A Site for Photographers by Photographers

Photographer's Request for Critique


Welcome ..


A.K. Sircar , November 24, 2005; 08:18 P.M.

Beautiful landscape.

Is this comment helpful?

Kaushik Chatterjee , November 25, 2005; 02:38 P.M.


Nice shot Tuhinda, Jhalong is very much photogenic. I was there for two days but the camera was not working. But suprisingly after returning the camera began to work automatically. My luck was not with me there. About this one, I love this one very much specially the faded mountain range and the clouds. IMO One thing is distracting, the peeping branches in the right of the frame. Rgds.

Is this comment helpful?

alexandra rauh , November 25, 2005; 05:32 P.M.

Pleasant to look at.like the continuation of the mountains and the sunny space in front. I agree ,it does not need the branch on the right to hold on. regards.

Is this comment helpful?

Richard Hans , November 26, 2005; 09:27 A.M.

Very nice!!!

Is this comment helpful?

Pnina Evental , November 26, 2005; 09:57 A.M.

Tuhin,nice landscape. I like the clouds and the misty mountains. I wish a bit more space in the fg, as the yellow part and path are a bit tight, and are very nice, giving a good lighted color point to the composition. Pnina

Is this comment helpful?

Tuhin Saha , November 28, 2005; 04:42 A.M.

thanks Amalda , Richard , Kaushik , Pnina and Alexandra ..thanks for leting me know what you feel :)

Cherlyn . , November 28, 2005; 11:49 A.M.

The floating clouds, the misty distant mountains, the yellow fields are all elements to a good landscape composition. The branch is not that noticeable, to me.

Is this comment helpful?

Anatolij Blaszewicz , November 29, 2005; 04:22 A.M.

Nice landscape

Is this comment helpful?

Tuhin Saha , December 06, 2005; 10:05 A.M.

thanks Cherlyn and Anatolij .

Dilip Kumar Singha , December 08, 2005; 09:50 A.M.

Potential Landscape:

Slightly adjusted:

Excellent composition, there was a very high potentiality in this shot to be a superb landscape. The problem appears to be the haze / smoke filled in the vast empty space. This is a characteristic problem in the hills of West Bengal. Clean environment exists only after heavy shower. The combination (ISO 400, No tripod & 1/60 SS) also may not be very suitable but may be the compulsion of the moment. You have tried Circular Polariser also. Right now only editing can improve the photograph significatly. I have tried but do not know how much it improves and whether you like it or not? Congratulation!

Is this comment helpful?

Tuhin Saha , December 09, 2005; 09:06 P.M.

thanks Dilipda for your effort in helping me , with more saturation and hike in levels , the photo does look better . I use D70's ISO 400 because it gives more flexibility and I find it nothing to complaint about ( about dirts ) . The type of lens I used , I can safely click my shutter at 1/30 . It was 1/60 here .Hence , the use of tripod was/is not an issue .

Thanks .

Paula Grenside , December 10, 2005; 09:49 A.M.

Love the fading mountains in the background and then the crips clouds rising. Great depth.

Is this comment helpful?

Tuhin Saha , December 11, 2005; 03:03 A.M.

thanks Paula for ur visit and critique .

Armindo Lopes , December 20, 2005; 12:33 P.M.

To me, the shot is fine and the compositon is okay. I don't understand some comments you have here. You could do this shot with ISO 100, 60 sec (or less) without a tripod. With ISO above 200 I can have grain but at lower light conditions, like at dusk.

Is this comment helpful?

Tuhin Saha , December 24, 2005; 04:41 A.M.

thanks for your opinion Armindo .

Ram Thakur , July 09, 2006; 05:36 A.M.

Hi Tuhin! Getting back on PN after ages here in Dubai. You know the reason: I live in the LAND OF TABOOS! Lovely landscape. I do not like the workshop done by someone here. The original is the best.

Is this comment helpful?

Contribute a critique