Why this was chosen as Photograph of the Week
This photograph was chosen because
the Elves think it is interesting and
worthy of discussion. Like we've done
on previous occasions, we are not
going to influence the discussion by
submitting our own opinions,
questions etc. Enjoy! (Read Discussion)
Photographer's Request for Critique
--agnes donnadieu
no title
no message
Critiques
Rev. Brent M
, October 01, 2004; 10:26 A.M.
7/7
Excellent!
Welcome to P.N., your portfolio is stunning I look forward to seeing much more.
Boris Aleksandrovsky , October 01, 2004; 10:28 A.M.
Welcome Agnes, excellent work. Model's right leg is slightly blurred, and if you crop a bit on the bottom you will get an impression that they are drifting in the clouds if that's what you want.
Bernard Declerck , October 01, 2004; 10:43 A.M.
excellent
very nice pic ! well done ! 7/7
Marc Doyon 
, October 01, 2004; 11:11 A.M.
Sergey Efimov , October 01, 2004; 11:43 A.M.
7+7!!!
Paolo Rella , October 01, 2004; 12:44 P.M.
excellent... no title well!
Jean Stoque , October 01, 2004; 12:57 P.M.
J'aime vraiment beaucoup!Beau et dynamique....
Francesco Martini
, October 01, 2004; 01:01 P.M.
very nice and original!!!!
Umair Ghani
, October 01, 2004; 01:32 P.M.
fantatsic & enagmatic. idea & composition r brilliant.
Jos Van Poederooyen , October 01, 2004; 01:53 P.M.
Original
Intriguing shot.Love the whole sense of motion.
Jacques Henry
, October 01, 2004; 02:21 P.M.
Very refreshing!... and strangely scarry with the dog... a modern Little Red Hood...
and welcome to PNet
John Barclay , October 01, 2004; 02:50 P.M.
Unique and emotional
I love it! A fresh (I hate that overused term..) and unique perspective. Terrific!
Wernher S , October 01, 2004; 03:17 P.M.
Wonderful. Stands out amongst all the other excellent shots.
Bente D.-Nielsen
, October 01, 2004; 03:37 P.M.
Special .... very special. Original and eyecatching as he..
Martino Balestreri , October 01, 2004; 04:01 P.M.
Eccezionale! Complimenti! ciao.
John Peri 
, October 01, 2004; 04:59 P.M.
Marc Aubry 
, October 01, 2004; 07:02 P.M.
7/7
Spactacular! Great photo!
Felix Hug
, October 01, 2004; 07:40 P.M.
Hi.
Its one of the best photographs I've seen here for quite some time. Its icredible heart warming, it has humor, its highly original, its beautiful,its poetic, its artful... I can hear the music looking at it. ... I wished I could look at pictures like this more often...
Oasis Bear aka Bart Aldrich , October 01, 2004; 08:43 P.M.
My favorite of this pair of images. Delightfully airy & fun!
Boonwed Teo , October 01, 2004; 09:28 P.M.
I like your works. Hopefully ,the large will look better.
Wilson Tsoi 
, October 01, 2004; 09:41 P.M.
Serendipity...full of life!
Derek Au , October 02, 2004; 12:43 A.M.
lovely
This is a magical shot. Perfect. I couldn't imagine it working with any of the elements removed. The companion by her side, her legs in movement (skipping, probably), the billowing skirt, the hands positioned so daintily. Someone mentioned little red riding hood, and I agree, it is like a fairy tale.
And the clincher- they're running into the sea. Beautiful.
Abdullah AlQahtani
, October 02, 2004; 03:11 A.M.
Igor Diamandi , October 02, 2004; 05:43 A.M.
WOW
Cristina Fumi , October 02, 2004; 12:02 P.M.
Jan Scherders , October 02, 2004; 02:15 P.M.
Joy of Life
Agnes,
this is why we are photographers !! O what a great image. Thanks for joining photo.net
Jayme Hall - Bardstown, KY
, October 02, 2004; 05:49 P.M.
