A Site for Photographers by Photographers

Why this was chosen as Photograph of the Week

This photograph was chosen because the Elves think it is interesting and worthy of discussion. When participating in the Photograph of the Week forum, please offer a critique of the photo -- address its strengths, its weaknesses. (Read Discussion)

Photographer's Request for Critique

Defying time

Comments are welcome!

Best regards,
Marianna

Critiques

Rick Du Boisson , February 15, 2011; 05:56 P.M.

What a spectacular sky! The bright glow of the interior lights combine with the flaming clouds to give the impression the Coloseum is burning the ground. Very well done, RickDB

Is this comment helpful?

Grigoriy A. , February 15, 2011; 07:56 P.M.

Quite astonishing work!

Is this comment helpful?

Deidre McNamara , February 15, 2011; 08:13 P.M.

Most beautiful...

Wonderful shot. The colors are awesome. Right place, right time. Congrats, DMc

Is this comment helpful?

Art X , February 15, 2011; 09:05 P.M.

very well done. nicely captured and edited. The sky highlights are a particularly nice effect. compliments

Is this comment helpful?

Neil Jolly , February 16, 2011; 12:56 A.M.

A spectacular scene, superbly photographed Marianna! The lighting on the building, and the beautiful sunset combine to make this an outstanding image. Well done!

All the best,
Neil

Is this comment helpful?

Radu Carp , February 16, 2011; 03:09 A.M.

Splendid moment and location for this composition,light is so pleasantly,regards.

Is this comment helpful?

Pierre Dumas , February 16, 2011; 03:29 A.M.

Wonderful spectacle!

The best picture of this famous object I've ever seen! Seven all the way!

PDE

Is this comment helpful?

Claudio Castelli , February 16, 2011; 03:33 A.M.

Excellent

7

Is this comment helpful?

Gallego Caldas Jordi , February 16, 2011; 03:50 A.M.

Bravo, expectacular!!

Is this comment helpful?

Xavier Corcobado , February 16, 2011; 08:17 A.M.

Great view and colours Best regards.

Xavier Corcobado xcorcobado.blogspot.com

Is this comment helpful?

Pekka Porokara , February 16, 2011; 08:30 A.M.

like photo!! fine work!!

Is this comment helpful?

Mircea Tiron-Tudor , February 16, 2011; 08:40 A.M.

Beautiful ! Very well done !

Greetings, Mircea

Is this comment helpful?

Anne S , February 16, 2011; 11:02 A.M.

Very nice image and great processing! 

Is this comment helpful?

Marianna Safronova , February 16, 2011; 11:35 A.M.

Thank you all very much for your comments and ratings!

 

Best regards,

Marianna

niki barbati , February 16, 2011; 11:50 A.M.

i live in rome, i never see nothing like this! excellent 7

Is this comment helpful?

Wayne Sadler , February 16, 2011; 12:21 P.M.

Your artful re-creation in light of this historic place may be the greater masterpiece.  Congratulations, Marianna. 

Is this comment helpful?

Giovanni Rhodes Pasta , February 16, 2011; 01:50 P.M.

Beautiful !!!!!

Is this comment helpful?

Wendy de Kok , February 16, 2011; 03:07 P.M.

This is so beautiful, the colors and light, magical, bravo!!!!

Is this comment helpful?

George Trakakis , February 16, 2011; 04:55 P.M.

IMPRESSIVE!!!!!!!!!!

Is this comment helpful?

Hamid Reza Farzandian , February 16, 2011; 05:14 P.M.

Marianna!

Just amazing! Bravo.

Hamid.

Is this comment helpful?

Sumon Mukherjee , February 17, 2011; 03:29 A.M.

Excellent composition with brilliant light-effect and wonderful color tonality. Utilization of the clouds is really artistic. An image with fantastic backdrop. Best rating. Best regards.

Is this comment helpful?

Arnav Mukherjee , February 17, 2011; 04:37 P.M.

Superb work!

Excellent center composition with superb light and color. Love the artistic use of the clouds.

Cheers

Arnav

Is this comment helpful?

Vincenzo Corbo , February 17, 2011; 05:14 P.M.

This definetely one of the best shot of the Colosseum I've ever seen.

Colors, point of view and details.

Is this comment helpful?

Thadd . , February 18, 2011; 08:03 A.M.

WOW!

What an amazing capture of this familiar scene. I have to agree with the other critiquers who've stated this is the best shot of the Colisseum we've  seen.

Is this comment helpful?

Emmanuel Enyinwa , February 18, 2011; 07:32 P.M.

7!

Wow, wow, WOW!!

Is this comment helpful?

Monte Stinnett , February 18, 2011; 11:02 P.M.

The way the light shines on the coliseum is really spectacular and along with the clouds makes it a striking image.

Is this comment helpful?

Pamela Franklin , February 19, 2011; 09:35 A.M.

WOW ............. Just beautiful!

Best regards, Pamela

Is this comment helpful?

Anonymous, March 01, 2011; 06:46 A.M.

Defying time

 Love the picture, I think the light in the arches is incredibly beautiful.  Love the color, sharpness. Good job.

Respectfully, I don't like the editing of the sky, the clouds are clones of each other. Ask yourself what is the subject? The coliseum or the sky? In my opinion the sky takes away from the subject.

Thanks. 

 

Is this comment helpful?

Lech Dobrzanski , March 02, 2011; 08:04 A.M.


crop

I found a passage  here which can evoke some emotions. This crop has something of Boklin's  one way passage (IMO).

Is this comment helpful?

Ed Logan , March 03, 2011; 05:16 A.M.

Awesome

I was wondering did you use photoshop on this or is this just the right place at the right time? I love how you captured it head on following the rule of thirds.I also like how it gives the effect that the coliseum is on fire. Great capture & a great subject. I am sure there is so much more to say about this Photo but I don't have the time right now .Great Job.

Is this comment helpful?

Aykut Turhan , March 07, 2011; 08:04 A.M.

I'm speechless! No point to criticise for me, bravo!

Is this comment helpful?

Lex Linghorn , March 13, 2011; 07:29 P.M.

C'mon

I can't believe people buy into these fake images and I can't believe photo.net sells out.

Is this comment helpful?

Steven Edwards , March 31, 2011; 07:29 P.M.

The image is clearly photoshopped (pay attention to the clouds, there are exact duplicates).  However,  that is not to say that it isn't a wonderful piece of art!! 

Mastering photoshop enables one to create art that otherwise cannot be captured through a lense.  As long as the work isn't passed off as an actual photograph, I applaud & encourage works like this!

Is this comment helpful?

kambiz babakhani , April 06, 2011; 05:52 P.M.

kambiz

I love the color in this picture, very nice

Is this comment helpful?

Christopher Wheeler , May 10, 2011; 01:44 A.M.

I like the colors and how the orange contrasts the sky. I also like the way that some of the archways are lit up and some are dark, it makes you move around the picture, the leading lines of the foreground pull you back in once you are done looking at the beautiful sky.

Is this comment helpful?

Slavomir Misko , April 23, 2012; 12:30 P.M.

fantastic!!!

Is this comment helpful?

Similar / Related Photos  

View other images enjoyed by photo.net members who like this photo.

Find Related Photos