Water by Henk Boneschans | 2014-10-31
Landscape

Comments and critique will REALLY be appreciated!
>> Contribute a critique

Joyful youth.. by Chris Panagiotidis | 2014-10-30
Portraits

Thank you for stopping by..
>> Contribute a critique

No Cup Holders by Bill J Boyd | 2014-10-31
Cars and Vehicles

These guys had a hard time getting into this European car. Said it was a tight fit and there were no cup holders. Austin is in the b/g. Thank you for comments.
>> Contribute a critique

Foggy Autumn Morning by Warren Kaplan | 2014-10-31
Landscape

Thanks for looking!
>> Contribute a critique

Anticipation by Henk Boneschans | 2014-10-31
Landscape

Comments and Critique will REALLY be appreciated!
>> Contribute a critique

Pinhole ensaio de luz e cor by Miguel Boyayan | 2014-10-31
Still Life/Studio

Pinhole em ensaio de cor.
>> Contribute a critique

Any comments welcome. Thanks for Looking. by Mário Azevedo | 2014-10-31
Street

--MAA
>> Contribute a critique

The woman in the window by Svetlana Korolyova | 2014-10-31
Street

Your opinions and comments are important to me.
>> Contribute a critique

Autumn sun by Svetlana Korolyova | 2014-10-31
Street

Your opinions and comments are important to me.
>> Contribute a critique

Happy Halloween by Andrzej Nowakowski | 2014-10-31
Children

Comments?
>> Contribute a critique

northern sea by Maria Bostenaru | 2014-10-31
Landscape

stripes
>> Contribute a critique

Lake District_31 by Raymond Borg | 2014-10-31
Landscape

Any comments would be appreciated. Thanks.
>> Contribute a critique

Lilith by Massimiliano Uccelletti | 2014-10-31
Portraits

thx...
>> Contribute a critique

Holding on by MICHAEL D DAVIS | 2014-10-31
Nature

Any comments would be appreciated!
>> Contribute a critique

Childhood by Svetlana Korolyova | 2014-10-31
Street

Your opinions and comments are important to me.
>> Contribute a critique

LIBELULA by JOSE BRENER | 2014-10-31
Insects

AGRADEZCO SUS COMENTARIOS SALUDOS DE MÉXICO
>> Contribute a critique

The girl with long hair by Mircea Tiron-Tudor | 2014-10-31
Street

Thank you for visit !
>> Contribute a critique

A tree, a window and a... by Ruud Albers | 2014-10-31
Street

Thanks for (larger) viewing...
>> Contribute a critique

AGUILA PESCADORA by JOSE BRENER | 2014-10-31
Birds

AGRADEZCO SUS COMENTARIOS SALUDOS DE MÉXICO
>> Contribute a critique

Fall At My Doorstep by James Paul Frank | 2014-10-30
Nature

Thanks!
>> Contribute a critique

The Geese and the Seagulls by Victor Wei | 2014-10-31
Birds

One day, the geese decided to come over to the seagulls to say "Hi". They became best friends ever since.

Comments welcome.
>> Contribute a critique

LA RANA by JOSE BRENER | 2014-10-31
Nature

AGRADEZCO SUS COMENTARIOS SALUDOS DE MÉXICO
>> Contribute a critique

:-) by Jim Downs | 2014-10-31
Street

Thx for comments.
>> Contribute a critique

Fear is a mind game! by David McCracken | 2014-10-31
Still Life/Studio


We like to be scared. And so with halloween upon us I thought I would post an image apt for the time of year. It's not scary... or is it?

Feedback appreciated.

>> Contribute a critique

Nude Portrait by Richard Kemp | 2014-10-31
Nudes

Thank you for your thoughts...
>> Contribute a critique

Mt St Helens by Craig Allen | 2014-10-31
Landscape

So on an evening with my dad up around Mt St Helens she was blowing some steam and looking awesome. The moon made the scene even more surreal and as the last light was fading I setup and captured this shot. I'd love to hear your thoughts on it...good or bad. Thanks for viewing and commenting.
>> Contribute a critique

