photo.net Elves , Sep 27, 2011; 01:46 a.m.
This photograph was chosen because the Elves think it is
interesting and worthy of discussion. When participating in the
Photograph of the Week forum, please offer a critique of the photo
-- address its strengths, its weaknesses.
Photograph by niki barbati
Patrick Hudepohl 
, Sep 27, 2011; 01:47 a.m.
Please note the following:
- This image has been selected for discussion. It is not necessarily the "best" picture the Elves have seen this week, nor is it a contest.
- Discussion of photo.net policy, including the choice of Photograph of the Week should not take place here, but in the Help & Questions Forum.
- The About Photograph of the Week page tells you more about this feature of photo.net.
- Before writing a contribution to this thread, please consider our reason for having this forum: to help people learn about photography. Visitors have browsed the gallery, found a few striking images and want to know things like why is it a good picture, why does it work? Or, indeed, why doesn't it work, or how could it be improved? Try to answer such questions with your contribution.
Sumon Mukherjee 
, Sep 27, 2011; 03:07 a.m.
Congratulations Niki for this POTW. I’m really happy to see that one of your photographs has been selected as POTW. This is a beautiful composition with masterful light-and-shadow management. Best regards.
niki barbati 

, Sep 27, 2011; 03:20 a.m.
thanks Sumon, I'm really proud to see my works chosen as photos of the week. is a photo taken almost by accident, I walked into that church in Trastevere, and expected it to end the marriage to take some shots when the couple came out and the light was so beautiful and inviting .... thanks to all
Rashed S
, Sep 27, 2011; 04:40 a.m.
Congratulations Niki, there is so much of fine elements in this image, specially the lighting and shadows here is very appealing and so the the atmosphere is very original, I your wise choice for the b/w format along with its related contrast and tone, they are of very high quality, the present of the couple is also a great add of life to this image and so well connecting it with the viewers.
All of the best.
Ken Thalheimer
, Sep 27, 2011; 07:38 a.m.
Love the atmosphere that comes across from this photo. The bride & who's walking her down the aisle at not only the beginning of the ceremony, but the beginning of an entire chapter in her life. You can almost feel the tension in them at the moment
Technically nicely done with good detail in the shadows & highlights
Alex Shishin 
, Sep 27, 2011; 08:40 a.m.
The end and the beginning. I don't recall ever seeing a wedding photo quite like this one. It is very nicely understated.
The presence of the church is overwhelming. Yet it is the couple, seemingly diminished by the surroundings, who command all of our attention.
Interestingly, this is the second time in the last several weeks when we don't see the bride's face. We hardly see much of the groom's face either. But this works nicely. In this way they become the universal bride and groom.
Fred G. 
, Sep 27, 2011; 11:43 a.m.
For me, the draw of the photo is the lighting and the couple walking into it. That takes up about one third or less of the photo. The rest of it doesn't really support that. The design on the floor, which is a substantial aspect of the photo, seems not to work with what I'm seeing and not to be dealt with strongly. The big podium in the shadowed area to the left doesn't do much for the overall photo. The shadowed areas simply supply an offset for the light but don't intrigue me in any way and don't hold much interest beyond being a foil for the light. But there is enough going on in the shadowed areas to draw my attention and then disappoint. As an idea, this works well. And in terms of the light on the couple, their gate, etc. it's nicely done. But as a whole, where often the devil is in the details, the detail and sub-plots here don't do much for me. They actually seem to get in the way. Though the cross on the door and the one hanging above the picture on the far wall, almost as a halo to the couple, are very nice touches.
Marie H , Sep 27, 2011; 01:20 p.m.
I know there is some debate as to altering people's images, however I could not express in words how I would prefer it to look so here goes: I dislike the top of the door frame and the light crack at right so I cloned it out and re cropped and re toned. Pardon me Nikki and congrats on photo of the week.
Marie H , Sep 27, 2011; 01:20 p.m.
I know there is some debate as to altering people's images, however I could not express in words how I would prefer it to look so here goes: I dislike the top of the door frame and the light crack at right so I cloned it out and re cropped and re toned. Pardon me Nikki and congrats on photo of the week.