A Site for Photographers by Photographers

Photographer's Request for Critique


Swimming pool shooting with Katka


Elwin Estle , January 23, 2005; 03:43 P.M.

Excellent tone, sort of a black and white bronze look.

Is this comment helpful?

Frank Lloyd , January 23, 2005; 03:55 P.M.


Very nice composition and lighting! Frank Lloyd

Is this comment helpful?

Daniel Benoit , January 23, 2005; 04:34 P.M.

Chain ruins a otherwise beautiful shot

Is this comment helpful?

M. H. , January 23, 2005; 05:23 P.M.


Beautiful model and great lighting.

Composition is a bit boring and I agree regarding the comment on the chain, but I still like the photograph as a whole.




Is this comment helpful?

Elwin Estle , January 23, 2005; 06:01 P.M.

I disagree, I think the chain is part of what makes the shot.

Is this comment helpful?

Angel Pena , January 23, 2005; 06:04 P.M.

I love the tone and the way the light reflect off her skin. The scan is flawless and the model is in her own league.

Is this comment helpful?

Al Li , January 24, 2005; 12:02 A.M.

Beautiful tone and love her expression.

Is this comment helpful?

Allan Hogan , January 24, 2005; 01:01 A.M.

Great shot

A brilliant glamour shot

Is this comment helpful?

Aguiar Thierry , January 24, 2005; 07:23 A.M.

How wonderful it is!

and Katka is a real beauty!

Is this comment helpful?

fred moore , January 24, 2005; 06:40 P.M.

very very hot

Is this comment helpful?

Jim Swenson , January 25, 2005; 06:38 A.M.

Agree with Daniel, perfect except for the chain.

Is this comment helpful?

frans hartman , January 25, 2005; 09:18 A.M.

what a perfect picture!!!! 7/5

Is this comment helpful?

Thomas Collins , January 25, 2005; 04:04 P.M.

A picture perfect fantasy! Love the tonal range, the beautiful model, the pose and everything. The chain works for me. Outstanding!

Is this comment helpful?

James Vincent Knowles , January 26, 2005; 11:39 A.M.


Would LOVE to see her eyes looking right at the camera. Wonderful photo! 7/7 - Keep 'em coming! Bravo!

Is this comment helpful?

tonya cinnamon , January 26, 2005; 04:24 P.M.

if she didnt have tan line would be more dramatic^_^ but a great photo

Is this comment helpful?

CheKim Chhuor , January 26, 2005; 06:35 P.M.

Oh my God, unbelievably pretty and well done!

Is this comment helpful?

Chris Minor , January 28, 2005; 05:09 A.M.

I'm guessing this was a color photo converted to black and white. Either case that is a great set

Is this comment helpful?

Eduard K , January 29, 2005; 02:26 A.M.

Excellent skin tones!

Is this comment helpful?

Aaron W , January 29, 2005; 05:12 A.M.

Very nice skin texture and tone

Is this comment helpful?

Milan Krepelka , January 29, 2005; 06:55 A.M.

jo Dodo, to je dobre

Is this comment helpful?

Geoff Smith , February 02, 2005; 04:46 P.M.

wow. Skin tone amazing. 7/6

Is this comment helpful?

Jerry Hagan , February 03, 2005; 02:40 P.M.

Amazing Shot 7/6

Outstanding shot, excellent lighting and skin tones. Kudos.... ~jerry

Is this comment helpful?

Milos Mashed , February 04, 2005; 07:48 P.M.

This taking is beautiful, likes the treatment of color that you give.... 6/6. Parfaite expression d'art.

Is this comment helpful?

Ralf Zenker , February 05, 2005; 03:57 A.M.

hi, this is a wonderfull shot! perfect light, great looking girl and a good location - perfect :-) like your portfolio also... greets,


Is this comment helpful?

Peter Saucerman , February 08, 2005; 09:17 P.M.

A bit too trite - like a skin mag.

Is this comment helpful?

Barry Mac Court , February 11, 2005; 01:17 P.M.

very sexy

Is this comment helpful?

Daniel Benoit , February 19, 2005; 08:18 P.M.

Loose the chains that bind you.

Is this comment helpful?

franka bades , February 21, 2005; 06:24 A.M.

wow, excellent light, spectacular model, cheers

Is this comment helpful?

Rusty Dallas , October 12, 2005; 12:24 A.M.

Pornographic? But well executed!

Is this comment helpful?

Daniel Benoit , April 21, 2006; 08:02 A.M.

I agree with the above comment.

And the chain just make me think she is peeing.

Is this comment helpful?

mark williams , October 22, 2010; 03:22 P.M.

fabulous.... sexy, smooth. Wonderful skin tone and with the un-tan area and the chain, your eyes just bounce back and forth trying to choose wich part is sexier. the lighting of her breasts are just right and as for the type of nipples.... any other type/style wouldn't have been the same.

Is this comment helpful?

Max Torpey , January 31, 2013; 02:11 A.M.

this is my first comment on any one but i really love this pic the symmetry, lighting and pose is amazing and i love it the only thing i could say with this pic is that the face on her is to forced maybe with the head back and the mouth slightly more open would give a better feel to it but none the less the cemetery and how it is centered and balanced is exquisite

Is this comment helpful?

Contribute a critique

Similar / Related Photos  

View other images enjoyed by photo.net members who like this photo.

Find Related Photos

More Photos by Member

View Entire Portfolio

Discuss - Photography Forums

Interact in 44 photography forums with 1,500+ posts added on a daily basis

Today’s Most Active Threads

View all photography forums »