Haleakala Sunset by Alberto Patiño Douce | 2014-10-31
Landscape

Comments welcome - thank you for stopping by!
>> Contribute a critique

no title by Siamak Jafari | 2014-10-31
Landscape

thanks in advance .
>> Contribute a critique

contrejour by Maria Bostenaru | 2014-10-31
Architecture

facade of an early postwar building
>> Contribute a critique

Fall in CT by Brian Whitton | 2014-10-31
Landscape

comments appreciated
>> Contribute a critique

Structured Farming by Henk Boneschans | 2014-10-31
Landscape

Comments and Critique will REALLY be appreciated!
>> Contribute a critique

Yellow by Vikas Chikhalkar | 2014-10-30
Landscape

Thank you,
>> Contribute a critique

Shoreline at night by B. Bernardo Grobman | 2014-10-31
Abstract

Hi, your comments are most welcomed, Bernardo
>> Contribute a critique

Beech Leaves by Len Marriott | 2014-10-30
Nature

Your constructive comment\critique will be gratefully received. LM.
>> Contribute a critique

Popularity by B. Bernardo Grobman | 2014-10-31
Street

Your comments are most welcomed, Bernardo
>> Contribute a critique

Nude Portrait by Richard Kemp | 2014-10-31
Nudes

Thank you for your thoughts...
>> Contribute a critique

by Evgeni Donev | 2014-10-31
Landscape


>> Contribute a critique

The Art of Infrared by tony brandstetter | 2014-10-31
Landscape

Two Tree is another attempt at Infrared photography, something I feel is unique to this site

Tony B
>> Contribute a critique

In The Gallery by stefano fiori | 2014-10-31
Street

Thank you very much for every comment or rating
>> Contribute a critique

Click for larger view by Line Martel | 2014-10-31
Street

And....another cowboy character. Your comments are welcome.
>> Contribute a critique

EL MAR by JOSE BRENER | 2014-10-31
Landscape

AGRADEZCO SUS COMENTARIOS,SALUDOS DE MÉXICO
>> Contribute a critique

community building at Bellavista by Maria Bostenaru | 2014-10-31
Architecture

large scale
>> Contribute a critique

Latourell Falls by Craig Allen | 2014-10-31
Landscape

Latourell Falls in Eagle Creek Wilderness is a tough falls to shoot because you have such a limit area to shoot from. This viewpoint is literally cut out of the side of a cliff. This is a B&W conversion of a previously posted color image. I'm very interested in what you think, especially compared to the color version. Thanks for viewing and commenting.
>> Contribute a critique

Untitled by Chris Hamom | 2014-10-31
Nature

Thanks for looking
>> Contribute a critique

Black camisole 01 by WL Schlueter | 2014-10-31
Fashion

A simple portrait odf a woman dressing a black camisole
>> Contribute a critique

Frank N Steen by David D O`Brien | 2014-10-31
Digital Alterations

C&C welcome
>> Contribute a critique

Polaroid type 55 negative by Victoria Perelet | 2014-10-30
Nudes

Sinar p2, schneider 210mm apo lens. Ring flash powered by speedotron pack.
>> Contribute a critique

Relaxing by Craig Allen | 2014-10-31
Pets

So this is my first submission to the pets category. This is our cat Earl, or as he like to be called Mr. Earl :-) I'm very interested in what you think about this shot. Thanks for viewing and commenting.
>> Contribute a critique

Fresco by Sarah McNulty | 2014-10-31
Fine Art

Thanks for looking and comments/advice always appreciated.
>> Contribute a critique

"Droplets" - Tribute to Radu Carp by Giangiorgio Crisponi | 2014-10-31
Birds

When I saw the flamingo's head out of the water with all those drops on the neck and head, I immediately thought to Radu Carp who recently is working on with great skill and good results to make pretty pictures with droplets. I want to dedicate to him this photo Greetings Giangiorgio
>> Contribute a critique

Top to Bottom by Henk Boneschans | 2014-10-31
Landscape

Comments and Critique will REALLY be appreciated!
>> Contribute a critique

no title by Siamak Jafari | 2014-10-31
Nature

thanks in advance .
>> Contribute a critique

Getting closer to film by Edward Horn | 2014-10-30
Portraits

I'm trying a new workflow that seems to be getting my digital images closer to the sort of colors I am used to with film. What do you think?
>> Contribute a critique

Composition by Waldemar Szaraniec | 2014-10-31
Abstract

Welcome All :-). Thank You for every comment.
>> Contribute a critique

The Art of War by tony brandstetter | 2014-10-31
Documentary

One battle in many.
>> Contribute a critique

Evening Tranquility by Bjørn Breimo | 2014-10-31
Landscape

All comments are appreciated :)
>> Contribute a critique

Trick or treat... by Dimitris Vasiliou | 2014-10-31
Humor

As I write this introduction the door bell is ringing with children dressed up for Halloween normally accompanied by their parents and my wife runs and opens the door..'trick or treat', they shout. It was fifteen years ago that the doorbell rang and you can imagine her surprise when she opened the door...I heard her scream...I ran downstairs.. and I nearly died of laughter. Two of my friends and neighbors were at the doorstep dressed in drag. They borrowed most of their props from their wives and they came to give me a laugh...I hope it will make you laugh as well...-:)

