Welcome to Photo.net: A Community of Photographers

Gallery > Rarindra Prakarsa > Photos > Care > Good Father

Photographer's Request for Critique

Good Father

Not God Father, but good father. taken in jakarta

Critiques

Ramón Vaamonde , September 13, 2006; 08:51 A.M.

I dont know how do you get this light but... your light is GREAT. COngrat, another amazing job.

Ekayana Surya , September 13, 2006; 08:58 A.M.

Wonderful... Nice light & tone...

Magnus Rönnkvist , September 13, 2006; 09:16 A.M.

I agree, beautiful light and atmosphere. It looks alot more like a painting than a photograph.

Well done!

/ Magnus

Paulo Barreto , September 13, 2006; 09:28 A.M.

First, this is an excellent image. No doubt about that. Congratulations my friend. Second, you take it with a Canon PowerShot G5 camera!!! Third, this is a manipulated photo. Now, in this particular image what is real and what is not? Love to know. Curious the not God but good father because God is Good and is Father.

Rejith Warrier , September 13, 2006; 09:39 A.M.

I havent seen much photos in my limited experience in PN with such a wonderful lighting, except may be from Daniel bayer or Mg Lizi ... Fantastic image and using a powershot G5. I would like to know the specifics and how you got that effect ... Would you be kind enough to share ???

Paulo Barreto , September 13, 2006; 10:01 A.M.

When I say manipulated I don't want to say that you cut or paste something in this image. I want to say that I think you use some software that produces that effect very common in your other work. What is the effect, or effects, is the question. But, perhaps that is a secret and I respect that. I repeat: excellent work!

Jef Van den Houte , September 13, 2006; 10:28 A.M.

Strong and captivating image with a very beautifull light

Sondra Kicklighter , September 13, 2006; 10:37 A.M.

Well captured, beautiful lighting and love that big old tree. 7/7

Razaq Vance , September 13, 2006; 11:02 A.M.

7\7

*****!!!!!!!!!

Pulok Pattanayak , September 13, 2006; 11:25 A.M.

Excellent!

putu suanditha , September 13, 2006; 11:28 A.M.

finally, my favourite photo uploaded..

this is one of my favourite photo by MR. Rarindra.. i believe, even this image is manipulated but the original is very dramatic. even taken by canon powershoot G5.. can anybody imagine how talented person is mr. rarindra? congratulation..

Wendy de Kok , September 13, 2006; 11:52 A.M.

Great atmosphere and light! Excellent

Pawel Sawicki , September 13, 2006; 03:28 P.M.

One of the best light I've ever seen. Wonderful picture. Congratulations.

Bora Benic , September 13, 2006; 03:40 P.M.

7/7

Perfect.Bora

Gerard Burgstede , September 13, 2006; 04:00 P.M.

Wow

Very beautiful. Almost looks like a 16/17th century painting. Amazing!

Gerard

(http://www/burgstede.com)

Giangiorgio Crisponi , September 13, 2006; 05:02 P.M.

Fantastica!!

excellent light and atmosphere, nice diagonal composition, bravo Rarindra, ciao Giangiorgio

Michael Lyons , September 13, 2006; 05:12 P.M.

7/7

Fantastic image--ML

Panayotis Papadopoulos , September 13, 2006; 05:45 P.M.

7/7

There is not much to say about your beautiful work my friend. I can not find words to descibe how much I like it, eventhough I also believe that it is somehow manipulated. But I wish if I could do the same!...excellent!

Kay C , September 13, 2006; 05:53 P.M.

Amazing lighting, wonderfully captured!

Michael Nigro , September 13, 2006; 07:06 P.M.

Perfect composition but it's still too dark.

Michael Haydon , September 13, 2006; 07:51 P.M.

7/7

Perfect.

Wayne Pinkston , September 13, 2006; 09:41 P.M.

A true work of art.

Denise L , September 13, 2006; 11:02 P.M.

Fairy Tale

This beautiful image looks like a scene from a happy, idyllic fairy tale. Exquisitally rendered. Regards. Denise.

Chung Lee , September 13, 2006; 11:36 P.M.

Wow, wow 7/7

Well composed, amazing lighting, excellent work. It makes me feel like I'm looking at a classic painting in a museum. Congrat!

