Photographer's Request for Critique
--Eskil Olsen
Aurora dansing over Hauan
Like it?
Critiques
J. Knight , February 16, 2006; 07:34 P.M.
4/4......some ratings just make me laugh....fantastic shot!
Dave Holland , February 16, 2006; 09:10 P.M.
?details
An outstanding image, for sure. This is a pretty rare experience, and I am not sure I know how to expose for this shot, if I ever get a similar chance. What was your exposure data (f-stop, shutter speed, lens length)?
Lorenza F , February 17, 2006; 05:19 A.M.
Wow .. I have always dreamed to see an aurora ... sure that I like it!! But were the colours really like this (yellow-green, I mean) or did you use filters/post production adjustments?
Cheers, Lorenza
Bob Kurt 
, February 17, 2006; 07:37 A.M.
Dexter Dee Dee , February 17, 2006; 11:48 A.M.
Very nice colors and aurora form. DDD
Alin Balanean , February 17, 2006; 04:58 P.M.
AWESOME!! I think it's the best one with this subject! Excellent!
Julian Chu , February 18, 2006; 01:16 A.M.
Spectacular!
Peter Kervarec , February 18, 2006; 04:42 A.M.
Fantastic! I think its about time photo.net makes it impossible to rate without leaving your name - 4/4 is a joke.
Eskil Olsen , February 18, 2006; 08:40 A.M.
Thank you for comments. The coulors are true, no filters. F:5,6 25 sek. Canon lens 17-40mmL f/4. (21mm) Iso 400
Ferrando Flores Rafael , February 18, 2006; 11:28 A.M.
Fantastic capture!, love the aurora shapes and how the left trees and horizon guide into the composition, stars are a great add, totally awesome, would love to see one of these sometime!
Arnab Banerjee , February 18, 2006; 01:05 P.M.
Hard not to like this one - fantastic capture. I like the way the tree and mountains are illuminated by the aurora
Vi P , February 18, 2006; 04:23 P.M.
Ooohh.... I have seen it once in my life, in Iceland, and I will never forget it.
This is so very magical... its like... they say - its magic! you know its intangible. But aurora borealis - it is visible... and when you see it - you know it. you know its by its beauty and by how it takes your breath away....
A.K. Sircar 
, February 19, 2006; 11:19 A.M.
Never seen a spectacle like this.Excellent capture.Thanks for sharing.
seckin aziz top , February 19, 2006; 02:20 P.M.
unusual
Ketil Monsen , February 19, 2006; 03:03 P.M.
Angel Hernandez
, March 20, 2006; 04:47 P.M.
This is the most beautiful shot I have ever seen of the Aurora. Let me tell you how I envy you in an honest way. I would be mad if I could take something similar. BRAVO!!!!
Daniel Gaworski , April 16, 2006; 08:38 A.M.
impressive. I think I'll post my aurora shots soon :)
Robert Pastierovic , July 03, 2006; 02:06 P.M.
Hi. Norway is a very nice country. Great shot.
Manfred Feuser
, November 12, 2006; 01:04 A.M.
This is just awesome Eskil , more please!
Angelo Plessas , November 12, 2006; 06:47 A.M.
A place i have always dreamed of visiting .... excellent capture !!!
My regards !
Vadim Makarov , November 12, 2006; 07:58 A.M.
Perception of color
Id like to offer a suggestion to answer the question about color. Judging from the f-stop/ISO/exposure data for this image, this is a relatively bright aurora, so it would probably be seen as green by the eye, close to its photographic depiction. However, weaker (less bright) auroras are not percepted by the eye as having a strong color or any color at all, because color receptors (cones) in the eye are not sensitive to weak light, only monochrome receptors (rods) are. This is called a scotopic, or night, vision: everything is be perceived as monochrome, or with pale colors. Also, rods are more sensitive in the green and partially sensitive in the blue part of the spectrum. So, red colors look much darker than other colors in near darkness. Color film does not mimic scotopic vision. It records everything in full color even at very long exposures and/or high ISO.