Thank you for viewing and laughing....:-).
>> Contribute a critique

Retezat mountains by Claudiu Draghia | 2014-10-31
Nature

Thank you!
>> Contribute a critique

A Beauty Bush! by Janine Linning | 2014-10-30
Nature

Please look at the larger version. J
>> Contribute a critique

Any comments welcome. Thanks for Looking. by Mário Azevedo | 2014-10-31
Street

--MAA
>> Contribute a critique

Fantasie marchigiane by Sergio Gavardi | 2014-10-30
Landscape

Thanks for your comments and rate. Sergio
>> Contribute a critique

path between the seas by Leonardo Villalobos | 2014-10-30
Fine Art

Panama Canal 1914
>> Contribute a critique

Mamquam Mountain at Sunset - COMMENTS AND FEEDBACK WELCOME! by Cory Sine | 2014-10-31
Landscape

This was shot RAW using the HDR method with a Canon 60D before processing in Lightroom 3.6. It is part of my portfolio and I am considering it for enlargement into a photo-canvas for upcoming shows. Any feedback, criticism, and advice that people might have is greatly appreciated. I am aware of the small patch of snow to the right of the central peaks that is a little too white because of de-saturation. I will correct that in future prints and canvases.
>> Contribute a critique

Ice patterns and blue light by Brian Clark | 2014-10-30
Landscape

Comments welcome
>> Contribute a critique

Driftwood at Dusk - COMMENTS AND FEEDBACK WELCOME! by Cory Sine | 2014-10-31
Nature

This was shot combining the detail of my 50mm Canon Macro lens with the HDR method using a Canon 60D and was processed in Lightroom 3.6. I have made it part of my portfolio and am considering it for enlargement into a canvas print for future shows. I worry about the deep reds being a bit too saturated and would greatly appreciate any advice, criticism, and help anyone has.
>> Contribute a critique

no title by Siamak Jafari | 2014-10-31
Children

thanks in advance .
>> Contribute a critique

Fall Colors by David Carlson | 2014-10-30
Landscape

Just wondering what people think. I haven't manipulated this photo.
>> Contribute a critique

COLORS OF AUTUMN by MASSIMO ALBERTO BONELLI | 2014-10-31
Nature

Thanks for your comments.
>> Contribute a critique

... by Wolfgang Arnold | 2014-10-31
Fine Art

...
>> Contribute a critique

Mangrove by Kamaruddin Said | 2014-10-31
Landscape

A mangrove tree.
>> Contribute a critique

Nude Portrait by Richard Kemp | 2014-10-31
Nudes

Thank you for your thoughts...
>> Contribute a critique

northern sea by Maria Bostenaru | 2014-10-31
Landscape

blue green infrastructure
>> Contribute a critique

Final resting place... by Dimitris Vasiliou | 2014-10-31
Fine Art

It stopped being a boat and now it became a 'time sculpture'...some artistic soul left it there on the beach, a reminder of a bygone era..

Thank you for viewing and commenting.
>> Contribute a critique

Bathroom Light by Nick Turley | 2014-10-31
Nudes

Please feel free to comment. thank you
>> Contribute a critique

Asia Rainforest Series: Tiger Beetle by Shu-Shin Chin | 2014-10-30
Macro

Thanks for looking :)
>> Contribute a critique

Happy Halloween! by Natalia Lakes | 2014-10-31
Portraits

Thank you for viewing :-)
>> Contribute a critique

'The Sloppy Sandwich' by John Crosley | 2014-10-31
Street

A bus driver or organizer is smeared with sauce from an Arab flatbread sandwich while his woman pampers him before his Mercedes Sprinter (LIUKX) luxury jitney bus awaits taking passengers from Kyiv train station to regional Rivne, Ukraine. Your ratings, critiques and observations are invited and most welcome. If you rate harshly, very critically, or wish to make an observation, please submit a helpful and constructive comment; please share your photographic knowledge to help improve my photography. Thanks! Enjoy! john
>> Contribute a critique

On the Long Island shore by Dani Heller | 2014-10-30
Fine Art

Please view large
>> Contribute a critique