Original and cute! Love the hand positioning.
Steve Miranda , October 02, 2004; 07:41 P.M.
Very unusual and beautiful!
Rich Evans
, October 02, 2004; 08:23 P.M.
Huh???
You have got to be kidding me...I can't believe all the high ratings that this image has received. 1-its partially out of focus, 2-its acatually MOSTLY out of focus. It looks like most of the image was manipulated in PS but to what point? Sorry for venting at this particular image, but the high ratings of images which are mediocre at best is becoming ludicrous. If you would all start looking at images with the intent of helping others take better photos rather than patting each other on the back in order to get your images on the first page, than this site would be much better off.....OK I'm done
Wolfgang Lienbacher , October 02, 2004; 09:46 P.M.
@Rich:
so these are your only arguments? oh my.
By just quickly looking at your pictures i can tell you, why this image gets better ratings.
the composition is strong, eyecatching, and the image manipulation works.
this is art man! most of the stuff you see on this page (photo.net), is art!
earlier the images were manipulated in the darkroom, now they are in photoshop, time moves, as does photography, and it will move further on.
What if painting had not changed between renaissance and biedermeier? the same is now happening with photography, it's changing from analog manipulation in the darkroom, to digital manipulation on a computer - only because an image had obviously been edited in the computer, it doesn't mean that it isn't well done. think about it.
---
great image, perfect editing, perfect composition. it simply works. 7/7 - well done.
Rafael S. , October 02, 2004; 10:13 P.M.
7/7
Outstanding. Im speechless.
marco prenninger , October 03, 2004; 07:11 A.M.
just wonderful!!!! the way dhe is holding her hands, is a very nice detail, i love this whole photo, even with the dog ;-) cause usually i don't like dogs, and animals on photos....but in this case its different!!!
Howard Dion
, October 03, 2004; 08:23 A.M.
Andrzej Dragan
, October 03, 2004; 10:55 A.M.
Only a woman could create such a masterpiece :)
Alok Patel , October 03, 2004; 01:20 P.M.
Christophe Debon
, October 03, 2004; 05:27 P.M.
7/7
Jim McConnell
, October 03, 2004; 08:07 P.M.
Simply Irresistible! Very artistic composition. 7/7
Liv Edgeworth , October 03, 2004; 10:57 P.M.
lovely ... looking forward to more agnes
Kay C
, October 04, 2004; 03:50 A.M.
refreshing, surreal, feminine, and on top of that, very beautiful.
Rich Evans
, October 04, 2004; 07:42 A.M.
Wolfgang...
Comparing my images to anything like this is like comparing apples and oranges - My stuff is not intended to be art - merely a record of things I observe. If you do a search of the top photos (bt average) of the last five years, you'll see some truely stunning work - most of which I think you would also consider art. For example, take a look at the portfolios of these contributors:
http://www.photo.net/photodb/user?user_id=484267,
http://www.photo.net/photodb/user?user_id=543917,
http://www.photo.net/photodb/member-photos?include=all&user_id=609092,
http://www.photo.net/photodb/user?user_id=628554,
http://www.photo.net/photodb/user?user_id=947345,
http://www.photo.net/shared/community-member?user_id=53127,
All of these and many more are standards by which I judge and evaluate images in order to qualify for a '7' rating. This image and others in the portfolio simply do not meet those criteria. I'm sorry if my standard of 'art' does not match that of the others here, but I just don't see that this image meets the criteria for a 7/7. --Rich
pascale grenier , October 08, 2004; 07:08 P.M.
Ritch
really...some people here are getting me nervous...after your bright demonstration, ritch, I only need to provide one answer : take 5 minutes and visit : http//:www.donadieustudio.com
maybe, if the temperature is fine, if everything is cool around, going there - maybe - you will learn that photography is not just a question of focus...
Christophe Debon
, October 09, 2004; 03:17 A.M.
I do agree with you Pascale...
Felix Hug
, October 14, 2004; 04:54 P.M.
