A Site for Photographers by Photographers

Gallery > Gaetan Chevalier > Photos > Winter scenes. > Touring Old-Quebec city by...

Photographer's Request for Critique

Touring Old-Quebec city by carriage in winter time.

Touring Old-Quebec city by carriage in winter time.

Critiques

Michael Ging , January 07, 2006; 11:42 P.M.

Gaetan, Great photo.....nice composition and framing. I like the look of Color in the foreground and B&W in the background ,and you did it naturally.This photo looks like it could have been taken a 100 yrs ago.This photo makes me feel cold ,and It was 82 degrees here yesterday. Thanks for sharing it.

Is this comment helpful?

Pnina Evental , January 08, 2006; 01:39 A.M.

My fierst impression was the redish color of the man , his horse and carriage against the grey bg. , than the solitude of him in that weather, and the question why is he standing there as no customers seen at that time...

Very well composed Gaetan,has a special atmospher. Pnina

Is this comment helpful?

Darko Kordovan , January 08, 2006; 02:47 A.M.

EXcellent image...

Is this comment helpful?

Pulok Pattanayak , January 08, 2006; 03:24 A.M.

Like it!

Regards...

Is this comment helpful?

rabinder bhandari , January 08, 2006; 05:03 A.M.

Gaetan, you have successfully catptured the seasons beuty in this pic. a praiseworthy photograph....

regards.... rabinder

Is this comment helpful?

Claude Germain , January 08, 2006; 09:16 A.M.

Encore une superbe vue hivernale du Vieux-Quebec ! J'aime beaucoup l'ensemble quasi monochrome d'ou ressort le triangle rouge.

Is this comment helpful?

Maurizio Guarino , January 08, 2006; 12:49 P.M.

Eccellente!! Bye.

Is this comment helpful?

Tomaso Nigris , January 08, 2006; 12:59 P.M.

Very nice, beatiful contrats between the color of carriage and the snowing day.

Is this comment helpful?

Michael Raddatz , January 08, 2006; 03:35 P.M.

Awesome, Gaetan. I only wish the lights were on......

Is this comment helpful?

Julio Segura Carmona , January 08, 2006; 04:50 P.M.

Excelente

Magnifica imagen Gaetan. un perfecto trabajo, luz, color y nieve, PN, no seven, un cordial saludo.

Is this comment helpful?

Alberto Quintal , January 08, 2006; 05:47 P.M.

Beautiful cold shot!

Cheers.

Alberto

Is this comment helpful?

Serge Raymond , January 08, 2006; 08:20 P.M.

Bravo!

Bravo Gaetan! Superbe vue monochrome et photo bien 鱵ilibr饡

Is this comment helpful?

alexandra rauh , January 09, 2006; 01:37 A.M.

Gaetan,. what a dream of winter wonderland.The carriage and the reds ,stand out beautiful. Nice to look towards the arch.Thank You for sharing

Is this comment helpful?

Alex Milarakis , January 09, 2006; 05:04 A.M.

A beautiful photo with excellent composition and nice perspective. Great work. Congrats!

Is this comment helpful?

Aivar Mikko , January 09, 2006; 05:43 A.M.

You have a lot of good snowy winter shots. This is one of them. Well composed. Poor horse.

Is this comment helpful?

umashankar pandey , January 09, 2006; 10:29 A.M.

Superb!

Dear Gaetan, I've come to trust you for spectacular photographs with your cooplix cams. Its a perfect, perfect photograph! Its almost a dream! (Wish you a very Happy & Prosperous New Year {wish I could say that in French!})

Is this comment helpful?

C J Rupp , January 09, 2006; 05:24 P.M.

Gaetan, a wonderful winter scene, wish I were there. Well seen. Its good to be back.

Is this comment helpful?

Alberto Pareto , January 10, 2006; 04:09 P.M.

A very beautiful image, suspended ... the colors of the subjects against the lack of colors of the background make the shot. Just a thing is out of place: the red triangle!

Regards Alberto

Is this comment helpful?

Lou Ann Aepelbacher , January 10, 2006; 05:11 P.M.

A wonderful winter scene!! Typical of your excellent work Gaetan!

Is this comment helpful?

Donna Albers , January 10, 2006; 10:21 P.M.

Gaetan, a beautiful image to add to your repetoire of winter scenes of this beautiful city. . . they are especially meaningful since I don't think I'll be seeing snow this year. . .

Is this comment helpful?

Jason Williams , January 11, 2006; 01:32 P.M.

Great shot, nice composition.

Is this comment helpful?

Arthur Baas , January 11, 2006; 10:34 P.M.

Excellent work!

Is this comment helpful?

Colin Carron , January 12, 2006; 12:48 P.M.

I like the oldtime atmosphere and the composition.

Is this comment helpful?

Ada Ipenburg , January 15, 2006; 06:48 P.M.

Hello Gaetan,

Never known that Quebec has such a beautiful old city centre. The snow underlines the beautiness of it. This is a wonderful picture and radiates the romantic sphere of the 19the century. Very nice work!

Warm Greetings, Ada:~)

Is this comment helpful?

Alec Ee , January 16, 2006; 11:25 A.M.

Lovely post card style shot.

Is this comment helpful?

Razvan Pantescu , January 17, 2006; 12:14 P.M.


My version

The composition is very good, it has that old medieval athmosphere, but that man does not make part of that. Personally I think I would clone it and make an white/black version for the photo! Here's down my version. Regards,

Razvan.

Is this comment helpful?

Gaetan Chevalier , January 18, 2006; 10:01 P.M.

Razvan

I would like to thank you for your nice comment and also for the superb work you have done on my photo. Yes it gives a special old medieval athmosphere. The white/black version is well done and give that very special mood to the photo. Again thank you, I would like to know and master editing photo like you.

Gaetan Chevalier , January 29, 2006; 02:51 P.M.

Pnima

Yes the man is standing just waiting for customers.

Christa Thompson , February 25, 2006; 10:15 A.M.

I like it just the way it is. The atmosphere looks almost like a black and white photo, that's why the little red poking out makes it so wonderful. Great catch:~)

Is this comment helpful?

Yvan Frechette , March 12, 2006; 04:33 P.M.

J'aime beaucoup le cote sombre, presque monochrome avec quelques touches de couleurs.

Is this comment helpful?

Michael Haydon , May 06, 2006; 07:53 A.M.

7/6

Beautiful photo, I missed this one.

Michael

Is this comment helpful?

Contribute a critique

Similar / Related Photos  

View other images enjoyed by photo.net members who like this photo.

Find Related Photos


More Photos by Member

View Entire Portfolio