A Site for Photographers by Photographers

Photographer's Request for Critique

rainy day

Thank you


Linda Davidson , March 17, 2008; 02:40 A.M.

Andrzej, I don't comment on nudes very often, but this one is exceptional. This is so ethereal. Very clever, original and artistic. Warm regards.

Is this comment helpful?

Eugenio Pastor Benjumeda , March 17, 2008; 07:12 A.M.

You have my 7/7 for such an excellent image. Regards from Eugenio.

Is this comment helpful?

Goran Anastasovski , March 17, 2008; 07:37 A.M.

Amaising image.

Is this comment helpful?

Din Menasheroff , March 17, 2008; 10:36 A.M.

Very good

I would have chose a diffrent headline though. Something that emphasizes the fact that it's only raining on this woman.

Good job


Is this comment helpful?

Cherlyn . , March 17, 2008; 11:32 A.M.

Enchanting work, Andrzej. There is a magical charm to this image. Love it. 7/7

Is this comment helpful?

Josh Derik Thompson , March 17, 2008; 02:22 P.M.


Great job!

Is this comment helpful?

Airi Pung , March 17, 2008; 07:33 P.M.

Beautiful creation! Bravo!

Is this comment helpful?

Craig Philpott , March 17, 2008; 10:37 P.M.

If this was posted as a nude, may I suggest also posting it in Fine Art. There are many influences here and the results are stunning. I am moved by this in ways that are hard to put into words.

Is this comment helpful?

Rolland Steil , March 19, 2008; 12:20 A.M.

Simply incredible. Cheers!

Is this comment helpful?

Paolo Bevilacqua , March 19, 2008; 07:21 A.M.

Idea grandiosa e ben eseguita.Complimenti.

Is this comment helpful?

Tolo Duran , March 20, 2008; 09:52 A.M.

Bellisima y creativa composicion,con un detalle y tonos sensacionales.Felicidades.7/7.Anon.

Un cordial saludo -Tolo.

Is this comment helpful?

Tim Keller , March 20, 2008; 01:43 P.M.

You're pursuing very playful work these days! I agree that this one belongs better in "Fine Art" than "Nudes". A wonderful and dreamy image, wildly original. (PN won't allow 7/7 so I'll have to come back later.)

Is this comment helpful?

Roger Bella , March 20, 2008; 03:47 P.M.

Salut Andrzej,

Mais comment tu fais ??? C'est magique, je suis bleuffé. Merci de partager avec nous tes rêves. Merci de ta visite, cordialement, Roger.

Is this comment helpful?

Don Davis , March 24, 2008; 06:57 A.M.


The contrast is both subtle and stark at the same time...very cool piece.

Is this comment helpful?

George Watters , April 19, 2008; 05:53 P.M.

Nicely done but the rain effect is pretty poor. There are a few large "drops" on her skin but most of her skin is clear. The rain is supposed to be falling inside the umbrella? Then she should have water all over her. The "streaks" of rain are unrealistic and from a pretty poor Photoship plug-in.

Is this comment helpful?

Gudmundur Geir , April 23, 2008; 06:28 P.M.

Ohh I love everything about this. Surrealistic and very well done. If I look very closely the things i feel that are not perfect are the oversized droplets on the body and the tilting of the rain like there is wind coming from the right, still there is noting else in there indicating wind. I'd like this one on my wall in a huge print.

Is this comment helpful?

Cristian Maghiar , May 08, 2008; 06:30 P.M.

Yes, the rain and the drops are a little bit too unnatural, but my only problem is that judging by the position of the umbrella, we should see it’s handle. Really nice idea though, so Andrzej, please take my comment as a constructive, not an offending one. Cheers.

Is this comment helpful?

Richard Cox , May 27, 2008; 02:09 P.M.

I don't believe that a surreal image is suppose to be authentic. I love this concept and the processing is great. Bravo!

Is this comment helpful?

Julie Tanaka , June 05, 2008; 02:34 A.M.


i too usually don't comment on nudes, but this was so artfully done and is so creative. wonderful photo.

Is this comment helpful?

Bijan Karamad , October 07, 2008; 11:38 A.M.

One of the most beautiful photo I have ever seen... 7/7. I watched our wonderful profile and I should say that I was really jealous of you because of your profile! Well Done...

Is this comment helpful?

Mark Brosnihan M.D. , January 06, 2010; 11:49 P.M.

Another great image

Is this comment helpful?

Jaap Voets , January 21, 2010; 02:06 A.M.

wonderful work , well done !

Is this comment helpful?

Clemson Guy , January 21, 2010; 08:02 A.M.

Yikes, that is well done! Only nit-picky thing I see is that the water drops on the body are disproportionately large. Very imaginative.

Is this comment helpful?

Ben Goossens , February 16, 2010; 09:18 A.M.

Clever idea perfectly executed:-))

Is this comment helpful?

Czarek S , October 21, 2010; 11:05 A.M.

Interesting :-)

Is this comment helpful?

Contribute a critique