Digital cameras could in principle mimic scotopic vision, but I am yet to hear of such a recording mode. It could be mimicked (after some research) with manual processing in Photoshop if the exposure data is recorded. The result probably wont be pretty, if accurate :).
It is a little trick photographers practice: shoot at low light, show fantastic colors the eye never sees.
Norbert Borowiec , November 12, 2006; 09:13 A.M.
ivan bacon , November 12, 2006; 03:31 P.M.
my eyes.
"auroras are not percepted by the eye as having a strong color or any color at all,"
my EYES have seen aurora's in yellow, green, red, purple, and every shade that falls inbetween. you can only understan if you have seen them , it will blow your mind.
excelent photo i like that the little town is in the shot.
Jacynthe Harel
, May 12, 2007; 01:12 P.M.
Very beautiful!
7/7 Fantastic shot, wow! Bravo!
andreas mixalopoylos , May 12, 2007; 03:07 P.M.
Shea Riggenbach
, August 31, 2007; 10:02 A.M.
This is amazing. I love the pin points of the stars.
Christian Hilmersen , November 23, 2007; 02:55 A.M.
Nice! I like the wing-like look of this. Regarding color: this is a rather conservative aura, if anything I would guess that the long exposure burned out some of the color.
Marius Hole
, November 23, 2007; 12:38 P.M.
Hei Eskil
skriver paa norsk jeg. fantastisk bilde og fin komposisjon. Veldig fine farger. Et nydelig bilde!
Autumn P. , November 23, 2007; 01:38 P.M.
Vahid Kohandel , November 23, 2007; 03:01 P.M.
7/7 Congrats for your amazing shot .
Florin Vitzman
, November 23, 2007; 07:30 P.M.
This is oustanding! a perfect exposure! Congratulations!
Bernard Reagan
, November 23, 2007; 09:35 P.M.
There is really nothing more to say..
Absolutely stunning. Thank you so very much for sharing -
Marla Marrs
, November 23, 2007; 10:19 P.M.
Oh wow, I really love this photo, I just was telling someone today I'd like to see the Northern Lights, Hopefully I will some day. =] Really nice photo.
Ignacio Romero Naves , November 26, 2007; 07:23 A.M.
Awesome
Wonderful!!! I love this shot it is incredible!! I have been living in Finland for 3 years already and actually I was talking today morning to my wife that I would love to take some pictures of aurora Borealis...but it is not that easy to find them...did you check anywhere the amount of magnetism of thatday?? Or you just got lucky and "crashed" into one :-)
Anyway great work...7/7
Tomislav Bukvic
, November 26, 2007; 12:04 P.M.
FANTASTIC! Envy you for having an opportunity to see something like this yet to photograph it. 10/10
Marek Novotny , November 26, 2007; 02:54 P.M.
Bill Pador
, December 29, 2007; 03:51 P.M.
Simply AWESOME !
These are those kinds of shots every photographer wishes happened to them, just a wonderful capture in every sense. So mystical & down right pretty to look at. I hope to someday see one of these in person and be able to capture it on film as you have. Be proud of this one, it's just FANTASTIC ! Thanks for sharing . . . "BRAVO" 7/7
Contribute a critique
Send a free photo eCard
Photo eCards from photo.net are a way to email someone a photo.net Gallery photo
with your personal greeting or message. Send an eCard to your contacts to announce
your portfolio on photo.net. Send one of your own photos as an eCard to ask
another photo.net member to write a critique of it. Share photos
and portfolios that you have discovered on photo.net with your friends. Or
just send someone a greeting or message for
a birthday, holiday, or other occasion or observance.
The recipients will receive an email from
photo.net announcing that they have received the eCard, with a link back to
photo.net. When the recipients follow the link, the photo and your message will
be presented to them in a special eCard format.
The easiest way to see how eCards work and what they look like
is just to send yourself one!
photo.net eCards are free: by sending one, you are letting others know
about photo.net and the exceptional photographers on the site! We won't charge you
for that. The email addresses you enter into this form will be kept private. Send as many
eCards as you like, but please don't turn this feature into a spam-a-thon.