Alec Ee , September 14, 2006; 12:01 A.M.

Superb composition and lighting. Congrats.

Marko Airismeri , September 14, 2006; 12:35 A.M.

This wonderful atmosphere contains a nice touch of unreality.

Jim Kerr , September 14, 2006; 12:38 A.M.

Rarindra, many of your photographs have some of the best color I've seen since I saw "Gone With The Wind" At a theater when I was in high school in the late '50s. Besides that, you have very great talent......Jim

Spencer Jimmie Lee , September 14, 2006; 01:22 A.M.

An Award Winning Picture. Excellent!!! I really love it. Thank you for sharing. :)

Salih Güler , September 14, 2006; 02:22 A.M.

7/7

excellent work=)

erwin bosman , September 14, 2006; 02:52 A.M.

the light is stunning !

erwin

Robert Semnic , September 14, 2006; 03:48 A.M.

I WANT TO TAKE PHOTO LIKE THIS ONE. CONGRATULATION

Kah Kit Yoong , September 14, 2006; 04:44 A.M.

I believe this is what they call 'artists' light'. Phenomenal capture. I thought from the thumbnail this was a shot of an oil painting.

Juan Pavon , September 14, 2006; 05:30 A.M.

Wonderful...evov0cative. Congrats

sahil banga , September 14, 2006; 06:16 A.M.

picture

this looks more like an abstract. kudos to u as its a celebrations in itself.

Salvatore Saitta , September 14, 2006; 07:36 A.M.

Even if I don't know what is real and what is manipulated in this picture, I find it fantastic! Wonderful :-)

Tomaso Nigris , September 14, 2006; 08:20 A.M.

Great work.

Javier Montero , September 14, 2006; 08:41 A.M.

Lord of the rings

Wow!!! It seems that they are in a scene of the Lord of the Rings.... Each of the persons are contentrated in their things... Congratulations...

Javi
Pedriza visions
My blog

Kaushik Chatterjee , September 14, 2006; 08:57 A.M.

7/7
Rarindra,

Extremely rich and colorful. Great tone and light efect. Just exquisite.

If you want, have a look...

Rarindra Prakarsa , September 14, 2006; 11:06 A.M.

tank you

Not manipulated mean no copy/paste here... burn/dodge/higher saturation in main object/...

PETER KING , September 14, 2006; 12:42 P.M.

Superlative. Makes me want to give up in despair

Stephane Robichaud , September 14, 2006; 01:31 P.M.

I guess he is saying that there is no cloning done here. All that you see in this photo is what was recorded by the camera. However, he did use some saturation and painting with light technique. In a good way.

I do find this photo absolutely impressive. You have developed a nice style. You do work on you photo digitally, but it is done in a very nice way and even after the work, this is still a photo to me.

Very nice work Rarindra. I would like to be able to have just one like this myself!

Markos George Hionos , September 14, 2006; 01:37 P.M.

lovely paint/photograph... i believe is heavily manipulated ..nevertheless a patently Great image !!!!!.

_ Cálico - NY, NY , September 14, 2006; 02:06 P.M.

WOW... I love it. You just caught a "keeper" and you should be very proud! Whew! Good luck and best wishes!

Stephane Valente , September 14, 2006; 03:46 P.M.

Beautiful light, atmosphere & composition. Great shot

Haleh Bryan , September 14, 2006; 04:39 P.M.

Good father, good image, good composition, and a whole lot of other good things!

Branimir Bencic , September 14, 2006; 05:44 P.M.

Fantastic light and photo. Congratulation.

Eric Gonzalez , September 14, 2006; 06:58 P.M.

FANTASTICO

I HAVE A QUESTION.....HOW DO YOU DO THIS PHOTO? THIS IS LIKE A PICTURE....CAN YOU SEY MY HOW TO DO FOR HAVE THIS EFECT?.... THANKS AND CONGRATULATIONS.

Alden Gray , September 14, 2006; 08:34 P.M.

Exceptionally well done

This photo and your other ones are exceptionally well executed.

I've seen people do effects like these with for instance AutoFx's Mystical Lighting plug-in but rarely as well as this. However you constructed your effects, you have a masterful eye and the all-important restraint not to go overboard with them.

Patrick Flynn , September 14, 2006; 08:43 P.M.

