A Site for Photographers by Photographers

Photographer's Request for Critique


Graditi commenti e critiche.


John Rhodebeck , March 02, 2004; 01:27 P.M.

Shadow appears contrived (IMO), otherwise good.

Is this comment helpful?

James Sarte , March 02, 2004; 01:56 P.M.

Nice, simple, and good tonal variance.

Is this comment helpful?

Olga Gerasimova , March 04, 2004; 01:26 P.M.

Great!! "In expectation of the artist."

Is this comment helpful?

Paul David Athey , March 04, 2004; 05:33 P.M.

I could not agree with Olga more - superb piece of work.

Is this comment helpful?

Gary H Sp , March 04, 2004; 08:19 P.M.

Exquisite in its grittiness! - best, Gary

Is this comment helpful?

Yuri Bonder , March 05, 2004; 04:27 A.M.


Composition is great, light is great, feel is great

Is this comment helpful?

John Marsden , March 05, 2004; 06:26 A.M.

9/10 + 8/10 + dissonance = 11/10

Great photo, but for something that is so dirty and gritty perhaps a little too perfect in framing.

Maybe move the brush off centre. Mis-align the picture frame. Put more of that stringy stuff around.

The flow from bottom left to top right, along the brush, is just too perfect for my taste. The background tiles might look better at an angle. These with the angle of the frame they could then produce more tension and dissonance in the picture.

Technically great 9/10. Aesthetic (8/10 which is still good)perhaps needs a few more jazz sharp and flat notes to make it 11/10.

Thank you for displaying this image.

All the best John

Is this comment helpful?

Antonio Baiano , March 05, 2004; 12:42 P.M.

molto bella!

Is this comment helpful?

Guido Fulgenzi , March 11, 2004; 01:26 A.M.

Grandissima cretività,veramente una prova d'artista!

Is this comment helpful?

Aykan ÖZENER , November 30, 2004; 05:21 P.M.


Is this comment helpful?

Contribute a critique

Similar / Related Photos  

View other images enjoyed by photo.net members who like this photo.

Find Related Photos