A Site for Photographers by Photographers

Photographer's Request for Critique




Tony Mistretta , March 15, 2012; 03:25 P.M.

This is hilarious. Congrats on getting the cat and child to cooperate.  The spilled pieces on the floor add to the calamity.  Two suggestions if you were to do this again: 1. Get the cat up a little higher, with one or both paws on the table, and 2. The texture on the wall in the background is somewhat distracting. A smooth wall with a framed picture or some other decor to tie it all in would make it perfect.

Is this comment helpful?

Emmanuel Enyinwa , March 15, 2012; 08:01 P.M.



Is this comment helpful?

Katie Clarke , March 15, 2012; 09:20 P.M.

Genius.  7.  K.C.

Is this comment helpful?

Hem Tripathi , March 15, 2012; 10:16 P.M.

wow.. your whole series of these images is intriguing

Is this comment helpful?

Jo Cools , March 16, 2012; 03:27 A.M.

Strong photo

Strong photo. Fun and amusing.

 For me the background a little too dominant

 greetings Jo

Is this comment helpful?

Marjans Burijs , March 16, 2012; 04:15 A.M.

Btravo! Amazing scene, makes me smile. A lot of interesting details.

Is this comment helpful?

Marco Overdiep , March 16, 2012; 05:46 A.M.

Humoristic and beautiful image. The strange environment makes it almost surrealistic.

Is this comment helpful?

Peter O'Hara , March 16, 2012; 06:28 A.M.


Great work! I love the cat series! I like your style of humor and your portrayal is wonderful. Keep up the good work (so I can keep laughing) :).

Best Regards,


Is this comment helpful?

Michel Latendresse , March 16, 2012; 06:42 A.M.

Simply a wonderful image, full of humor and candor.  Great work on post processing as well. This is going to "My Favorites". My first 7 in months... Regards - michel

Is this comment helpful?

Richard Karas , March 16, 2012; 08:35 A.M.


Beyond terrific.  Childlike in it's innocence and provacative and humorous as well. Kudos, rek.

Is this comment helpful?

Tamara Martoussevitch , March 17, 2012; 07:56 A.M.

I love your "Begemot" :)! Three pics are in my favourits! I would have taken all of them! Best regards, Tamara

Is this comment helpful?

Janice Rickert , March 17, 2012; 04:22 P.M.

I like this imaginative photo. It is very whimsical and surreal, and very well executed.

Is this comment helpful?

Alex Elias , March 17, 2012; 05:55 P.M.




Is this comment helpful?

Oleg Tokarev , March 17, 2012; 07:47 P.M.

Perfect! 7

Is this comment helpful?

Karl Schuler , March 18, 2012; 04:56 P.M.


Is this comment helpful?

Maurizio Guarino , March 19, 2012; 04:40 P.M.

Excellent work! 7

Is this comment helpful?

Christy Turner , March 22, 2012; 09:37 P.M.

I love this image! Witty and very well done! 

Is this comment helpful?

pauline fowler , May 05, 2012; 05:59 P.M.

Outstanding!Who won?

Is this comment helpful?

Pierre Dumas , May 20, 2012; 08:58 A.M.

Absolutely great! A masterpiece!

Best regards Andy!

Is this comment helpful?

Alan Baker , June 14, 2012; 08:39 P.M.

I love this photo, Andy. I keep revisiting it. The floor and background absolutely make it so intriguing. The players are intense in their competition; you must be very observant and patient! It's a 7 from me.

Is this comment helpful?

Owen O'Meara , May 03, 2015; 11:44 A.M.




Is this comment helpful?

John Hill , May 04, 2015; 05:41 P.M.


Is this comment helpful?

Contribute a critique

Similar / Related Photos  

View other images enjoyed by photo.net members who like this photo.

Find Related Photos

Discuss - Photography Forums

Interact in 44 photography forums with 1,500+ posts added on a daily basis

Today’s Most Active Threads

View all photography forums »