A Site for Photographers by Photographers

Photographer's Request for Critique

Tsegi-Canyon de Chelly

Early morning in Canyon de Chelly. Thanks for feedback.


Kathy Wilson , March 26, 2005; 02:38 A.M.

This is *gorgeous* really -- tho there are a few issues. 1) the image is tilted to the left, and should go back to the right by at least 1 degree. 2) The blown highlights are a little disappointing and 3) the lens flare is problematic. But that's a minor issue. Bottom line? I think this is gorgeous. I love the color, I love the depth, the tones are very nice too. Well done!

Is this comment helpful?

Joel Arnold , March 26, 2005; 03:18 A.M.

Superb !

Is this comment helpful?

Morey Kitzman , March 26, 2005; 07:25 A.M.

Thank you for the feedback. Kathy, I agree with you on the tilt, I can correct it, as well as the highlights. The lens flare is more a result of poor dodging and burning. Again, thanks.

Asier Zubiaga Monsalve , March 26, 2005; 09:03 A.M.

In my opinion, the composition would be improved if it wasn't tilted, but it is not easy to repair, isn't it?. Very good election of the color and tones, they increase the expressivity. Congratulations.

Is this comment helpful?

Brett Wall , March 31, 2005; 10:31 A.M.

The Grad ND shows. It cuts the picture in half. I think the filter should have been placed higher. Otherwise nice tones.

Is this comment helpful?

Contribute a critique