Critiques
Jim McNitt 
, July 19, 2005; 12:03 P.M.
Hi Ayse:
Hard to imagine a more perfect composition. Is this really a dress, or did you wrap the set in red fabric? Either way, the impression of passion and movement is unmistakable. I especially like the delicate way the fabric falls away from her ankles, creating a natural frame for her feet and shoes. I simply can't envision any way that this could be improved. Brilliant, brilliant, work! --jim
Salih Güler 
, July 19, 2005; 12:36 P.M.
7/7
biraz tatil yaptik Ayse, cok guzel bir calisma, kutlarim:=)
Photo Fun , July 19, 2005; 01:22 P.M.
Congrats.
Excellent shot,right title...7.7
Per Lothe , July 19, 2005; 01:33 P.M.
Excellent 7/7
Very good composition and light!
Julio Segura Carmona 
, July 19, 2005; 04:02 P.M.
Magnifica
Perfecta composicion de la modelo,,luz y color ,, una belleza Aylsen,,,un cordial saludo,,,7/7
hilmi m , July 19, 2005; 04:47 P.M.
7/7
Hi dear Ayse,
excellent comp., contrast, cong.
Longtang Lin , July 19, 2005; 07:47 P.M.
very creative ,, unusual composition and good one
longtang John Lin
Mark Kowalski , July 19, 2005; 08:31 P.M.
Great
A.K. Sircar , July 19, 2005; 08:54 P.M.
A classic image,Ayse. Excellent composition,colour,tone and caption. Heartiest congratulations.
Radu Carp , July 20, 2005; 12:57 A.M.
So simple and strong same time,composition and colour.All my best,Radu7/7
Bora Benic , July 20, 2005; 02:44 A.M.
7/7
Realy perfect photo and superb idea.Congratulation Dear Ayse.Best regards.
tamtam tamtam , July 20, 2005; 03:57 A.M.
puanlayamiyorum..uzgunum..tekrar deneyecegim..sevgiler..
Cherlyn . , July 20, 2005; 09:15 A.M.
Wow
Ayse, excellent idea & presentation. Sleek & sexy legs with all the red passion is so enticing.
Indranil Sircar 
, July 20, 2005; 09:30 A.M.
7/7
Ayse Yalcin 
, July 20, 2005; 10:05 A.M.
Thank you all
I would really want to thank all people here who made me so happy by their words and ratings for this photo ....
Jiri Vasina , July 20, 2005; 12:18 P.M.
Super, very sensual and yet decent... Jiri
Mustafa Sahin , July 20, 2005; 01:51 P.M.
Yaratici yonumu begendigini soyluyorsun :) sen de alcakgonullu olmayi birak, ne guzel bir contrast ve estetik bir fotograf cekmissin.. sevgiler :)
Curtis Forrester , July 20, 2005; 10:59 P.M.
7/7
tamtam tamtam , July 21, 2005; 08:26 A.M.
3 gundur birinciligi birakmayan sevgili Ayse'ye tekrar tebrikler...
Richard Hans 
, July 21, 2005; 09:52 A.M.
Just excellent!!! 7/7
Ayse, Great view point, exquistite composition & nice color tones, well done!!! Best regards.
Ferrando Flores Rafael , July 21, 2005; 12:00 P.M.
Lovely composition and reds Ayse! great pic, congrats
mario balzan , July 21, 2005; 02:19 P.M.
Fantastic composition, dear Ayse.
kadir barcin , July 21, 2005; 03:31 P.M.
Emrah Icten , July 21, 2005; 04:12 P.M.
Paulo Marx , July 21, 2005; 06:10 P.M.
Fantastic composition and a good taste without doubt. 7/7
Naim Ozturk , July 21, 2005; 10:22 P.M.
Echoing the objection of a tree, "I don't want to be a tree, I want to be its meaning", in "My Name is Red," this elegant and tastefully sensuous "Red" seems to be saying "I don't want to be red, I want to be its meaning,"--well at least one of its meanings.
arman poornazmi , July 22, 2005; 05:15 A.M.
Merhebalar ayse !
Zatan yeni ve mukemmel !
Kutliorum hanim efendi !
Renkler canli ve buyuk !
benim ilk 7/7 !
Esen kalin .
David Orea , July 23, 2005; 02:10 A.M.
7 / 7
High quality image, Ayse. Composition and colors are unique !
Arif Tanju Korkmaz , July 25, 2005; 03:49 P.M.
Sevgili Ayse,
uzun bir aradan sonra nete girdigimde sizin bu calismanizla karsilasinca... vay canina dedim, tutuldum, kaldim...
mukemmel otesi... gonulden kutlarim, sevgilerimle...
Mario Spalla , July 26, 2005; 06:33 A.M.
7-7!!
Really delicious dear Ayse!!!!!
