A Site for Photographers by Photographers

Gallery > Igor Amelkovich > Photos > Portraits > Portrait of young girl.

Photographer's Request for Critique

Portrait of young girl.

Portrait of young girl.

Critiques

Jan Emil Christiansen , November 23, 2004; 10:46 A.M.

I like it ;-)

Is this comment helpful?

Alon Brik , November 23, 2004; 10:53 A.M.

...and good looking one I may add! Nice texture and light!

Is this comment helpful?

Frank Sturm , November 23, 2004; 10:54 A.M.

Well done!

This is a superp shot. Nice model, very moody athmosphere and the tones are great. The composition is nice too! I like it.

Is this comment helpful?

Fredrik Wannerstedt , November 23, 2004; 11:03 A.M.

Nice shot i like it!

Is this comment helpful?

Biliana Rakocevic , November 23, 2004; 11:50 A.M.

Excellent

Bravo! WOnderful woman and B&W! I would give you a 7/7 too , but I am sorry no more available. I think that this limitation on 8 times 7/7 is not so good! Thank you, and bravo, Biliana

Is this comment helpful?

Fun Factory , November 23, 2004; 11:51 A.M.

7/6

!

Is this comment helpful?

Wilhelmina de Haas-Keane , November 23, 2004; 01:01 P.M.

Igor -- you are a master and I am delighted to see a non-nude for once. I would love to see more of this type of work! BRAVO!

Is this comment helpful?

Shawn Hooper , November 23, 2004; 02:04 P.M.

Great Shot!! Excellent lighting and model is very excellent as well!!

Is this comment helpful?

Adam Paine , November 23, 2004; 03:09 P.M.

I love this shot!! You really have a great understanding of lighting! Beautiful model too!

Is this comment helpful?

Gold Fish , November 23, 2004; 04:13 P.M.

7\7

wonderful shot + good pose ..simply great "i like to see more of these shots "better than nudes"

Is this comment helpful?

Nikolay Chigirev , November 23, 2004; 04:39 P.M.

Otlichno !

Great shot !

Is this comment helpful?

Lissa Hatcher , November 23, 2004; 04:43 P.M.

WOW She is stunning...what a great modle nice lighting as well...your the master :)

Is this comment helpful?

Ig [M] , November 24, 2004; 01:34 A.M.

!!!

Is this comment helpful?

John Keiffer , November 24, 2004; 01:41 A.M.

I miss her freckles! I like them better in the other shot (which is my favorite)...

Is this comment helpful?

Hector Brandan , November 24, 2004; 02:51 A.M.

Excellent!!!

Excellent Igor, greetings, Hector...

Is this comment helpful?

Hassan FARAHANI , November 24, 2004; 03:28 A.M.

Excellent!!!!!

Is this comment helpful?

manos xilouris , November 24, 2004; 04:19 A.M.

Excellent as always

Is this comment helpful?

Umair Ghani , November 24, 2004; 05:35 A.M.

7/ 7

exceptional quality. this is artistic portraiture. marvellous control of light. rich in feeling. textures & tones perfect.

Is this comment helpful?

BOURSIER Marc , November 24, 2004; 05:49 A.M.

Very lovely shot and delicious model. continue in this way.

Is this comment helpful?

Jayme Hall - Bardstown, KY , November 24, 2004; 06:55 A.M.

I really love the image, the tones, the detail, the lighting is perfect. I have a question. Did you take this with the model leaning forward or is this rotated in the frame, or did you rotate the camera. I like the diagonal you have created with the model, she looks very natural in her stance, so I am guessing you rotated the camera. Very nice creative choice.

Is this comment helpful?

Erlend Mørk , November 24, 2004; 07:21 A.M.

Beatiful girl - excellent photographer - beatiful photo

Is this comment helpful?

Davide Tizzoni , November 24, 2004; 07:47 A.M.

Perfect!

Is this comment helpful?

EUGENIV LIPPER , November 24, 2004; 09:22 A.M.

Very good. 6/5. Ciao.

Is this comment helpful?

Tony Georgiadis , November 24, 2004; 05:05 P.M.

Tones, Model, sharpness, execution all blend together to make this a great portrait.CONGRATULATIONS.

Is this comment helpful?

Brad Kim , November 24, 2004; 06:55 P.M.

Excellent job Igor as always....

Is this comment helpful?

Igor Amelkovich , November 25, 2004; 12:31 A.M.

Thanx.

manuela soitu , November 25, 2004; 11:41 A.M.

I like the air around her like she's there 'couse U can see her and than again...not quite. That's what I like about the twilight efect

Is this comment helpful?

Gérard Laurenceau , November 25, 2004; 11:47 A.M.

Vraiment superbe !!!

Is this comment helpful?

Steve J Murray , November 25, 2004; 01:54 P.M.

Wow, this is one of your better one's. Great lighting and pose.

Is this comment helpful?

John Campbell , November 25, 2004; 03:09 P.M.

Wow...

Beautiful portrait of a beautiful girl.

Is this comment helpful?

Perry Tourtellotte , November 25, 2004; 03:13 P.M.

Atlechna! Igor 5/5 (Russki system)= 7/7 Photonet system; lighting, detail, mood and final execution all great! keep up the good work!

Is this comment helpful?

Hassan FARAHANI , November 26, 2004; 01:11 A.M.

7/7

Excellent!!!!!!

Is this comment helpful?

Igor Laptev , November 26, 2004; 01:23 A.M.

Excellent!

Is this comment helpful?

nathan g , November 26, 2004; 02:14 A.M.

Superior 7/7

Is this comment helpful?

Rajeev Thomas , November 26, 2004; 03:33 A.M.

Yes that's the word for this one....SUPERIOR!!! 7/7!!

