A Site for Photographers by Photographers

Gallery > Radu Carp > Photos > Winter > The guardian

Photographer's Request for Critique

The guardian

thank you for your opinions


Miguel A. Leyva , February 06, 2011; 08:49 A.M.

Very good B&W image, Radu

Is this comment helpful?

Mehmet Akin , February 06, 2011; 10:17 A.M.

very beautiful bw.landscape..congrats

Is this comment helpful?

Arup Bhattacharjee , February 06, 2011; 10:19 A.M.

great presentation. silhouetted tree in this bright landscape has made the composition something different..

Is this comment helpful?

Joaquin Tornel , February 06, 2011; 01:06 P.M.

Hola Radu.

Excelente encuadre de este colosal paisaje invernal. Buen trabajo.

Un cordial saludo, Joaquín.

Is this comment helpful?

Mark Weir , February 06, 2011; 01:18 P.M.

Well done

The shadows in the BW image give it good depth, well done........best regars

Is this comment helpful?

harry tsappas , February 06, 2011; 04:36 P.M.

Very nicely caught,composition,light and weather pattern,very nice work

Is this comment helpful?

Art Lionse , February 06, 2011; 04:52 P.M.

Very nice capture, like the contrast feeling.

Is this comment helpful?

Hamid Reza Farzandian , February 06, 2011; 05:05 P.M.

Hi Radu!

A stunning landscape b/w capture with amazing diverse tonaliyt, contrast and composition. Bravo.


Is this comment helpful?

Anabela Sequeira , February 06, 2011; 07:37 P.M.

Great composition. Gorgeous shadows, detailed highlights. Very well done! Kind regards.

Is this comment helpful?

Grigoriy A. , February 06, 2011; 08:11 P.M.

Human creation as fragile fence against power of nature... Excellent work with nice and balanced composition...

Is this comment helpful?

Gallego Caldas Jordi , February 07, 2011; 03:56 A.M.

perfecta composicón y detalle. excelente b/w, 7, saludos

Is this comment helpful?

Maurizio Moro , February 07, 2011; 04:21 A.M.

6...from Italy!

Nature in B/W is done only for masters!

Is this comment helpful?

A.K. Sircar , February 07, 2011; 05:32 A.M.

Radu, you have captured a superb image, with deft touches of artistry. Composition,exposure and  subtles tones of black & white are admirable.

Is this comment helpful?

Cosmin Lucian ALBA , February 07, 2011; 06:37 A.M.

Hi Radu

Great choice of B/W. The composition is great. I love that you chose the vertical composition. Fits very well here.

My best regards. Cosmin

Is this comment helpful?

Ramon Romero , February 07, 2011; 12:30 P.M.

Hola Radu.

Bonita composicion y una edicion atrevida ,ademas de original.Saludos.

Is this comment helpful?

Paul Casagrande , February 07, 2011; 12:32 P.M.

In questo caso il titolo è importante,complimenti !   Ciao Paul

Is this comment helpful?

Lawrence Paiken , February 07, 2011; 07:58 P.M.

Fantastic shot...it shows the magnitude of the mountain. Well done, my friend. Regards, Lawrence.

Is this comment helpful?

R Sekhar , February 07, 2011; 08:20 P.M.

Truly delightful composition and apt title. Great work!

Is this comment helpful?

Gail Harmer , February 08, 2011; 01:48 A.M.

Very impressive shot Radu! The choice of Black and White was a good one for this image, such lovely mountains you have that surround you.  Your work in your dark and shadow areas is very well done, and the mountains truly show their majesty.  Love  the title.  Sincere regards,Gail

Is this comment helpful?

Antonio Giusti , February 08, 2011; 03:26 P.M.

It's a winter time. Very nice image, OK vertical format that enhance high mounts. Best regards from Italy, Antonio

Is this comment helpful?

Lester A. Garcia , February 08, 2011; 09:23 P.M.

A wonderful snowscape with nice tones of b&w. Great photo.

Is this comment helpful?

Larry Greenbaum , February 08, 2011; 11:41 P.M.

