Welcome to Photo.net: A Community of Photographers

Gallery > Paul David Athey > Photos > The Cotswolds > Selsley Church & Tree

Photographer's Request for Critique

Selsley Church & Tree

Selsley Nightmare
Heavy PS work again I'm afraid. Let me know what you think. Your comments are appreciated.

The Grey House Photography
www.thegreyhouse.net

Critiques

Loft Portugal , March 25, 2004; 09:44 A.M.

Like always a gift for my (our) eyes

Loft

Jack Blake , March 25, 2004; 09:45 A.M.

wow!!!!! wonderful image!!

(is it just slightly leaning to the right? hmmm)

powerful, Paul!!

Paul David Athey , March 25, 2004; 09:48 A.M.

Loft & Jack, thanks for your super quick ratings. Glad you stopped by. Jack you know you may be right. This was taken at an angle and on a steep hillside looking over the church and valley. I thought I'd got it about right, but I'll take another look. Thanks guys.

Lárus Sigurðarson , March 25, 2004; 09:59 A.M.

I am not religious so I can´t really read into anything, if there is anything you are trying to say with this picture but it looks really good.

I assume this is a composite, not unless you were exceptionally lucky to get this lightning striking the church like that but in my opinion it´s composed very well. It looks to me like the cover of a horror story book.

Anyway, love the colour, purple really makes this work and the mood of the whole picture is great.

Paul David Athey , March 25, 2004; 11:42 A.M.

Larus, thank you for your comment. No it is not meant to have any underlying religious message. I drove past the building a few days ago and thought it looked menacing and unusual. I went back yesterday to shoot it and give it a sinister effect. The lightning composition was aded at the last moment. I quite like the image without it. However the nightmare or horror story theme seemed to work. Thanks for your comment. Regards Paul...

Cristina Fumi , March 25, 2004; 02:42 P.M.

I am gealous you keep posting wonderful images! Great creativity!

christine n , March 25, 2004; 03:45 P.M.

Wow..love the whole mood this photograph creates.

Paul David Athey , March 26, 2004; 04:34 A.M.

Christine & Christina - thank you for your comments - I'm pleased the mood speaks to you.

Regards Paul...

Someone Else , March 26, 2004; 07:27 A.M.

You did a great job with the PS. I couldn't do this. I am learning but then in paint shop. Just like the picture before, I love the toning of the color, and the magic.

Peter Marzano , March 26, 2004; 11:30 A.M.

Very artistic and creative as usual Paul

Paul David Athey , March 26, 2004; 12:12 P.M.

Els & Peter - thanks for taking the time to view and comment. I'm enjoying your work also. Regards Paul...

Knicki ?!? , March 26, 2004; 01:47 P.M.

toning is pleasant. I like it quite a bit. I know it would seem off to have the lightning strike something that isnt the highest point but going thru the window would cause a whole 'nother response and interpretation. Of course then the lower branch would need to be worked a little too.

Again, I find my eyes going a bit green with envy.

Knicki

Marita Toftgard , March 26, 2004; 03:03 P.M.

huuuuuuiiiiiii...scary.....

but also incredibly good work!!! extremely well done image!! and the best presentation as usual... mita;-) thanks for toprating! and comment. and also thanks for help! and have a wonderful weekend..

Pnina Evental , March 27, 2004; 12:57 A.M.

Very dramatic composition Paul, you are doing wonders with the light, I think I need a lesson from you how to creat that kind of light........I went into the site and found your works there. Congratulations Pnina

Roberto P , March 29, 2004; 05:16 A.M.

I'm always impressed by shots at lightning bolts...but this is really great! Wonderful colours too.

Pedro G. Casas , April 06, 2004; 11:55 A.M.

Fantastic ambience!!

W. Roger Keagle Jr. , April 08, 2004; 05:50 P.M.

Paul

My first visit, so still getting my feet on the ground, myst say from here I am impressed.....Love the "Little Shop of Horrors" feel to this !*R*

Luke Peters , May 13, 2004; 11:49 A.M.

cool picture

Great impact!

Myke Gyver , June 24, 2004; 09:31 P.M.

???

I love this image, but I'm estonished of your technical details : f4.5 @1/1000 at ISO 100 ? If those parameters are corrects, you're very lucky to get the lighting and I like this image more...

Paul David Athey , June 25, 2004; 04:13 A.M.

Thanks Mike - this is a composite of two image. The technical details are for the tree and church part of the photograph. Regards Paul.

Alex Robert , August 16, 2005; 11:49 A.M.

Fast fingers

This is an awesome timing ! Right on Paul ! Very cold an moody shot, dark and mysterious ! Very inspiring thanks for sharing ! Keep it up !

Contribute a critique

More Resources here at photo.net...

Similar / Related Photos  

View other images enjoyed by photo.net members who like this photo.

Find Related Photos


More Photos by Member

View Entire Portfolio


Photography