Critiques
Verna Bice , August 09, 2002; 07:06 P.M.
Strong Profile
Very strong profile, nicely done!
V.Bice
John Orr
, August 09, 2002; 07:35 P.M.
two great 9s
WONDERFUL!!!
My only small suggestion is I wish I could see just a wee bit more of the forehead area. I hope we see more great B/W images up here photo.net.
Eliot Park , August 11, 2002; 05:04 P.M.
Drowning
Joe Tackett
, August 11, 2002; 10:52 P.M.
This photo is one in a million!!!!!!!!!
Great job....
Axel Cordes 
, August 12, 2002; 02:04 A.M.
10/10 Fantastic
It's a long time ago, that I found a image here which I was urged to rate. This one is simply great. So simpl, so much emotion.
Tom Grubbe 
, August 12, 2002; 03:01 A.M.
Did you give up your P67II for a digital? I sure hope not. This shot shows such ultimate care and attention to detail, I'm just blown away...(10)
Miguel Monteiro , August 12, 2002; 07:55 A.M.
Reconheci-o pelo menos. Mais uma vez uma bela foto.. Parabens
Martin O'Brien-Kelly , August 12, 2002; 09:53 A.M.
This is absolutely stunning! So sensual! As soon as I spotted this I was moved. What dramatic highlights on the soft tone of her face. How did you keep the water dark? My only thought is that I also want to see more of her forehead. Thank you!
Igor Amelkovich
, August 12, 2002; 11:46 P.M.
Pleasantly.
It would be desirable will touch.
Marc G.
, August 13, 2002; 07:47 A.M.
Not quite sure whether I'm right or wrong here, but I really don't share everybody's enthusiasm about this image. I mean, your POW shot was imo miles above this one emotionally, technically, and aesthetically.
<p>
First, I miss the forehead too, and I find the crop on the left too close to the chin as well. But then, more importantly, the profile itself isn't very appealing with the strong shine of the water on the skin. The hair on the face are also too heavy imo, and what could have meant peace is now kind of stressful imho.
<p>
Finally, the dark edge at the bottom, at water level, tells me that there has been too much light above water, and too little under the water level. I find this dark bottom border really disturbing, and it ruins the last hopes one could have to feel some peace here, while it is also quite prejudicial at aesthetical level. To me, this image is one of the weakest you have uploaded so far. Your POW was a 9 and a 10 for me, so I guess this would be a pair of 7s... Just my honest opinion. Regards.
Patrick (Washington, DC) , August 13, 2002; 11:15 A.M.
excellent execution and powerful contrast. i like it a lot.
Steve Mark , August 13, 2002; 03:07 P.M.
Antonio Araujo , August 13, 2002; 09:13 P.M.
Excelente (10/10)
Os meus parabéns, a fotografia é excelente...
Já tinha visto agum dos teus trabalhos naquele site português de fotografia. E nesta fotografia reconheci logo de quem era. A tua abordagem é muita própria e uma expressão profunda. Isto é fotografia.
Aproveito para convidar-te a ver algumas das minhas fotografias e gostava de um comentário teu sincero, talvez tivesse pistas novas.
Abraço
António Araújo
Antonio Araujo , August 13, 2002; 09:17 P.M.
This image deserve to be photo of the week.
Very goooood.
MANOLIS DIMELLAS , August 14, 2002; 06:27 A.M.
thank you for the fotos.....
Jeremy Smith , August 14, 2002; 10:33 A.M.
Umm, great photo, but why is there a Backstreet Boys song file attached to an above comment? It leads me to another question: was that really coffee that I just finished drinking?
David Stanton
, August 14, 2002; 02:56 P.M.
marc
sorry dont agree with mark i think the dark base of picture holds the picture in and gives it shape, this is a top pic for me
Paolo Cozzaglio , August 15, 2002; 06:33 A.M.
Nana
Excellent portrait! It's so sensual in this light... Brava!
Detlef Klahm , August 16, 2002; 09:51 A.M.
love how wet the skin looks ( was she just wet from the water or did you use oils?)...perfect image!
Maarten van Hoven , August 26, 2002; 08:04 A.M.
Venkat Iyer , August 27, 2002; 12:53 A.M.
striking
Pierre Lewis , September 11, 2002; 05:33 A.M.
Sensual and intense, magnificent.
Robert Stewart , September 14, 2002; 07:33 P.M.
Wow
I would like to see a little more in the forehead area, but the tight crop works nicely. Bravo!
Claude Gauthier , October 22, 2002; 09:32 P.M.
Great composition
Love the overall effect. Find that the dark area on the lower left comes a bit to abruptly.
Robert Tilden , November 14, 2002; 12:17 P.M.
Music and Artistic Harmony
Can't top the Back Street Boys music. What a great idea to post music! I think this photograph is on the cutting edge; a work of art in black and white photography that can't be achieved with painting.
JORGE ALVARADO , November 23, 2002; 10:00 A.M.
I agree with Eliot, this a great shot.