Excellent B&W, Radu.  I agree with Gail.  You have captured the grandeur of these mountains well.  Is the guardian the mountain or the fence?  Interesting title.   I like the way that the cloud above the mountain enhances the mountain and snow.  The fence and cloud together create a most interesting visual frame for the image.  You had an excellent eye in capturing this scene this way. Congratulations.

Is this comment helpful?

Tolo Duran , February 09, 2011; 03:34 P.M.

Precioso paisaje, magnifica composición y perspectiva, con una estupenda atmósfera y excelente b&w.

Un cordial saludo -Tolo.

Is this comment helpful?

Rashed S , February 10, 2011; 03:27 A.M.

Good Morning

Outstanding landscape work, the vertical lay out here is superb and bring out the bees of this amazing place, your lighting is so well set and so the DOF where the most fine details been obtained, this work remind me with Ansel Adam quality of work.

Thank you for sharing it and wishing you all of the best.

Is this comment helpful?

John Peri , February 10, 2011; 04:03 A.M.

Excellent composition and texture, bravo. The tree is particularly well placed, giving the eye a focal point from which to travel. 

Is this comment helpful?

Grant newland , February 10, 2011; 05:16 A.M.

A very beautiful BW landscape indeed... congrats.

Is this comment helpful?

Andrew Piotrowski , February 10, 2011; 05:37 A.M.


Very skilfully painted with great light and tonality.

Is this comment helpful?

Kallol R , February 10, 2011; 07:26 A.M.

Very nice composition.Well presented in B/W.The human made barrier is enhancing the image.

My best regards.


Is this comment helpful?

Fabrizio R. , February 11, 2011; 03:22 A.M.

Cute composition, very good winter mood!

Is this comment helpful?

sue tye , February 11, 2011; 11:08 A.M.

Nice capture Radu.... I like i and so does PN, a lot by the looks of it. Well done! 

Is this comment helpful?

Pep Mir , February 11, 2011; 05:04 P.M.

Hola Radu

Tus paisajes de invierno siempre son fascinantes.


Is this comment helpful?

Keith Lancaster , February 12, 2011; 10:24 A.M.

Excellent B/W work, fantastic scene.

Is this comment helpful?

Mari R , February 13, 2011; 08:29 A.M.

Wonderful view, great light and shapes. Love it!  Mari

Is this comment helpful?

Patsy Dunn , February 13, 2011; 02:24 P.M.


  Breathtaking b/w image with amazing lighting & details.  Take care, Patsy

Is this comment helpful?

Esben Utgård , February 13, 2011; 06:53 P.M.

Great light, nice tones and good comp. Thanks for sharing

Is this comment helpful?

El Porte-Bonheur , February 14, 2011; 05:19 A.M.

Breathtaking scenery. Good choice for b/w - compliments Radu!

Is this comment helpful?

Julio Segura Carmona , February 16, 2011; 06:14 A.M.


Buena imagen, preciosa luz y gran edición, saludos Radu.

Is this comment helpful?

Raymond Borg , February 16, 2011; 11:05 A.M.

Beautiful presentation Radu. Love the tones and composition. Congrats.

Is this comment helpful?

SAM COMTOIS , February 16, 2011; 10:04 P.M.

hi Radu.. the fence adds great detail here plays well with the lighting .. sam

Is this comment helpful?

Andrei Barbu , February 17, 2011; 06:24 A.M.

Hello Radu

Great image, love the composition!

Is this comment helpful?

Claudiu Draghia , March 04, 2011; 04:16 A.M.

I have no words, congratulations! 7

Is this comment helpful?

Bela Laszlo Molnar , September 18, 2013; 12:58 P.M.

Very nice sharp fence, the single tree, but the mountain lacks sharpness and the sky, the fine clouds has some hallow, or some kind of artifacts around them. Viewing on an extremely fine pixel monitor. Still a very nice composition.

Is this comment helpful?

Contribute a critique

Similar / Related Photos  

View other images enjoyed by photo.net members who like this photo.

Find Related Photos