A Site for Photographers by Photographers

Critiques

Lou Ann Aepelbacher , April 20, 2004; 09:35 P.M.

FAITH is right!!!!! WOW!! This is a great shot for so many reasons, Kim!! I love it!! First of all, without the church, it embodies what I love about mountains ... the sheer lack of human control over what happens on the sides of them. You can just imagine the rockslides. But the church at the bottom as part of your composition adds SO MUCH scale and human interest to the photo ... and so much better that it's a church and not a McDonalds or something else because you definitely can draw all sorts of parallels and paint all sorts of imagery. This is just wonderful!! What a great eye you have for this stuff!!!

By the way ... what highway in Canada? Do you remember?

Is this comment helpful?

Kim Slonaker , April 20, 2004; 11:10 P.M.

Lou Ann, I believe it was Highway 97 and this was south of Cache Creek if I remember right.

Someone Else , April 21, 2004; 08:06 A.M.

AMAZING

This is a unbelievable..speaking about faith.. composition, and you are right, about the size of the church

Is this comment helpful?

James Oliver , April 21, 2004; 08:18 A.M.

Absolutely awesome! Churches, with their spires are built to inspire awe, so to see this against the sweeping mountain slope inspires even greater awe for nature. Congratulations on a magnificent shot. One of the best I've seen.

Is this comment helpful?

Faith Cohen , April 21, 2004; 12:10 P.M.

You called!

Is this comment helpful?

Dimitar Jeliascov , April 21, 2004; 04:03 P.M.

Bravo Kim!

Is this comment helpful?

Paul David Athey , April 21, 2004; 04:14 P.M.

Awesome & Inspiring in one amazing photograph. Congratulations on visualizing and capturing this so well. Superb. Paul.

Is this comment helpful?

Kim Slonaker , April 21, 2004; 07:09 P.M.

Thanks for all the comments, everyone. I'm a little surprised because I almost didn't post this one. It was amazing when we saw it in person, but I didn't feel like the image really captured the scene as well as I would have liked.

Regina Chayer , April 21, 2004; 08:15 P.M.

One fabulous shot! Never seen anything like this Kim... great capture.

Is this comment helpful?

Kim Slonaker , April 21, 2004; 09:02 P.M.

Thanks for commenting, Regina.

Bente D.-Nielsen , April 22, 2004; 05:34 A.M.

Another church... threatened by the surroundings!!! Very impressive photo... very.

Is this comment helpful?

Kim Slonaker , April 22, 2004; 07:04 A.M.

Thanks, Bente. A different perspective on a church, for sure...

Len Marriott , April 22, 2004; 09:43 A.M.

Faith or tempting fate ?

Kim, Fantastic sense of scale. Perhaps an optical illusion but the hill sure looks ominous. Re: attending church service here....Call it faith if you want to but it looks like tempting fate to me. Best, LM.

Is this comment helpful?

Kim Slonaker , April 22, 2004; 08:41 P.M.

Len, no optical illusion here. There is a little distance between the church and the hill, but if there's a bad slide, it could get the church, too. The thing is, it's not really mud, but more gravel, so maybe slides aren't a problem. Also, I think this is a fairly low snow area, too, so an avalance isn't likely.

Russ Higgins , April 22, 2004; 09:21 P.M.

Ask the same of the folks in southern Alberta a place called Frank's slide. Superb shot.

http://www3.sympatico.ca/goweezer/canada/frank.htm

Is this comment helpful?

Robert Holmes , April 23, 2004; 12:46 A.M.

Spences Bridge

Kim, This church is in a village called Spences Bridge, on the Thompson River between Kamloops and Lytton in British Columbia...It is the next town to where I live in the mountains, and there is a large Indian (First Nations) community there....It is also the original home of the "Granny Smith" apple...Old Widow Smith brought apple seeds out from Scotland in the 1890's and planted them there, where they thrived and were subsequently sent to England where they became very popular...It is an excellent capture of this interesting place.

Is this comment helpful?

Sarah Underhill , April 23, 2004; 06:21 A.M.

WOW!

Love it! So different! Great composition!

Is this comment helpful?

Kim Slonaker , April 23, 2004; 06:59 A.M.

Thanks for commenting, Sarah and Russ. Robert, I couldn't remember where this was, but now that you have said Spences Bridge, it makes sense. We go through there usually every second year on our Canada trip, but I had never really noticed this church until our last trip through. We're going back in July/Aug and maybe I'll see if I can get another shot with different lighting. Thanks for visiting and for the history - very interesting!

Pnina Evental , April 23, 2004; 11:48 A.M.

There is always surprises Kim......you have nearly not uploaded that one, and good that you did, as it is a very special capture,it bringe the thought how fragil is human being comparing to nature. Pnina

Is this comment helpful?

Kim Slonaker , April 23, 2004; 07:50 P.M.

Thanks, Pnina. Sometimes it's hard to know what people will like. The ones I think are great sometimes don't generate any comments and others (like this one that I almost didn't post), seem to reach a lot of people.

Regina Chayer , June 12, 2004; 12:58 P.M.

This would be a nice one to add to your web site...(hint hint... I would buy it!)

Is this comment helpful?

Kim Slonaker , June 12, 2004; 01:31 P.M.

Regina, email me an address to mail this to and I'll send you a print.

Paul Greenwood , October 15, 2004; 01:45 A.M.

Fantastic shot Kim..thanks , now i gotta drive to Spences Bridge and see this live :)

Is this comment helpful?

Kim Slonaker , October 15, 2004; 07:52 A.M.

Paul, we drove by here again on the second trip to Canada in July and we almost missed it! I didn't see the same thing as what I shot in March! Weird - I guess the lighting was just right earlier in the year. It was rather disappointing the second time around as it didn't stand out at all.

Jeff Henderson , April 23, 2005; 11:32 P.M.

Excellent title for this image. What an awesome view, though, eh? Great work, Kim.

Is this comment helpful?

Kim Slonaker , April 24, 2005; 10:44 A.M.

Jeff, everything came together when I took this shot; on a future trip, I almost missed the church because we came alongside of it on the same side of the highway, instead of on the opposite side where I took the original, and the lighting was dull. There is actually some distance between the church and hill that isn't apparent in this shot. I've never been able to get a similar shot on our trips since this shot.

Howard Dion , September 22, 2006; 11:10 A.M.

Totally emotional response to this image. One picture is worth a thousand words.

Is this comment helpful?

Lou Ann Aepelbacher , March 30, 2010; 06:16 P.M.

Still lovin' this!!! :)

Is this comment helpful?

Lou Ann Aepelbacher , December 31, 2011; 03:34 P.M.

WOW - the first time I saw this was in 2004.  WONDERFUL!!!!  Thank you again!!  :)

Is this comment helpful?

Kim Slonaker , January 01, 2012; 02:38 P.M.

Yeah, I've reshot it a few times!

Contribute a critique

Similar / Related Photos  

View other images enjoyed by photo.net members who like this photo.

Find Related Photos


More Photos by Member

View Entire Portfolio