A Site for Photographers by Photographers

Photographer's Request for Critique

Sad girl

Hi, what do you think about this picture, comments please?


Mark Boyer , September 30, 2005; 02:19 P.M.

Terrific shot. Unique and somewhat startling.

Is this comment helpful?

Sondra Kicklighter , September 30, 2005; 02:58 P.M.

Wonderful composition and dof. Cheers, Sondra 6/6

Is this comment helpful?

Lasse Pettersson , September 30, 2005; 08:08 P.M.

I dont know if I think she is sad, but I like the shot very much.....

Is this comment helpful?

Igor Baranov , September 30, 2005; 09:33 P.M.


Very intersting and dynamic composition. Very artistic. Collage of course... but who cares.

Is this comment helpful?

Mario Paper Martinez Caballero , February 03, 2006; 07:07 P.M.

Nice view

Well at firsti view it looks as a fantastic photo taked from a book. The composition is so nice and the girl looks like an hada !!!

Is this comment helpful?

Mark Boyer , March 26, 2006; 01:14 P.M.

Beautiful, moody, artistic shot.

Is this comment helpful?

Scott Cromwell , August 16, 2007; 11:11 P.M.

She doesn't look sad at all to me, but I love what you've done to create this image.

Is this comment helpful?

Carlos Rodriguez , November 12, 2008; 02:41 A.M.


Very powerful photo, congrats...

Is this comment helpful?

Raymond Elstad , January 06, 2009; 10:07 A.M.


Is this comment helpful?

Manfred Kraft , January 06, 2009; 03:33 P.M.

good product. But i don`t like shadow&light-situation of girl. It works too hard against situation of background. It would be better, if you find a "subjective link" between main motive and background. This is no critique, just an advice...

best regards agentK

Is this comment helpful?

Pedro Olivo , January 31, 2010; 11:12 A.M.

The only thing I don't like about this is the title, she doesn't look sad at all. Nice portrait.

Is this comment helpful?

Luc Helie , January 19, 2011; 02:32 P.M.

You've got a great visual impact with the postwork. Like it!

Is this comment helpful?

Contribute a critique