Is this comment helpful?

Kim Slonaker , November 26, 2004; 08:14 A.M.

Great portrait - sharp and so detailed, with pleasing lighting. I like the angle of her pose making a diagonal through the center of the frame.

Is this comment helpful?

O. I. , November 26, 2004; 04:20 P.M.

7/7

Is this comment helpful?

Thorsten Jankowski , November 28, 2004; 10:17 A.M.

great portrait. good grey-conversion

today i came back and i find it stunning! if i can give a 7/7 i will do it.

would be nicht if you check my images, too.

Is this comment helpful?

Ali Najm , November 29, 2004; 04:42 P.M.

bad luck

what ever i'm going to say is nothing infront of your photos yes BAD LUCK not to have alittle of your professional style in photography but hope some day to be aphotographer like you sorry i can't give you any number for A&O but i will write A/7 & O/7 cause it must be 20/20

Is this comment helpful?

Clive Mealey , December 24, 2004; 10:34 P.M.

This is a gorgeous portrait. __ CJ.

Is this comment helpful?

Kevin saunders , December 27, 2004; 11:59 A.M.

Beautiful model, excellent level of tone, nice composition

Is this comment helpful?

Jan Peter , April 05, 2005; 04:55 P.M.

7/7

Still excellent!

Is this comment helpful?

Szymon Gdowicz , May 15, 2005; 02:18 P.M.

7/6

Is this comment helpful?

Yann R. , June 02, 2005; 08:25 A.M.

7/7

PERFECT ! Not only a young girl, she's The Angel of the Beauty...

Is this comment helpful?

Pablo Coronel , June 24, 2005; 10:46 A.M.

Excellent job! Excellent lighting and composition.

Could you comment on how you processed th efilm and how you printed/scanned it?

Is this comment helpful?

Igor Amelkovich , June 26, 2005; 05:16 A.M.

Processed in FX-11, scaned on Nikon 8000-ED.

Russ Rosener , June 27, 2005; 10:09 A.M.

That is a beautiful portrait of a lovely woman. It could use a bit of burning-in to bring down the highlights on her nose. I noticed you posted this to the B&W forum over at APUG. Why not post it on the B&W Film forum here at Photo.net? A lot of photo.netters have questions about this film.

Is this comment helpful?

Igor Amelkovich , June 28, 2005; 11:32 P.M.

Where I have sent? On what forum?

Beatrice Jach , September 14, 2006; 12:26 P.M.

Wow, outstanding! The light on her face adds so much mistery to her...

Is this comment helpful?

Pietro Ferrante , September 24, 2006; 03:29 A.M.

this is perfect

Is this comment helpful?

Jim Adams , September 26, 2006; 12:07 A.M.

Whatever it is that you do to get this marvelous tonal range, I wish I knew how to do it! Highest compliments on this one.

Is this comment helpful?

Boris Pale , November 23, 2006; 02:53 P.M.

Beautiful model. I like the raw and natural look on this one. Good use of the 6x6 format

Is this comment helpful?

dan fein , December 23, 2006; 09:16 P.M.

Question

I enjoy your work, it very good technically, and your content is beautifull. I wanted to ask if you use filters when shooting people with b/w film ?

Is this comment helpful?

Igor Amelkovich , December 24, 2006; 02:11 A.M.

I don`t use filters in studio, but on nature i use red filter.

Dale Barnes , February 05, 2007; 02:22 A.M.

you have an amazing eye for detail and capturing natural beauty with your shots

Is this comment helpful?

Mr G.Q , June 09, 2007; 09:26 A.M.

fantastic

which illumination? which film? I/you/they are admired you are one great

Is this comment helpful?

Igor Amelkovich , June 09, 2007; 10:15 A.M.

Fomapan 100. Soft 1x1 meter. More at http://www.amelkovich.com/articles/24

Adrian Ciorba , March 07, 2008; 04:02 A.M.

beautiful shot

Is this comment helpful?

Szabolcs Nemeth , March 07, 2008; 04:46 A.M.

simply Beautifull!!

Is this comment helpful?

David Fink , March 07, 2008; 07:56 A.M.

Super portrait.

Is this comment helpful?

Jeny Plante , March 07, 2008; 08:33 A.M.

7/7

One of the best I have seen.

Is this comment helpful?

Tom Sheridan , March 07, 2008; 08:48 A.M.

A Classic ...

... that simple.

Is this comment helpful?

Animesh Ray , March 07, 2008; 10:33 A.M.

Awesome!

I can hardly add more to what has been said already. Wonderful work.

Is this comment helpful?

Siamak Jafari , March 07, 2008; 10:52 A.M.

dear igor

an excellent B & W portrait. 7/7 regards-siamak

Is this comment helpful?

Gabor Hertelendy , March 07, 2008; 12:02 P.M.

Just beautiful!

7/7

regards, gh

Is this comment helpful?

Igor Amelkovich , March 13, 2008; 05:35 A.M.

Thanx all!!!

Dolf Walter , February 24, 2009; 12:20 P.M.

Superb

Is this comment helpful?

Raymond Borg , April 22, 2009; 01:01 A.M.

Very nice protrait. Well done.

Is this comment helpful?

Jean-Michel Cabanis , February 14, 2010; 01:04 P.M.

Beautiful shot, wonderful tones!

Is this comment helpful?

Etay Appelberg , December 11, 2010; 06:53 A.M.

Beautiful shot

Is this comment helpful?

Contribute a critique

Similar / Related Photos  

View other images enjoyed by photo.net members who like this photo.

Find Related Photos


More Photos by Member

View Entire Portfolio

Discuss - Photography Forums

Interact in 44 photography forums with 1,500+ posts added on a daily basis

Today’s Most Active Threads

View all photography forums »