Best congrats!
Pnina Evental , July 27, 2005; 07:40 A.M.
Ayse
Very original presentation of womanhood! ...well executed,and titled. Pnina
Mark Boyer , July 27, 2005; 01:22 P.M.
This is extremely creative and very cool.
Okan YILMAZ , July 28, 2005; 10:48 A.M.
7/7
Randall Paul , July 31, 2005; 03:13 A.M.
beautiful elegant and with style lovely photograph
Mustafa Gunduz SOYUSATICI , August 04, 2005; 07:10 A.M.
Daha iyisi, g�zeli olamaz..
Sevgiler, Saygilar
Haleh Bryan , August 05, 2005; 07:07 P.M.
This image is making me want to go put my red shoes on and then apply some rich candy red lipstick on and go dancing! Lovely!
Al Li , August 09, 2005; 09:55 P.M.
Fantastic image. I love it.
Bartek B , August 11, 2005; 08:47 A.M.
Mujahid Awais , August 17, 2005; 01:28 A.M.
Excellent
Love image. Excellent peace of Art.
Tony Georgiadis , August 17, 2005; 07:42 A.M.
Ayse this is a greaT shot congratulations I LOVEIT
Vesi Kovacheva , August 31, 2005; 05:33 A.M.
Great!
yalcin bocugoz , September 09, 2005; 07:01 P.M.
Fevkalade guzel, tebrikler .
Hakan SELEK , September 17, 2005; 09:29 A.M.
Çok Ho? olmu?
İncelik-Kırılgan baskın....
Yuri Bonder , September 30, 2005; 12:52 P.M.
7/7
Betty Clemo , December 03, 2005; 12:37 A.M.
great shot. HORRIBLE title
Bill Long , December 27, 2005; 10:58 A.M.
"The Lady in Red
...looks wonderful tonight."
Exceptional.
Bill
Oktay Ýybar 
, January 23, 2006; 07:54 A.M.
Kirmizi rengi neden cok sevdigimi bir daha
anladim. Cok basarili bir calisma.
Tebrikler.
Alec Ee , April 12, 2006; 06:37 A.M.
Imanol Gabilondo. , May 19, 2006; 01:23 P.M.
Perfect Red... :) Blue ... red... Green?
RUBEN MARTINEZ MUÑIZ , November 20, 2006; 08:21 A.M.
篫 g�zel photograf!!!
The designe of the picture is nice, and the colours also. It is a very powerfull picture.
Congratulations!!1
Okan Metin , December 07, 2006; 05:37 A.M.
Fotografinizi yeni gordum..cok basarili ..iyi vurgulanm�s
ellerinize saglik..
sevgilerimle..
Murat & Yasemin ERPUYAN-OZTURK , December 25, 2006; 11:00 A.M.
Kirmizi
Kediye bayildim ama bu kompozisyona da sapka 穫ardim ! (7/7) Zaten begeni de mutlak 篧unlugu saglamis Ayse...
Kutlarim kiskan笩kla...
Helena Morgenshtern , March 25, 2007; 05:33 P.M.
Excellent shot. Well done!
Alec Ee , April 12, 2007; 10:29 A.M.
7/7
One of my favorite in PN.
Christos Markou , May 16, 2007; 02:50 A.M.
Hannah Thiem 
, May 16, 2007; 02:12 P.M.
Beautiful composition, contrast, bold statement. I would also like to see an alternate composition adding movement to the fabric while the feet remain stationary.
Wonderful job!
Kemal Riza , July 31, 2007; 04:02 A.M.
Purely and simply this is the beauty of the red...
And very nice composition. Thanks...
Jeny Plante , October 18, 2007; 04:46 P.M.
Excelente
Art X 
, April 18, 2009; 03:33 A.M.
everyone above has said it all Ayse, and so all I can do is reiterate their thoughts...brilliant!!
Contribute a critique
Send a free photo eCard
Photo eCards from photo.net are a way to email someone a photo.net Gallery photo
with your personal greeting or message. Send an eCard to your contacts to announce
your portfolio on photo.net. Send one of your own photos as an eCard to ask
another photo.net member to write a critique of it. Share photos
and portfolios that you have discovered on photo.net with your friends. Or
just send someone a greeting or message for
a birthday, holiday, or other occasion or observance.
The recipients will receive an email from
photo.net announcing that they have received the eCard, with a link back to
photo.net. When the recipients follow the link, the photo and your message will
be presented to them in a special eCard format.
The easiest way to see how eCards work and what they look like
is just to send yourself one!
photo.net eCards are free: by sending one, you are letting others know
about photo.net and the exceptional photographers on the site! We won't charge you
for that. The email addresses you enter into this form will be kept private. Send as many
eCards as you like, but please don't turn this feature into a spam-a-thon.
