A Site for Photographers by Photographers

Photographer's Request for Critique

Bare Naked Anorexic

I really hope you like this but I will be happy if you hate it too.

Feedback appreciated.


Richard Spurdens , April 02, 2010; 09:04 A.M.

Richard Spurdens

Certainly different and a good concept, but not sure it works for me. However it has give me an idea for a future shoot, so thanks for that.

Is this comment helpful?

Pierre Dumas , April 02, 2010; 09:06 A.M.

Most original kind of nude!

I've never seen something similar to that!


Is this comment helpful?

John Matheo , April 02, 2010; 09:11 A.M.


The idea is so outstanding and the light is superb, a wonderful image that I never stopped studying, thank you for sharing it my friend and wishing you all of the best.

Is this comment helpful?

Owen O'Meara , April 02, 2010; 09:56 A.M.


I tried to rate it 7/7 but the rules would not allow it thus the sixes. This flat out rocks. It is original, fun to look at and beautifully framed.



Is this comment helpful?

Bulent Celasun , April 02, 2010; 03:29 P.M.

Mr. McCracken, the forum rules are very strict about the selection of the category "nude".
And, your above submission disregards it seriously... as this is no nude!
Still, you will likely be forgiven because the proper category for this one does not exist in the list provided:
Pure Fun :)

Is this comment helpful?

Saleem Khawar , April 02, 2010; 04:26 P.M.

Great portrait

Is this comment helpful?

David McCracken , April 03, 2010; 04:21 A.M.

In reply...

Richard, Thanks for leaving a comment. I look forward to see the image you create that this inspires.

Pierre, I do try to be original sometimes. Thanks a lot.

John, I am humbled. Thanks a lot.

Owen, The numbers game on this site is something I have never liked. Comments are what counts the most although it is nice to see a lot of ratings. Thanks for the kind comment. I am glad you like this.

Bulent, Point taken! I should have got her to remove the bikini from her fingers are remove her bracelet. Fun it was! Thanks a lot. ;-)

Saleem, Perhaps not but thanks for saying so.

Thanks everyone.

Dave Barstow , April 03, 2010; 06:13 A.M.


Wow David... you have outdone yourself with this one! Masterfully creative and superbly crafted... with a message. What more could one want?

Is this comment helpful?

David McCracken , April 03, 2010; 11:28 A.M.


Thanks for the comment! I have to be honest and say I wasn't sure if anyone would see a message in this or not.

Jim Phelps , April 03, 2010; 11:51 A.M.


Very creative, was this planned or did it evolve???

Jim Phelps

Is this comment helpful?

David McCracken , April 03, 2010; 01:02 P.M.


That's a very good question. It wasn't planned. Did it evolve? Obviously it did but I am not sure what it evolved out of.... boredom... alcohol... having too much time or a mix of those and more.

Thanks for stopping by!

Richard Spurdens , April 03, 2010; 01:13 P.M.

Richard Spurdens

David I forgot to say its a great title by the way

Is this comment helpful?

David McCracken , April 04, 2010; 03:54 A.M.


Thanks again. I believe the title to be quite Googleable but unfortunately not Bingable.

Kallol Majumdar , April 04, 2010; 03:17 P.M.

Wow!!! What an !dea...brilliant image...my best

Is this comment helpful?

David McCracken , April 05, 2010; 03:50 A.M.


Thanks for stopping by!

Bob Kurt , April 05, 2010; 11:20 A.M.

:) funny!

I really like this photo.

Is this comment helpful?

David McCracken , April 05, 2010; 12:49 P.M.


Thanks for the comment. Humour wasn't my intention here but if it makes you laugh then that's fine.

Richard Ramirez , April 07, 2010; 01:54 P.M.

Hello David, very nice and creative image of Art abstract! Thanks for your comment in my recent picture. best regards.

Is this comment helpful?

David McCracken , April 08, 2010; 02:37 A.M.


Thank you! You are welcome.

Maurizio Moro , April 08, 2010; 07:48 A.M.

A great and clever idea and composition!

Is this comment helpful?

David McCracken , April 08, 2010; 10:53 A.M.


Thanks! I am glad you like it.

Biliana Rakocevic , April 09, 2010; 10:50 A.M.

Intersting, but I do not like your title with this anorexic... well this is your point of view! What is this!? you have such a wrong notion of woman... why dont you shoot a Man and do the same? wont be so funny? well ... I am disappointed in this photo!!!


Is this comment helpful?

Contribute a critique

Similar / Related Photos  

View other images enjoyed by photo.net members who like this photo.

Find Related Photos