I love your technique. This is a beautiful photo.

Cherlyn . , September 14, 2006; 11:39 P.M.

Well, almost all have been said. This is indeed a 7/7 photo with perfect light & effect. Composition itself is excellent. Such a good candid moment.

Luca Rubini , September 15, 2006; 09:06 A.M.

Excellent

Fantastic shot. It really seems a painting!

Hannu Hentila , September 15, 2006; 02:40 P.M.

The colors are simply magical! This is one great photograph!

Joan Newhall , September 15, 2006; 05:24 P.M.

Lighting is beautiful and the setting is like a fairytale.

Basrie K , September 15, 2006; 06:32 P.M.

Stunning. as always!

Many people have been begging for Rarindra to share the secret recipe but to no success. Coming from the same country like him, I even once recommended him to exhibit his masterpieces to the Indonesian audience. No answer yet from him. He's making a history. I am not exaggerating, but take a look at his other fine works at fotografer.net. We will be amazed and kept begging! Rarindra, the world is watching! Might be begging. So, a first class exhibition is all yours. Why should wait? Must be lots of major sponsors willing to support, at least Canon Powershot plant factory manager and PS CS2. Congrats.

Luc Jacobs , September 16, 2006; 06:26 A.M.

Great light, wonderful composition. Regards.

James DeMoss , September 16, 2006; 07:05 A.M.

Thanks

You are truly one of the most inspiring artists here to date. I appreciate that you chose to share these with us

Beng J. , September 16, 2006; 09:41 A.M.

You have Style !

Wow ! What a beautiful picture with mystique light ! and you said it is not manipulated. You really got a unique style, which can be seen with all your photos. Somehow it is still a mystery for me, how you could capture all the wonderful light so beautifully. The right picture taken at the right place, on the right time of the day with the right light ?. Really good work and I like all your photos.

Jana Vanourkova , September 16, 2006; 10:27 A.M.


What a wonderful image, great quality of light here, cheers Jana

Jay Park , September 16, 2006; 11:13 A.M.

Great!

First of all, when I first time saw this, thought it was a picture instead of photograph. I like how we can see all the details on the tree, and how babies are doing their own things. I also like the trees at the back side. The mood of this photo is very attractive. Great job!

Ricardo Lago , September 17, 2006; 12:41 A.M.

Amazing.

Longtang Lin , September 18, 2006; 12:22 P.M.

wondeful !!!!!!!!

the lighting and color.. need to learn from you ..

Longtang John Lin

Robert Bennett , September 18, 2006; 06:14 P.M.

How?

How in the world did you get that texture and feel? I've never seen anything like it.

Bravo!

Peace, Bob

Robert Bennett , September 18, 2006; 10:51 P.M.

Set the time to 'Week'...

and you've got two oustanding images in the top five.

Most Deserved.

Peace, Bob

Luis Martínez , September 19, 2006; 09:04 A.M.

Best

Probably one of the best photos I've seen inside PN and outside. Whatever the post-processing used, the results are wonderful; what in my opinion reveals a great artistic sense. I would have liked to see the original photo; even that one should have been extremely high rated.

Tanya Truong , September 20, 2006; 01:06 A.M.

Simply perfect. My admiration. Best regards, Tanya.

Beau . , September 22, 2006; 10:59 A.M.

Looks just like a Maxfield Parrish painting.

Ben Wyrick , September 25, 2006; 09:18 P.M.

Your pictures capture a golden stillness and your use of light is like a master painter. I like how the people are leaning against the tree. There is a great separation between the tree and the background, almost as if the background were a movie set. Your photo has both great sharpness and a low-contrast haze.

Brett Wall , October 03, 2006; 01:44 P.M.

Yes, amazing technique. One little nitpick though, you might use different pieces of foliage when you insert them into different images. The foreground foliage in this image http://www.photo.net/photodb/photo?photo_id=5023820 has an uncanny resemblance to the one you have used here.

John North , October 07, 2006; 05:43 P.M.

Congrats.

Farooq Bhatti , October 14, 2006; 07:11 A.M.

Farooq Bhatti

One can't believe, but no way to escape. Perfect themetic photo. Well Done Friend

Zacarias Mata , October 21, 2006; 05:33 A.M.

Excellent!

Mehmet Tüzün , November 04, 2006; 12:22 P.M.

