A Site for Photographers by Photographers

Photographer's Request for Critique




Indraneel Majumdar , June 12, 2011; 10:36 P.M.

Extremely beautiful! Gorgeous light and nice surreal effect.

Is this comment helpful?

Bob Kurt , June 12, 2011; 10:45 P.M.

Very good photo. congrats...

Is this comment helpful?

R Sekhar , June 12, 2011; 10:51 P.M.

Very beautiful image and composition. BW - Sekhar

Is this comment helpful?

Gail Harmer , June 13, 2011; 02:37 A.M.

Excellent Macro Scott, love the title! A very 'eye-catching' shot, beautiful reflections in the water...and re the water, love it's appearance, I can't really find the exact word I want, but it is most effective. The irridescence colors of the frog really stand out. Your lighting also was very important in the final result of this composition.

Congrats on good timing, in camera skills, and of course your excellent editing, sincerely, Gail

Is this comment helpful?

Boeboe Fiel , June 13, 2011; 03:06 A.M.

Impressive picture, and great to see how violation of the "rule of thirds" can yield something wonderful.

Is this comment helpful?

Grayham Allott , June 13, 2011; 04:44 A.M.

Hi Scott................

........ Oh Yes!....... Ribbit, ribbit. ribbit. Great shot and great title.

With the Cane Toad epidemic in Australia heading towards WA we are not too "indisposed" to these amphibians, however you have captured (and presented) this one exceedingly well.

Well done.


Is this comment helpful?

Ruud Albers , June 13, 2011; 04:59 A.M.

A beautiful shot with very nice lighting and reflections, Scott!

Is this comment helpful?

Mike Palermiti , June 13, 2011; 02:42 P.M.


Very good capture.

Too bad the water was not more rippled or turbid to avoid that third eye from being revealed.

Best Regards,  Mike

Is this comment helpful?

Christal Steele , June 14, 2011; 10:19 P.M.


Interesting how we all view things so differently, because the '3rd eye' Mike just mentioned is the very thing that appeals to me about this image.  It sets it apart from the average, IMO.  Of course the colors, tack sharpness and overall look of this unique frog would all make this a standout image anyway.  Excellent catch!

Is this comment helpful?

Scott Cromwell , June 14, 2011; 11:10 P.M.

Thanks everyone.  I think Mike was just trying to get a rise out of me, Christal.  It's certainly possible, but it's hard for me to believe someone thinking the reflected eye not only doesn't add to the appeal of this shot, but it makes it less so enough to make a comment about it.  I'm not even sure I would have posted it if it wasn't for the reflection.  If I'm wrong and others think the same as Mike, I'd love to hear it.

Bob Belanger , June 15, 2011; 06:00 P.M.

Nice closeup.  Kermit seems pretty content.

Is this comment helpful?

Pekka Porokara , August 12, 2011; 06:05 P.M.

I like photos!!

Is this comment helpful?

patrick coombes , October 13, 2012; 10:50 A.M.

Excellent capture, for sure the 3rd eye is doing it all! Good eye Scott!! ;-)

Is this comment helpful?

Contribute a critique

Similar / Related Photos  

View other images enjoyed by photo.net members who like this photo.

Find Related Photos