A Site for Photographers by Photographers

Gallery > Scott Lewis > Photos > Single Photos > "Human" Interest

Photographer's Request for Critique

A Different view

Striking Contrast...

Critiques

Jim Trombley , December 15, 2004; 11:40 P.M.

This speaks so loudly, from the $$$$ in the distance to the trailer park in the center to the wreckage in the foreground. GREAT JOB. Was the original in color or B&W? If color I'd like to see that for further comparison.

Is this comment helpful?

Scott Lewis , December 16, 2004; 12:53 A.M.

I will put others up I have a few versions... i was moved by the contrast & I was thinking about the indians

Travis Pierson , December 16, 2004; 08:11 P.M.

I don't think the red highlight is necessary. . . but otherwise I like this composotion the best of the three that you posted of the same scene.

Is this comment helpful?

Jeremy Rardin , December 18, 2004; 03:54 P.M.

fabulous!

Is this comment helpful?

Tom Appel , December 26, 2004; 02:40 P.M.

I agree with Travis, the red highlight is overkill. Let the scene speak for itself. Nice catch.

Is this comment helpful?

Scott Lewis , December 26, 2004; 02:49 P.M.

I've seen color added I guess this just wasn't the right picture, I will change the photo to original, for those that read the comments after the fact I had just made Harrahs Red so it stood out as more than a just building, based on comments I have reverted back to my original Picture in raw form

Tom Appel , December 26, 2004; 03:13 P.M.

I think it is a mistake to involve critiquers in the story behind this photo. Critique shots need to stand by themselves. I only came to look at this shot, which I feel is very effective. Please don't use this forum as a political outlet.

Is this comment helpful?

Scott Lewis , December 26, 2004; 03:43 P.M.

Tom, That sounds like a great idea, thank you

Doug Bays , January 22, 2007; 02:23 P.M.

Human" Interest

I really like the theme behind this shot. Just can't come to terms with the rather flat tones, throughout. At least the Casino/Hotel should look inviting, as it always does, in contrast to the devastation, gambling can cause.

Is this comment helpful?

Scott Lewis , January 22, 2007; 03:19 P.M.

Pre PS for me

Doug Bays , January 22, 2007; 10:15 P.M.

"Human" Interest

"Human" Interest

I don't have the PS experience to render it the way I see it,but I'll try to convey my thoughts on it. I was also thinking in terms of "It's a Slippery Slope, and Cause and Effect" for titles. Properly done, it would make a great Gamblers Anonymous, poster.

Is this comment helpful?

Scott Lewis , January 23, 2007; 02:19 A.M.

When i first put this on I did the Harrahs in red... I think it is just to small... I think you have a good idea Thanks

Contribute a critique

Similar / Related Photos  

View other images enjoyed by photo.net members who like this photo.

Find Related Photos


More Photos by Member

View Entire Portfolio

Discuss - Photography Forums

Interact in 44 photography forums with 1,500+ posts added on a daily basis

Today’s Most Active Threads

View all photography forums »