Perfect!

Francisca Vugts , March 18, 2007; 05:56 A.M.

jealousy...

Not only the colors and light are fantastic, I love the whole picture. The composition, the tree, the contrast between the old colors and the modern clothes, the couple of leaves on the left....just great!!

Charlie Widdis , March 18, 2007; 02:55 P.M.

Wow

I love this shot. 7/7. It just has this airy atmosphere.

roberta orlando , March 18, 2007; 04:36 P.M.

quietly simple

Rafael Cedano , April 06, 2007; 05:31 A.M.

Encantadora

Esa foto me parece impresionante, me encanta la forma en la que los colores calidos te hacen sentir dentro de la foto...
--
rC - Es tiempo de Conquistar el Mundo
Posicionamiento Web / SEO
Habitaquo - Pero con + Z

Jeff Holland , May 19, 2007; 04:06 P.M.

Amazing!!

Your work is pure magic! The passion you show in your work is so inspirational. Thank you for sharing your vision. Jeff

José Reynaldo da Fonseca , June 02, 2007; 03:22 P.M.

Big....!

Good... very good!

Aimelle LM , June 27, 2007; 03:39 A.M.

wonderful light and colors... I find the composition interesting as well and quite unusual. Like it :)

Kris Jacques , October 29, 2007; 06:35 A.M.

Shocked

Rarindra is a master craftsman; but as much a master of Photoshop as of photography. I've been teaching photography for 25 years and I know that what he is doing is the result of heavy manipulation (and there is much discussion and demonstration of his techniques on Photoshop sites all over the Net). This is more a demonstration of superb craftsmanship than great photography. If only Rarindra would say this openly. He clearly has enormous photographic and artistic talent, and a masterly command of Photoshop. I am mostly moved to write this because I feel sad that so very many innocent people, keen on photography, have said how much they admire the light, not knowing that such "light" can be fabricated. They will try to take true photographs that look like this and wonder what they are doing wrong. (One of my students first mentioned his photos, so I went to look myself.) So please Rarindra, you don't have to say HOW you do it (it is quite fair to keep such superlative techniques to yourself) but at least be honest and tell people that many of your images are as much computer creations as they are photographs. There is no shame in that. You can be proud of true works of art. Honesty will bring respect.

Rarindra Prakarsa , December 02, 2007; 08:10 A.M.

Thanks

Any comments are welcome.

@Kris: Many thanks...I will more open how to achieve photos like mine. (And thousands email received by me and some have answerd/replied) But please dont say that the light are fabricated. Because I always take photograph early morning in good weather. You sad that I am lie to everyone here?

Alberto Mascali , December 02, 2007; 02:21 P.M.

Kris's question

Introduction: the shot is beautiful, but Kris's question is justified. Can we define it a photography? Or painting, or graphic or what? The word photography is derived from ancient greek: fos, fotos = light grafo = to write then , written by light. Not written by photoshop. Best regards.

Jennifer Elser , February 10, 2008; 07:43 P.M.

I think this is an absolutely beautiful image. And I do think it is ok to alter or change your photographs to give them a different feel or quality or highlight what you want to stand out etc, but at what point in altering our photo's does it change from a photograph to a graphic image? if we alter our photo's so much to the point that if simply shown to someone they would not be able to tell whether it is a photo, a painting, etc, can we really still call that photography?? I would honestly love to see this image before the alterations. Either way, it is still a wonderfull image/photo, kudos to Rarindra for having the talent to create such beautiful art.

Ernesto Herrera , April 28, 2008; 01:51 P.M.

nice photo. i'm pretty sure that you used HDR for the technique here and all your photos. don't get me wrong, i like your photos.

Mikhail Aleksevich , August 28, 2008; 06:02 A.M.

very warm card! Fine!

Fabien Tschantz , December 30, 2008; 06:23 P.M.

Wonderfull !!

Wonderfull picture !! Its like a dream !!

Ghita Viorel , July 16, 2009; 12:16 P.M.

Amazing!Hutte hoch!(I agree:is not godfather!) All the best!

Contribute a critique

More Resources here at photo.net...

Similar / Related Photos  

View other images enjoyed by photo.net members who like this photo.

Find Related Photos


More Photos by Member

View Entire Portfolio