Rich, or what makes a photograph
We all learned about focus, in focus, out of focus.. well maybe one of the first rules,no? Then later we learn about colors, color combinations and so on. We learn about rules of third and how to crop, to use a frame.
And then? If you follow all this rules you get a great shot? No, wrong!!!
If Ilook at some of the greatest shots of all time, a lot of them are grainy.. or out of focus, or no rule of thirds, or cropped "strangely". The beauty about photography is that often the best pictures break all this rules to show us something we dont see on a daily base. Almost all of these photographs though have one thing in common: Content, message, emotion!.. so does this photograph. It does not only capture what I see, but more important, what I cant see! It triggers emotions and tickles my senses. it stimulates my brain.
Evgeniy Shaman
, October 15, 2004; 03:39 A.M.
Philip Turner - San Francisco, CA
, October 20, 2004; 03:27 A.M.
Significant Image Creation
I love this fanciful image. Light, dreamy and romantic I'd expect Audrey Hepburn to be at the top of those legs! Superb sensitive created image. I wondered how many takes/attempts you made at this particular image before you were happy with this end result? The best thing about your images is that they defy all the conventional rules for photography yet they illustrate very simple and somewhat conventional themes and emotions. Just lovely image creation!
Bernard Declerck , October 20, 2004; 05:47 A.M.
makes me happy
i always enjoy life.
and this picture makes me even more happy !
very interesting image !
thanks.
Yanne Golev , October 22, 2004; 06:43 P.M.
ABSOLUTELY FANTASTIC, REMINS OF ALLICE IN WONDERLAND AND MUCH MOORE !!!
100% PRO WORK :)
BEST OF ALL
Alexei Gourianov , October 25, 2004; 01:53 P.M.
Superb story telling keeping a mystery, sexy, a go go
Yuri Bonder 
, October 30, 2004; 11:15 A.M.
77
Pierre Casanova , November 21, 2004; 02:57 P.M.
Une photo fantastique...
Congrats for this marvellous moment... out of "Amelie Poulain". Not for the colors, but for the contrast in the sky and fairy-like atmosphere giving by the differently blurred parts.
A dream come true.
Jean Pierre Romeyer , December 06, 2004; 12:25 P.M.
Karim Damien Ghantous
, January 27, 2008; 01:43 A.M.
I totally love this shot. It is out of focus but that doesn't detract from the image overall. Philip's Audrey Hepburn comment is apt.
Your other beach shot may be better in one or two elements (the position of the woman's legs, the higher shutter speed) but on the whole this is the better one.
Alparslan Berik , January 27, 2008; 04:38 A.M.
Simply put, lovely picture with a touch of elegance. Thank you for sharing
Heiko Mausolf , January 27, 2008; 06:30 A.M.
Great
Excellent. Reminds me of Eliott Erwitt's work, and it wouldn't look misplaced amongst his pictures.
Regards, Heiko
JDM von Weinberg 
, September 24, 2009; 04:55 P.M.
I can see why it was chosen. Great and extraordinarily eye-catching. I find it makes me smile.
Send a free photo eCard
Photo eCards from photo.net are a way to email someone a photo.net Gallery photo
with your personal greeting or message. Send an eCard to your contacts to announce
your portfolio on photo.net. Send one of your own photos as an eCard to ask
another photo.net member to write a critique of it. Share photos
and portfolios that you have discovered on photo.net with your friends. Or
just send someone a greeting or message for
a birthday, holiday, or other occasion or observance.
The recipients will receive an email from
photo.net announcing that they have received the eCard, with a link back to
photo.net. When the recipients follow the link, the photo and your message will
be presented to them in a special eCard format.
The easiest way to see how eCards work and what they look like
is just to send yourself one!
photo.net eCards are free: by sending one, you are letting others know
about photo.net and the exceptional photographers on the site! We won't charge you
for that. The email addresses you enter into this form will be kept private. Send as many
eCards as you like, but please don't turn this feature into a spam-a-thon.