Palmi Einarsson , January 04, 2003; 01:49 A.M.
Bob Douglas , January 05, 2003; 01:27 A.M.
Nice, so beautiful
What can I say this is a gorgeous photograph.
Anders Persson , January 15, 2003; 02:50 P.M.
Lou Korell , January 22, 2003; 12:42 P.M.
Once again you have created a super image. I am a big fan of your work. I love black & white and you have certainly got an eye for the magic of B&W images. Nice job on this one, keep up the great work.
Raul Drechsel , January 31, 2003; 05:17 P.M.
Duane Edmonds , February 09, 2003; 12:29 P.M.
andrew mundroff , February 18, 2003; 07:44 P.M.
Bert Armijo , February 28, 2003; 03:37 A.M.
If there's anything wrong with this shot, I sure can't find it! Superb!
Paul Ferraris , March 08, 2003; 09:30 P.M.
Carla Maio , March 30, 2003; 11:02 A.M.
O MEU FOTÓGRAFO FAVORITO
E A MINHA FOTOGRAFIA FAVORITA
Nuno Borges
, March 30, 2003; 12:14 P.M.
One will almost feel the thrust of the foating body as the force that is pushing the body into the light of oblivion. Wet to the point of hopelessness. Cold to the point of numbness. Rotten to unbearbleness.
Peter Smith , April 01, 2003; 08:49 A.M.
Margarita Draguijeva , April 11, 2003; 03:05 P.M.
no tittle = Sensuous....
i like this picture... it's so simple and pure...
greets :)
Paolo De Maio , April 24, 2003; 10:51 A.M.
Standing ovation
A standing ovation for you Nana.
Never seen a sensual shot like this.
Spectacular
Paolo
Matthew Anderson , April 24, 2003; 11:28 A.M.
One among many amazing shots. This, I think, is your best.
Lei GAO
, April 28, 2003; 02:34 A.M.
Could not remember how many times I came back to this image.
Steve Broyles , April 29, 2003; 06:07 P.M.
i've been staring at this for a few minutes trying to come up with a good way to comment on it.... but I can't. I like it very much. The texture of the skin and the inky-black hair and the curve of the lips. Very beautiful photograph of a lovely model. Excellent.
Robert Tilden , May 20, 2003; 04:15 P.M.
No Title
After looking at the other comments, why add just one more expletive? This image should be worth a lot. Do you sell your photographs? This isn't a nude or an erotic photograph but it is both. This is definitely cutting edge; one I carry in my mind.
Nile master , June 01, 2003; 10:44 P.M.
Nilemaster
Wow..I'm totaly astonished !!
Lilly Brand , June 09, 2003; 04:44 A.M.
Alain Martinez , July 16, 2003; 08:31 P.M.
Some advise to a beginer
True beginner here. Great photo. I see a lot of questions being asked but none answered. I would just like to know if you used a flash for this picture. Thanks
eric t. , July 16, 2004; 07:37 P.M.
peaceful...engaging...strong...submissive....all of those things and more...and a damn fine photo!
Ed Sorenson
, October 16, 2004; 01:00 A.M.
This is wonderful. One of my favorites.
Shamik Bag , December 30, 2004; 01:57 P.M.
A 7/7 is not doing justice to his photograph. This one does not belong to this world...will it be possible to tell how you kept the water dark? It'll be a pleasure to learn from you. Thank you so much
Nana Sousa Dias
, December 30, 2004; 04:17 P.M.
Thank you, Shamik! It's very simple...
This photo was made in the bathroom, at my apartment. I used a black cloth, fixed with tape, on the wall, falling in the water. The model lied in the thub, above the cloth. I used a Multiblitz head, with a softbox.
Shamik Bag , December 31, 2004; 02:43 A.M.
I'm grateful
Thanks Nana....you make it look so simple. But the attention you have paid to aesthetics and details surely took its share of your time. If ever I can get close to reproducing anything like this, I'll know who to thank. It is helpful people like you who keep p.net rolling.
Vicki Passmore
, December 30, 2006; 11:37 A.M.
7/7
S. M. , September 02, 2009; 07:08 A.M.
Contribute a critique
Send a free photo eCard
Photo eCards from photo.net are a way to email someone a photo.net Gallery photo
with your personal greeting or message. Send an eCard to your contacts to announce
your portfolio on photo.net. Send one of your own photos as an eCard to ask
another photo.net member to write a critique of it. Share photos
and portfolios that you have discovered on photo.net with your friends. Or
just send someone a greeting or message for
a birthday, holiday, or other occasion or observance.
The recipients will receive an email from
photo.net announcing that they have received the eCard, with a link back to
photo.net. When the recipients follow the link, the photo and your message will
be presented to them in a special eCard format.
The easiest way to see how eCards work and what they look like
is just to send yourself one!
photo.net eCards are free: by sending one, you are letting others know
about photo.net and the exceptional photographers on the site! We won't charge you
for that. The email addresses you enter into this form will be kept private. Send as many
eCards as you like, but please don't turn this feature into a spam-a-thon.