Welcome to Photo.net: A Community of Photographers

Photographer's Request for Critique

Roll

Thank you...

Critiques

Jim McConnell , October 07, 2008; 07:42 A.M.

Beautiful focus and detail, awesome sky!

Andrzej Radka , October 07, 2008; 11:15 A.M.

Good photograph,but would by more interesting if U could move main subject to one of site,not just in the centre of field.Cheers.Andrzej

Tim Keller , October 07, 2008; 01:31 P.M.

Yes, Andrzej, I gave much thought to this, knowing the "rule" and anticipating this discussion; I shot some as you suggest, which I'm likely to post later. But I processed this first as it just felt compelling to me despite breaking the rule. There are times we can successfully break rules; we'll each have our own opinions on whether this is one of those times. Thanks.

El Porte-Bonheur , October 07, 2008; 06:47 P.M.

Don't change anything, Tim. It's great! Rules?...Rules say: Red traffic light = stop. Where I live it's a question of personal interpretation... and all is fine :)

Richard Armstrong , October 07, 2008; 07:56 P.M.

Tim,

This is a wonderful photo, so I agree with your presentation and forget the "rule"! I just got the same lens and it was really because of you and Matt Laur's results. It is very sharp but I'm not really used to it. This image is a great example of a perfect use for it!

Best regards,

Dick

Maajed Naghshbandi , October 08, 2008; 02:24 A.M.

Very nice shot, beautiful sky, good colors and light.
--Maajed

Jean-Marc Raveau , October 08, 2008; 06:17 A.M.

Another very nice one. Regards, Jean-Marc

Jose Ignacio Saez de Ugarte , October 08, 2008; 07:16 A.M.

Great colours and composition, Tim. I like it "in the middle". But I like, most of all, meet you again after vacations. Best regards from Bilbao.

Kraft Jamie , October 08, 2008; 08:07 A.M.

lovely image

nice tonal control.

Matt Laur , October 12, 2008; 10:59 P.M.

Tim, I will appear in your defense at your hearing in front of the Rules Of Thirds Commission when the time comes. This one works! I like the hay vortex and the sky it's spinning off. Just so. Great use of that focal length.

Contribute a critique

More Resources here at photo.net...

Similar / Related Photos  

View other images enjoyed by photo.net members who like this photo.

Find Related Photos


More Photos by Member

View Entire Portfolio


Photography